Messages to Prime Minister John Key
Over 2500 caring New Zealanders sent heartfelt personal messages to John Key asking him to support an immediate ban on cruel sow and farrowing crates. Great work everyone! Check them out:
Dear John Key,
Factory farmed pigs have suffered enough. Please support a ban of both sow and farrowing crates because they both break the law and are equally cruel. I am opposed to factory farming because...
a life of cruelty is no life at all! Let's make New Zealand cruelty free, mining free and all around environmentally friendly! Let's make our reputation for clean and green a reality rather than a myth!
- Alicia Haysom, 10:29 AM on Sat 17 Apr 2010
it is a cruel way to have them living.
- Kate Magazinovic, 10:17 AM on Sat 17 Apr 2010
I believe all living animals deserve the right to live without cruel treatment.I as a Mother and Grandmother of six will not and do not buy Pork that is not free range I think it is better all round for the animals and us to have happy Pigs.I am nt rich and i find it hard to not go for the cheaper cuts of Pork ,yet I will not give in.I feel sad and guilty about even thinking of buying even pork sausages and bacon too! now and remind myself of the suffering that maybe the pigs have gone through for bacon even!just in the name of $$$.STOP THIS PLEASE.Can't we all be more thoughtful of animals and suffering for us,can't we make their little lives a bit more comfortable while they are here on this earth ? they have intelligent brains too it is proven! they understand,pain and suffering like humans.
- Susan and Robert Fyall, 9:22 AM on Sat 17 Apr 2010
I have raised a number of pigs in my life, the first being a piglet I was given when I was 15, and she was just newborn. I know them to be very clever, and I have witnessed many examples of this including showing a clear sense of humour and a long and accurate memory. Given the opportunity they are clean animals, more so than many people. No creature deseves to be treated the way Government allows these "factory farmed" pigs to be. I urge you to do something to be proud of, take a stand to protect the helpless, and not turn a blind eye to this torture.
- Janet Hackshaw, 11:14 PM on Fri 16 Apr 2010
it is barbaric! Please help New Zealand to be able to say truthfully it is a wonderful place to live, because without respect for our creatures it is not.
- R Taylor, 11:09 PM on Fri 16 Apr 2010
these intelligent animals should not be confined to life of misery, frustration and suffering. Pigs are hugely intelligent creatures and there are far more humane ways of "farming" animals. Where is our national pride, of being a wonderful farming country where integrity and compassion are coupled with decency and practical application. I became a semi-vegetarian almost 5 years ago, because of the animal practices in our farming. To my shame, I still eat fish but am working on stopping that as well. Please consider my email and the welfare of a wonderful mammal, the pig. Thank you.
- Judy Prior, 10:27 PM on Fri 16 Apr 2010
I love animals. I think it is a question of ethics to breed animals like crop and vegetable. If it is necessary to breed pigs and other animals for people that like to eat them these animals have to live species-appropriate. Please close animal farms.
- Michaela Kayser, 9:23 PM on Fri 16 Apr 2010
it is a cruel practice which places profit over the welfare of animals. Pigs are proven to be as intelligent as dogs and yet we continue to treat pigs as sub-animal while we call people that treat dogs or cats in a similar manner criminals. Factory farming and the use of sow crates is corporate animal abuse and should be considered a criminal act! Profit should not be placed above the welfare of any animal - be that human, dog or pig! Aux animal!
- L. Moore, 8:05 PM on Fri 16 Apr 2010
Freedom Farms has shown New Zealand that free range pork can operate as a sustainable business. There must be a point where we say that enough is enough and that, just because pork farms have always operated in this way, does not make it right.
- James Lord, 7:55 PM on Fri 16 Apr 2010
it is simply wrong and cruel, it is irresponsible and unecessary.
- CRAIG WILSON, 7:46 PM on Fri 16 Apr 2010
it is a cruel and uneccessary practice. There are no arguments for this kind of treatment that are true. Please, please use your conscience and do the right thing.
- Monique Streater, 7:45 PM on Fri 16 Apr 2010
even though pigs are primarily farmed as a food source they have the right as a living being to be treated humanely and given a decent life before being turned into food
- Mike Dutton, 7:34 PM on Fri 16 Apr 2010
i hate u Labour kicks yous ass. leave those pigs alone and the fucken driving age LEAVE IT
- Jordan, 6:54 PM on Fri 16 Apr 2010
it causes unnecessary suffering and cruelty to the pigs that are in crates. Factory farming is an inhumane practice.
- Lyne Kearns, 6:51 PM on Fri 16 Apr 2010
It is fundamentally unnecessary. The torture is unncessary and the environmental cost to the communities surrounding the 'farms' is unnecessary. If consumers can't afford to pay the whole and true cost of eating pork then they can't afford to eat pork. Pork is not a necessity it is a luxury.
- Natalie Jones, 6:51 PM on Fri 16 Apr 2010
it is cruel, inhuman, unfare to any living being, animal or otherwise. These animals (Pig) have been proven to be very Intelligent Creatures and so I hate to think what they are thinking and feeling every day they live like this. I stopped eating pork etc.. after I saw the very first thing that came out about this. It is bad enough that we eat meat but even worse that we don't even have respect for the creatures that provide us the meat. I feel that all life is precious and even more so for those lives that help us live.
- Tina Court, 6:43 PM on Fri 16 Apr 2010
All animals whether farmed for food or kept as pets need fundamental requirements for their wellbeing. Confinement in Sow and farrowing crates is contrary to the code of humane treatment of animals and is no better than keeping a dog chained to a kennel all its life.
- Leonie Couper, 6:30 PM on Fri 16 Apr 2010
Cruelty to animals is obviuosly a terrible act. Not only is it against the law but it is morrally wrong. Ive heard under certain conditions these animals can become disorianted and even become insane, to the extent that they no longer express the normal behaviour of a healthy pig, that cant be right. Also..... I love bacon, and if these animals lives are gonna be resorted to these types of living conditions would that not make the meat lesser to what it could be if they had slightly more desirable living conditions. Just a theory.
- Andrew Brett, 6:20 PM on Fri 16 Apr 2010
...well, the opening statement should be more than enough reason for the banning of the sow crates etc.. However, better quality of pork products will surely come of this, which will undoubtedly raise our international profile and perhaps raise the bar for animal husbandry standards elsewhere. Nothing but good can become of this. We can't continue to become "New Zealand Corp." more and more - sacrificing our higher standards one at a time every time we could scrooge an extra couple of bucks.
- Tate Standen, 6:20 PM on Fri 16 Apr 2010
Pigs are highly intellegent and sensitive creatures. When I was younger my family raised pigs on our farm so I am familiar with their habits and needs. I can tell from observing the photographic evidence 'open rescue' have provided that the animals in these stalls are experiencing exceptional levels of distress. I am not vegetarian so wherever possible I will buy free-range meat, however I will NEVER buy factory-farmed meat again (chicken and pigs). I believe that the state of chicken and pig farming represents a slippery slope to normalisation of animal abuse in the name of profit and 'efficiency'. This country needs to carefully consider the welfare of its animals if it is to maintain its reputation as a first-class agricultural state, which has good standards of animal welfare and protects against major animal abuse.
- Helen Cox, 5:52 PM on Fri 16 Apr 2010
How well we treat the weak is a sign of our humanity (or lack thereof).
- Jessica Needleman, 5:45 PM on Fri 16 Apr 2010
it is inhumane and unnecessary, meat should cost more, because it does cost more to farm properly and fairly. The health implications of people eating less meat are also very good!
- Simon Hoffmann, 5:36 PM on Fri 16 Apr 2010
John Key, how would you like it if your wife was kept in a crate her whole life with barely an inch to move, suffering in silence!!! you wouldn't even do it to a dog, it would be illegal, so why do it to the pigs!! come on John, make a difference, i believe in you, i voted national!!!!
- Charlotte, 5:26 PM on Fri 16 Apr 2010
it deprives pigs of freedom of movement which no animal should be deprived of, especially animals such as pigs which are known to be highly intelligent, at least as intelligent as dogs. To impose such confinement on such an animal is obviously cruel and unnecessary. If we, as a society, are going to farm pigs as a source of food, the least we can do is to show them enough respect to ensure that they live their lives in humane conditions. I ask that you do everything in your power to help initiate a change to pig farming with humanity and compassion. Thank you.
- Gavin Hanson, 5:25 PM on Fri 16 Apr 2010
it is going to make pigs' lives more bearable... They are being bred to die but please; let's make their short lives more enjoyable :o)
- Vlasta Wilson, 5:20 PM on Fri 16 Apr 2010
It makes no sense to inhumanely farm meat. Since becoming aware of this issue, i will no longer eat any pig meat not freedom farmed. I beleive a lot of consumers are the same. Some however are still tempted by the cheaper prices. We need to remove the option. It is disgusting to treat animals this way.
- Liz Hargraves, 5:16 PM on Fri 16 Apr 2010
it is inhumane and there is no need to treat another living creature like that.
- Kara Bradley, 4:48 PM on Fri 16 Apr 2010
they don't deserve to suffer just because we want cheap meat. It is inhumane and disgusting that they are kept in such appalling conditions and they deserve a good life.
- Rebekah Stirling, 4:47 PM on Fri 16 Apr 2010
its beyond hell for these animals, just not pigs but other animals in this world that you should be aware of and wanting to make a change. Heres a very real example for you...pig farming may seem like a dream come true when you compare it to this inhumane act on animals in china, but if we dont change how we farm our animals today, we to could end up ending up like china with digusting animal cruelty commited on piglets and pigs. When undercover investigators made their way onto Chinese fur farms, they found that many animals are still alive and struggling desperately when workers flip them onto their backs or hang them up by their legs or tails to skin them. When workers on these farms begin to cut the skin and fur from an animal's leg, the free limbs kick and writhe. Workers stomp on the necks and heads of animals who struggle too hard to allow a clean cut. When the fur is finally peeled off over the animals' heads, their naked, bloody bodies are thrown onto a pile of those who have gone before them. Some are still alive, breathing in ragged gasps and blinking slowly. Some of the animals' hearts are still beating five to 10 minutes after they are skinned. One investigator recorded a skinned raccoon dog on the heap of carcasses who had enough strength to lift his bloodied head and stare into the camera. Before they are skinned alive, animals are pulled from their cages and thrown to the ground; workers bludgeon them with metal rods or slam them on hard surfaces, causing broken bones and convulsions but not always immediate death. Animals watch helplessly as workers make their way down the row. BACK GROUND Undercover investigators from Swiss Animal Protection/EAST International toured fur farms in China's Hebei Province, and it quickly became clear why outsiders are banned from visiting. There are no regulations governing fur farms in China—farmers can house and slaughter animals however they see fit. The investigators found horrors beyond their worst imaginings and concluded, "Conditions on Chinese fur farms make a mockery of the most elementary animal welfare standards. In their lives and their unspeakable deaths, these animals have been denied even the simplest acts of kindness." LIVING HELL On these farms, foxes, minks, rabbits, and other animals pace and shiver in outdoor wire cages, exposed to driving rain, freezing nights, and, at other times, scorching sun. Mother animals, who are driven crazy from rough handling and intense confinement and have nowhere to hide while giving birth, often kill their babies after delivering litters.
- sophie moir, 4:45 PM on Fri 16 Apr 2010
Animals are not our slaves, all animals have a 'right to a life' one with dignity and without cruelty, we are their guardians not their masters.
- melanie, 4:35 PM on Fri 16 Apr 2010
it is wrong!! What makes humans think we own the earth and every living creature on it. We do not have the right to torture pigs for nearly their entire existence. Their lives already revolve around being a meal for us humans, but they deserve to at least have a decent and natural life. We would never think it OK to treat humans in this way, such as in jail (but maybe we should as those people have actually done something wrong). Pigs haven't and they don't deserve to suffer the way they have been anymore. As New Zealanders we need to stop this cruel practice in our country and take action.
- Gina Crawford, 4:31 PM on Fri 16 Apr 2010
Pigs are animals and dserve to lead a healthy life. Put yourself in their position, it is just so wrong!
- jennifer, 4:25 PM on Fri 16 Apr 2010
SAVE THE PIGS!
- Matthew Grainger, 4:24 PM on Fri 16 Apr 2010
I know you're a great guy John, please help do something about this!
- Michele Grainger, 4:22 PM on Fri 16 Apr 2010
Dear John Key, Please have a law to stop this barbaric and cruelty to the pigs in the stalls. Pigs are intelligent animals and make good pets. They also feel pain and depression confined in the stalls for the rest of their lives. How would the farmers feel confined in the stalls for a month. They would start yelling their heads off. Please have compassion for the pigs and release them from the torture and allow them to run in the paddocks. Other countries judge us and most think Kiwis are fair minded, then please stop this cruelty now. Not next year but this year, and please have a talk with the minister of farming and say that the majoruty of Kiwis are against this cruelty to pigs and also hens Animals have feelings and feel pain and so do hens so please put an end of this cruelty.Thank you for your time reading all the letters and we hope that the end is in sight for the pigs and hens. Yours faithfully, Helen Butt
- Helen Butt, 4:20 PM on Fri 16 Apr 2010
Animals are far more intelligent than we give them credit for! I have loved animals all my life and it literally breaks my heart when I see how some people can treat them! I eat meat but I would never treat an animal - or human being like this!
- Melissa Grainger, 4:19 PM on Fri 16 Apr 2010
What we do to others, we do to ourselves.
- Becky Turrell, 3:53 PM on Fri 16 Apr 2010
U already know it is wrong and why. Most N.Zers do not want this to continue any longer. U have the Power to stop this cruelty NOW, not in 2 years or 5 years or whatever...BUT NOW!!! U and I get to walk around every day, these pigs have to stand in a small crate where they cannot move every day and every night. Do the right thing and life will support u. It's as simple as that. I am waiting and I am watching to see what u do. Please do what is right. Regards Sarah.
- Sarah Hicks, 3:52 PM on Fri 16 Apr 2010
Pigs are living creatures who feel pain and deserve better treatment. If New Zealanders are going to be eating pork the least we can do for these animals is give them a happy life. Its just common cruelty.
- Emily Haywood, 3:51 PM on Fri 16 Apr 2010
it is simply hideous the way that pigs are treated. we are better than this and we have a chance to help change it. YOU have a chance to help change this.
- elsa , 3:51 PM on Fri 16 Apr 2010
I find the way that we treat animals disgusting. First and for most I worry for the animals. Pigs are intelligent animals and these farming practices cause deprecation and unnecessary psychological suffering for them. Looking at the footage form with in farms in New Zealand I am shocked at how sad the eyes of the animals are and am startled by the frustration that they are obviously going on in there lives. These practices also cause the pigs to cannibalize each other and this is apparent in the footage that has been shown needless to say this worry's me for obvious reasons. My second worry is what will happen to people. What will the health impacts of eating this pork do to them? Logic says that if you put unhealthy food in to your body then unhealthy things will happen to your body. After seeing what is happening in these farms I can not neglect the fact that this is not going to produce healthy food and it is not going to be good for people. My third worry is for the way that New Zealand is viewed by people from other parts of the world for allowing this to happen in our country. I don't think that I am a cruel person and am worried that people form outside of New Zealand will paint me with the same brush as these framers. I was proud of this government when you, John came out and said that you disapproved of this. The word you used was 'discussing' I agree with you and I hope that you will do something about this not just for me and for you but for everyone in New Zealand.
- Darcy Peacock , 3:47 PM on Fri 16 Apr 2010
they too have feelings and deserve a good life!!
- chelsea ryan, 3:39 PM on Fri 16 Apr 2010
it is cruel and inhumane to intelligent animals. In my opinion, it is also liable to spread disease within the factory-housed pigs and then on to the human population, so it is not only cruel to animals but also dangerous both physically and economically to humans. Please do your best to stop this. Thanks. Anthea
- Anthea Armstrong, 3:35 PM on Fri 16 Apr 2010
Dear John Key, You have the chance to be recognized throughout history as the man that changed the lives of thousands of suffering pigs in New Zealand. You have the power to raise the standards of animal welfare and leave a massive positive impact in the history of NZ. Change is needed now, before the morals of our country sink to the depths of self-destruction.What excuse is there to condone the cruelty of caging, intelligent and sentient pigs? Please stand up against the greed of some of the pig farming industry, and choose to instill Fair free range farming practice - so New Zealand will not continue to hide under a veil of shame and be at the forefront of the outdated cruel sow crate. Yours sincerely, Kelsi Joy Stayt
- Kelsi Joy Stayt, 3:33 PM on Fri 16 Apr 2010
NZ can do better. It's nothing less than a complete embarrassment to see images of these intelligent animals being kept the way they are, and to think our government doesn't have a problem with it. “The greatness of a nation and its moral progress can be judged by the way its animals are treated”. -Mahatma Gandhi
- Shelley Grace, 3:32 PM on Fri 16 Apr 2010
it is inhumane to keep any animal in such confined conditions. If field farming is not profitable or acceptable then why not think about pig styes as an alternative. Pig styes (a house and run) have been used successfully for many hundreds of years to rear pigs and litters, it is far more humane than farrowing pens whilst letting the farmer keep control. I am a meat eater but will not eat the flesh of any animal that is not humanely reared, so pork is not on the menu at my home or if I go to a restaurant I do not choose it
- Lesley Ramsey, 3:30 PM on Fri 16 Apr 2010
humanity and respect of animals should be put ahead of profits.
- Fabrice Baras, 3:26 PM on Fri 16 Apr 2010
Dear John Key, I know how important both farming and image are to New Zealand. Therefore, if we can raise the standards of pig farming to an acceptable level, it will not only abolish pig cruelty in New Zealand but raise the economic value of the meat produced due to the global trend towards humanism in meat production. We can't do much to help pigs globally, but there is so much that can be done nationally. Thank you for looking at this issue thoroughly. Yours sincerely, Angelique MacDonald
- Angelique MacDonald, 3:19 PM on Fri 16 Apr 2010
it is so obviously brutal. We know that pigs are as intelligent as dogs. Near my home town (Masterton), there is a pig farm, housing 10,000 pigs in artificial light, unable to move and exercise their normal behaviours. If it were 10,000 dogs kept in those buildings for the natural duration of their lives, what an outcry there would be. I wholeheartedly join my voice to the protest of so many New Zealanders against these inhumane types of farming. People get brainwashed, and their normal ethical reactions get worn down. This has happened to a greater degree in other countries where such things as feedlots for cattle are taken as the norm. Please, can we NOT let these sort of practices get a hold in this country. I believe most New Zealanders will welcome a strong stand on these issues by your Government.
- Robyn Bracey, 3:16 PM on Fri 16 Apr 2010
pigs deserve the respect as any other animal.. they have feelings and should be allowed to run free as well... it breaks my heart to know that pigs are being caged up like criminals as if they have done anything wrong but have not done anything to deserve such treatment..
- Rebekah Brittin, 3:09 PM on Fri 16 Apr 2010
we need to treat these lovely pigs with the respect they deserve. When they are farmed they rely upon humans to look after them. Who are we to mistreat them and then exploit them for their meat.
- Gina Matheson, 3:08 PM on Fri 16 Apr 2010
its heaps as bad for little pigs.
- Tom Grant, 3:06 PM on Fri 16 Apr 2010
its unnecessary, simple as that. I won't stop telling/showing people about the kind of cruelty pigs and other animals face for the sake of a few dollars saved. I have no problem boycotting any meat sold which supports inhumane conditions including bad living space and mistreatment from meat-workers. No-one should justify treating someone/something worse than a human being just because its of a different species. They're beautiful creatures just like we are and they deserve respect just like we do.
- Selina, 3:06 PM on Fri 16 Apr 2010
its not nescersary.
- Dan Clarke, 3:05 PM on Fri 16 Apr 2010
it is a completley unnecessary cruetly to these defenseless animals.
- Kat, 3:03 PM on Fri 16 Apr 2010
Please stop this inhumane treatment of very smart living creatures. People will support your decision. No one wants suffering.
- debbie Hahn, 3:02 PM on Fri 16 Apr 2010
it is unnecessarily cruel and callous method of farming which cannot be justified in any way. The arguments that it is the only way to effectively farm pigs are unfounded. For example there is plenty of evidence, including on many farms with pigs around the country, to refute the contention that mother pigs must be confined to farrowing crates because of their aggressive behaviour, and it is impossible to defend such practices as sow crates. Added to this is the business risk posed to this country by such blatantly cruel practices. As Peter Nielson of the NZ Business Council for Sustainable Development identifies, our overseas trading partners are overwhelmingly positive about this country in relation to various policies and practices including our approach to animal welfare. Peter goes on to warn that if we ignore the voices of the "quality conscious consumer" it will be to our national peril. I hope consideration for the intelligent beings that pigs are, plus the welfare of most New Zealand citizens will be put ahead of a few. Yours Sincerely Marianne Riley
- Marianne Riley, 3:01 PM on Fri 16 Apr 2010
Stop this horrendous farming! It is disgusting. if you condone it, you are disgusting!
- Matt Coldicutt, 3:01 PM on Fri 16 Apr 2010
animal cruelty is punishable by law. Why arn't you arresting the people who are abusing their rights as an animal owner. Would you arrest someone who harmed a cat for money? Yes you would. So why not create the law to save pigs? Respect for the animals!
- Caymen Beeby, 2:56 PM on Fri 16 Apr 2010
This is just so horriable, our house is pork free, come on and help these animals we need to be there for them.
- Leisa Rippin, 2:55 PM on Fri 16 Apr 2010
Don't keep the pigs in this horrible state! Thanks. This is serious! It is horrible.
- Rose Hansen, 2:52 PM on Fri 16 Apr 2010
animal cruelty is completely unacceptable and should be stopped immediately. thank you for taking this issue into consideration.
- emma, 2:51 PM on Fri 16 Apr 2010
the measure of a person is how they treat those who are less powerful than they are. We can't consider ourselves truly human until we stop inflicting pain and suffering on beings that have no way of fighting back.
- Stephanie Cairns, 2:50 PM on Fri 16 Apr 2010
even though you may think pigs are dirty and smelly (which I spose they are),they still feel pain just like any other living creature. It's an inhuman way to treat animals, you wouldn't allow parents to lock their children in a cage that is bearly bigger than themselves, so why allow people to lock animals, who feel and have natural instincts, up in one?? If you have any kind of heart you WILL stop this.
- Sarah, 2:45 PM on Fri 16 Apr 2010
Its horrible!!! PLEASE STOP THIS!! Ban it for good!!!
- Sarah Clarke, 2:45 PM on Fri 16 Apr 2010
animals deserve better treatment than humans.
- Kate, 2:42 PM on Fri 16 Apr 2010
it's a cruel and inhumane way to treat animals. No animal despite being farmed for food should have to have a life of suffering.
- charlotte, 2:38 PM on Fri 16 Apr 2010
it's despicable to think that we live in a country that projects a clean and green image, and yet these pigs are allowed to exist in conditions worse than squalor. The fact that we feel we can treat animals this way for nothing but pure profit is disgusting and disgraceful.
- Hannah Jennings-Voykovich, 2:37 PM on Fri 16 Apr 2010
it is unfair for innocent animals to have to be subjected to such poor standards of living.
- Sarah Hedley, 2:37 PM on Fri 16 Apr 2010
It is revolting that animals are kept in conditions like that for the duration of their lives- and all just to feed the masses cheaply and conveniently, with no regard to the animals, the environment, and those who consume these products. Its not just the pork industry that needs to change-its all industries which confine animals in such conditions. Please protect the animals that feed you, your family and Nz. We owe them a decent life.
- Zoe Sheffield-van Mierlo, 2:36 PM on Fri 16 Apr 2010
All animals should be treated with humanity and respect. Even if they are going to be eaten. We live in a country where there is adequte land that farmed animals should not be penned up. Economy over morality is not an option.
- Ryan Bogardus, 2:35 PM on Fri 16 Apr 2010
Dear Sir, Due to your religious following, pork being taboo, you you can not close your eye to the cruelity annd discusting conditions of farming pigs in New zealand. The human race has a lot to answer for in the treatment of defenceless animals. yuor's sincerely, Kevin M. Naylor
- Kevin M. Naylor, 2:31 PM on Fri 16 Apr 2010
it is cruel to be raising animals in such a way that they would be unable to function in nature. They become extremely agitated, deformed, and in some cases insane. They cannot move or do any of the things that pigs naturally do. It is a sad day when money becomes more important than welfare of anything living, and this is just another example of trying to justify horrific treatment of animals purely for profit. It is disgusting and should not be associated with farming in New Zealand, a country where we have managed to maintain reasonably ethical treatment of other livestock.
- Cass Goodwin, 2:29 PM on Fri 16 Apr 2010
this is so cruel and inhuman to these beautiful and innocent animals. They don't deserve this kind of treatment. They are very intelligent animals and being confined to these crates drives them crazy. Imagine you are the pig and what kind of life you would have if you were them. They are unable to turn around in these tiny, cramped crates that they live in their entire lives. They need to get out they are trapped! They need to stimulate their brains! Ban this kind of animal cruelty John Key.. please! This kind of thing is a shame to the nation. This is not the 100% pure image we portray ourselves as. Think of these beautiful pigs! Please!
- Jessie Hackford, 2:28 PM on Fri 16 Apr 2010
Mr Key I love pork but this is beyond the joke, I am a good kiwi guy but I can't in all conscious condone this treatment of these animals, I live in the country and we have farmed pigs before - please make the changes necessary Neil Clark
- Neil Clark, 2:25 PM on Fri 16 Apr 2010
it's simply disgusting. find a massive plot of land - add a few mud pits - and let them run free and live their short lives the way nature intended! there is no excuse for such blatant and unnecessary cruelty.
- Hannah Sedgman, 2:23 PM on Fri 16 Apr 2010
New Zealand has a reputation to keep both at home and overseas, as Minister of Tourism you should be aware of this. There are better options for our farmers than cruelty.
- Joe McCrory, 2:22 PM on Fri 16 Apr 2010
Mr Key I support the fair and humane farming of pigs in New Zealand, please pass some laws that will stop this cruelty. I have always been a meat eater but I will stop eating NZ pork that is farmed from pigs who are not treated in a humane manner and I will ask all of my friends to do the same and all the visitors I can who visit NZ I will highligh these cruel practices. I have seen the conditions these poor pigs are kept in and I want change please. Regards Juelle Hunt
- Juelle Hunt, 2:22 PM on Fri 16 Apr 2010
it's cruel and unnecessary. The meat industries do not need to treat animals in this manner in order to produce meat. I'm not a vegetarian but I refuse to eat meat from animals raised in factory farming, and I hope that the practice can be put to a complete halt.
- Ben, 2:20 PM on Fri 16 Apr 2010
It is not a humane way for us to farm pigs, just because they are animals doesn't mean that they don't have the right to a healthy and happy life.
- Marty Jones, 2:20 PM on Fri 16 Apr 2010
it is just cruel and not necessary. Lets stand up as a country and show we care.
- Lisa Roberts, 2:16 PM on Fri 16 Apr 2010
Pigs are intelligent animals and should not have to suffer.
- Maree Martin, 2:16 PM on Fri 16 Apr 2010
there are better options for farming in more sustainable ways.
- Leon Sullivan, 2:09 PM on Fri 16 Apr 2010
Sort it out mate, We don't need this BS going on in our Backyard!!
- Scott Carruthers, 2:07 PM on Fri 16 Apr 2010
there has to be a better way to breed our pigs. I cannot go along with stuffing a living creature in such a confined space and then say it is all right. I am happy to pay more for pork if I know the animal has been humanly treated and have in fact now started buying bacon this way. I have actually started feeling guilty for eating meat altogeather because of the way pigs and chickens are treated. I really feel it is time the government stepped in and stopped this barbaric practice. regards Ann Lamb
- Ann Lamb, 2:01 PM on Fri 16 Apr 2010
these animals should never have to go through this kind of torture and pain all for the sake of the meat on their bones. I believe everyone and everything should be treated as we would like to be treated. Teaching young children to be kind and respectful to animals and people would be a giant step in the right direction as these children will be the next generation to lead our country. I truly believe you would be making the right decision to help our animals by allowing them a greater quality of life before they ultimately serve their purpose. Thank you for time and patience as I know you'll have many more letters like this to read. Yours sincerely, Casey
- Casey Samaeli, 1:46 PM on Fri 16 Apr 2010
I feel it is an outdated farming process that New Zealanders do not want to have in place here. Many other countries worldwide have begun to ban the use of sow crates and it is now time for New Zealand to do the same. It also shows a lack of compassion on behalf of human beings to allow this type of farming to continue when there are numerous other alternatives. These animals are incredibly intelligent beings that deserve humane treatment so please show some compassion towards them and make the decision to ban both sow and farrowing crates.
- Samantha Crick, 1:41 PM on Fri 16 Apr 2010
It is unkind and inhumane to continue to mistreat animals for our own benefit. We are at a point in time where we can use other resources to obtain information and products without hurting innocent animals.
- Urshula Macleod, 1:32 PM on Fri 16 Apr 2010
its intorerably cruel, these animals cannot help themselves, but you can help them. Please do.
- Melody Voyce, 1:17 PM on Fri 16 Apr 2010
This is the wrong thing to do, and you KNOW IT. Not every single pig will get the quality of life every here is asking for, but if at a least a few do, at least we know we have tried.
- Kimmi Hibel, 12:55 PM on Fri 16 Apr 2010
Since we are going to kill these animals to eat, isn't it our right to make sure that they live a good life before do this! we need to respect our food more and where it comes from!
- robert carpenter, 12:54 PM on Fri 16 Apr 2010
Dear John Key, it disgusts me that animals are able to live in such inhuman environments. please stop this cruelty now and give the pigs some dignity before they die.
- rachel emmott, 12:49 PM on Fri 16 Apr 2010
Mr Key, I am appalled that food safety allow our food to be managed in this condition. Factory farmed pigs need to be abolished for our sake and for the comfort of the pigs. As a farmer we would be sued if we treated our stock like this. Where are the health and safety laws for pig farmers. Where is your public conscience
- Pauline Holden, 12:33 PM on Fri 16 Apr 2010
Pigs are intelligent animals so it seems terrible to keep them in horrible conditions that we would never keep other intelligent animals like dogs in. The undercover videos of pig farm conditions that animal welfare groups have recorded reveal severe suffering and unnatural behaviour. If we don't ban the conditions that cause pigs to suffer we are effectively condoning them. I, along with most other New Zealanders, am not OK with that.
- Emily Harris, 12:14 PM on Fri 16 Apr 2010
I'm not saying every pig should be free range, I just want minimum quality of life standards for pigs. Why should pigs suffer so terribly? There's no good reason! Please stop this cruel, cruel practice. Kindest regards, Emily Meese
- Emily Meese, 12:07 PM on Fri 16 Apr 2010
I do not believe in animal cruelty, I have seen footage of how the pigs are kept in cages which do not even give them enough room to turn around. I think this is sad and cruel especially on this animal which is so intelligent. Even though we all know that one day these piggies are going to end up on our toast as bacon or our dinner plate as roast pork I beleive these pigs deserve a better life while they are alive on earth and no one should have the right to take that better life away. And that is why I ask you John Key to stand up and fight for these pigs rights as they cannot do it alone and we cannot do it without you. get rid of the factories, Free the Bacon and serve us free Range only!
- Nikki Keeble, 11:49 AM on Fri 16 Apr 2010
Dear John Key, Factory farmed pigs have suffered enough. Please support a ban of both sow and farrowing crates because they both break the law and are equally cruel. I am opposed to factory farming because... it's an affront to the word humane. These intelligent and sensitive animals suffer psychological stress and boredom from not being able to display normal patterns of behaviour typical of the species, and that causing such intense suffering merely for economic gain is quite simply, morally wrong.
- isis graywood, 11:44 AM on Fri 16 Apr 2010
of both the illegality and the cruelty inherent in this activity.
- Megan Clayton, 11:42 AM on Fri 16 Apr 2010
it is cruel and unnecessary. Let animals breed and live in a natural state. Maybe more people could eat less meat, help the greenhouse gasses, be slimmer and healthier and we would need less animals.
- Lanell , 11:32 AM on Fri 16 Apr 2010
Just put yourself in a pigs shoe. They can't speak for themselves they can't protect themselves - it is up to us humans to put it right. This just can't go on, it's just WRONG on so many levels. Please do the right thing...thats all we are asking....
- sarah, 11:24 AM on Fri 16 Apr 2010
I'm vegan! Did you know that ham, pork and bacon come from piglets, not fully grown pigs? It's disgusting. I also want to take a moment here to talk about eugenics. I think the people of New Zealand should have to pass some kind of test in order to be able to have children. The test would include background checks on the potential parents, making sure they earn enough, don't have a history of voilence or heavy drug abuse etc. People with heart conditions or genetic diseases shouldn't be allowed to breed. This way we can better the human race as a whole, making our species stronger and completely eliminating child abuse. As for unliscenced births, there could be a simple procedure that could be done to every human at birth to prevent them from having children. This preocedure could then be undone when the pass the test and are allowed to have a child. Thanks
- Not a nazi., 11:23 AM on Fri 16 Apr 2010
STOP THE FACTORY FARMING OF ALL ANIMALS!!! IT IS CRUEL!!!! THINK OF IT AS YOU BEING LOCKED IN A SMALL CARDBOARD BOX ALL YOUR LIFE AND NOT GETTING OUT TO STRETCH YOUR LOU WOULDNT AND I KNOW IT!!!! SET THEM ALL FREE!!! PIGS, CHICKENS, AND NOW THE COWS THAT THEY ARE NOW HOUSING DOWN SOUTH!!!! DONT PUT THEM THROUGH THAT TORTURE!!!! They dont need locking in small boxes to breed or fatten. if you do it properley it can be done out in the paddocks. look at the normal dairy cows for example... we dont lock them in small restricting pens to make them produce milk!!! Think on that and set them free!!!
- Rob Lewis, 11:11 AM on Fri 16 Apr 2010
I think we should treat our animals with care for their welfare and I don't think this is being done with pigs and it is time for a change. The present proposals will limit the time that pigs can be kept in stalls and it is a good start. It is something that has continued because government and the whole country has allowed lax and irresponsible standards to prevail. It is uncaring to continue in this way, is shameful and doesn't reflect well on us as a people. Please can you use your influence and act now to assist new regulations to be introduced immediately and implemented within a year, to change this unsatisfactory situation.
- Denyse Kinraid, 11:05 AM on Fri 16 Apr 2010
its simply unethical and inherently cruel. I voted National and have in the past because I believe in the partys underlying principles including its commitment to sound enviromental economic policies. We have a code of welfare for cattle. We even have codes of ethics for lab animals lets see a decent one for swine. It is not enough to prosecute someone for feeding live kittens to a dog and yet allow the slow suffering and cruel treatment of pigs.
- Brendon Willis, 10:56 AM on Fri 16 Apr 2010
it is completely inhumane to be treating pigs this way. they supply food to us and we just make them suffer for our needs and wants. i feel that this is definitely animal abuse and needs to be stopped as soon as possible. New Zealand relies on pigs for meat greatly, so at the present time, thousands and thousands of pigs are suffering for basically no reason. Freedom Farm's is a perfect example of how pigs should be treated and a great alternate for the factory farmed pigs. please stop this suffering ad ban pig factory farms!
- Stephanie Ewen, 10:51 AM on Fri 16 Apr 2010
you would never let this happen to dogs. There are so many rules about the way you treat dogs, why aren't they enforced when it come to pigs. Pigs are actually smarter than dogs. Because they are't our household pets, it shouldn't mean that they are classed less of a species. They should'nt be treated this way.
- Shannon, 10:51 AM on Fri 16 Apr 2010
Its sick and inhumane.
- Chase Goodwin, 10:43 AM on Fri 16 Apr 2010
I have a doctorate in animal behavior and welfare. The methods currently utilized in factory farming of pigs in NZ do not stand up to basic animal welfare legislation. Legislation based on animals being maintained in humane conditions, practically and behaviorally. NZ likes to be viewed as a beckon for other countries in this field – e.g. our Great Ape legislation. Yet for our production animals we are falling behind. The government and farmers need to stop hiding behind misinformation (for financial gain) and make changes in standards for animal care that we can be proud of and stop animal suffering.
- Dr Melanie Vivian, 10:42 AM on Fri 16 Apr 2010
being a Vegan I value all forms of life - especially those who cannot speak for themselves. While you may not be against eating meat you can't possibly turn your back and pretends that this cruelty does not exist. It seems a shame that in New Zealand we ignore those who can't help themselves. Please help these defenceless animals who are very social, friendly and wish to live free. Animals should have the same rights are we do.
- Stacey Furse, 10:36 AM on Fri 16 Apr 2010
it is cruel for any living creature to be treated that way. I believe that animals have the same rights as humans to a peaceful life full of enjoyment. Locking pigs in sow and farrowing crates is completely inhumane and they simply don't deserve it. PLEASE ban sow and farrowing crates. Thanking you kindly in advance.
- Bard O'Shannessey, 10:31 AM on Fri 16 Apr 2010
It's just wrong. Hundreds of pigs are being locked up for the whole of their short life, never to see the sunlight. What happened to a 'clean, green New Zealand'? You can say that passing a law will ruin the economy, but this isn't some cycle path we're talking about. These are actually lives at stake here, yet you refuse to act. Think about it. Please do something. That's all we ask of you.
- Chloe Bangs, 10:30 AM on Fri 16 Apr 2010
Dear Mr keys . Animals get achey muscles just like humans do. On any one of your long distant flights to England; America or any number of the countries you have visited....you must have at times felt overwhelmed with your seating arrangement encaged confined space. You would have needed to get up and stretch, walk around for a while have a chat to someone and then return contented to your seat ...in reality you have more room to do this on a flight than a pig cage. Can you imagine the mental state of anguish for man or beast when put in such a confined space for such a long time...This has to stop!. It's just cruel! For the sake of Pigs and any other creature of this world who suffer. 'Make a stand'!....Who is beleiveable when they ignore the suffering of those creatures great or small right under your own nose. It's just not right...!!!! Respectfully Donna Bartlett
- donna barlett, 10:28 AM on Fri 16 Apr 2010
this is NOT the way forward for human kind or the planet. You have an amazing opportunity to bring positive change for the benefit of all of us John! Embrace your opportunity! You were born to contribute to the evolution of humanity and I have faith in you. Rock on! Yours sincerely Melana Flay
- Melana Flay, 10:26 AM on Fri 16 Apr 2010
The people have spoken, not the farming industry. It is time to listen and stop putting profit before humanity. It is time to stop these barbaric practices,and enter the 21st century.
- Stephanie Rowe, 10:24 AM on Fri 16 Apr 2010
We do not need more needless suffering induced on these poor animals. They are like us, the grown pig has a understanding and liveliness of a 3 year old human child. Imagine how they might feel. Let them roam the farmlands, not couped up in a dark, dim factory. They need their open air and grass.
- Keszia Tyler, 10:23 AM on Fri 16 Apr 2010
IT IS plain cruel to keep any animals caged in these appalling cages with hardly any space.im sure as humane beings we wouldnt like to be accomodated like that and so just because they are an animals the prime minister mr.john key thinks its ok.well its not.they say they do this so the sow wont roll on her piglets,what a lot of rubbish.if the sow was outdoors in her natural habitant she would make her own nest for her babies and not lay on them and as far as her chasing the pig farmer off well shes probably getting even as to him caging her.i say it is nothing shorter than CRUEL
- linda jane, 10:22 AM on Fri 16 Apr 2010
how could you not be, they're stuck in the same dark place and position their whole life. It's not a life, they're sacrificing themselves as is. At least make the little life they are given worth while.
- Monique Hiskens, 10:20 AM on Fri 16 Apr 2010
it is an inherently cruel way to treat animals. You have seen the footage. It's appalling to think that 'farming' animals in this way is acceptable and legal in New Zealand. The famous Gandhi quote “The greatness of a nation and its moral progress can be judged by the way its animals are treated" could not be more pertinent. I love New Zealand, but I am deeply ashamed of the way we treat animals. So long as we continue to condone and legalise the abuse of animals we cannot claim to be a great nation or even a good one.
- Nichola Kriek, 10:17 AM on Fri 16 Apr 2010
It's 2010. Just because we're at the top of the food chain doesn't mean we should treat living things with the compasion of a Moro bar. We can do better.
- Gena Tuffery, 10:07 AM on Fri 16 Apr 2010
as human beings living in the 21st century, we like to pride ourselves on how far we have 'evolved' from our barbaric past. Now is the time to step up and PROVE that we actually understand what it means to live humanely and intelligently. Cruelty - and especially the wholesale apathy that allows cruelty on a commercial scale to flourish - cannot be tolerated by any society that supposedly values its role as moral guardian of what is right and ethical, clean and pure.
- Sue Howlett, 10:01 AM on Fri 16 Apr 2010
Pigs should be treated the same as humans, How would you like be kept in a cage your hole life and die because no one cares about you and your babies have no future except this cage! it CRUEL! THIS NEEDS TO BE STOPPED! im sure everyone on this page agrees with me! :)
- Chloe, 9:55 AM on Fri 16 Apr 2010
Dear John, It would be fantastic if New Zealand kept it's image of clean and green. Please put a stop to the cruelty of factory farmed pigs, so we can be known and seen as clean and green New Zealanders Thank you Mary Ann
- Mary Ann, 9:54 AM on Fri 16 Apr 2010
Do something.
- Stu Jones, 9:52 AM on Fri 16 Apr 2010
pigs have been given a bad reputation over many centuries, starting with the proscriptions in the book of Deuteronomy. People used the Bible as a justification for slavery and subhumanising other races. We are finally climbing out of that blinkered view, and now we should review humanity's arrogant attitude to animals. We happen to be the most powerful species on Earth - look how that power has corrupted us.
- Ian White, 9:49 AM on Fri 16 Apr 2010
I find it incredible that in 2010 we can allow animals to suffer in this way for the sake of money. SPCA needs the power to prosecute and I find it abhorrant that a law protecting the Pork Industry could be passed by our Government. I strongly urge you to take action on law change to stop this cruelty immediately. Thank you
- Owen Williams, 9:46 AM on Fri 16 Apr 2010
we should treat animals how we wish to be treated. they feel pain just like us!!!
- Joanna Gregory, 9:43 AM on Fri 16 Apr 2010
I think all animals deserve a decent life, these pigs are suffering and it needs to stop. -Kelsi
- Kelsi , 9:32 AM on Fri 16 Apr 2010
Any animal should be allowed to express their natural behaviours and have freedom to stretch their legs - there is no way a human would be treated this cruelly and pigs should be no different. Agriculture is the backbone of this country and New Zealand should set the standard when it comes to the welfare of all farmed animals. Just because we are small, does not mean we should not set an example for everyone. Please support this ban.
- Rebecca Harper, 9:32 AM on Fri 16 Apr 2010
I find the living conditions of pigs in piggerys extremely distressing. It is easy to put in the back of your mind if you haven't seen it first hand, however what animal should have to be confined in such a cruel way? When a dog travels on a plane for even 1/2 an hour, we have restrictions on how much room they have, they should be able to turn around fully and have room to stand. How is it then, that pigs can be confined to sow and farrowing crates for long periods of time and this somehow be okay? New Zealand is a country known as a country for doing things first. Lets be the country to ban these outright and actively promote how well our animals are treated. I personally have not eaten/purchased any pork since viewing the documentary last year with Mike King. I will not support the NZ Pork industry until something is done to give these animals the quality of life they deserve.
- Jess Howard, 9:29 AM on Fri 16 Apr 2010
I have always grown up with people saying "do unto others as you would like done unto you". Would you like to be put into the conditions that these poor animals are living in or let alone your wife giving birth to your children in those conditions. I certainly will not touch the meat knowing of the fact that they are sleeping in their own waste which will be seeping through their skin into their body. Anyone, after watching the documentaries, who can say that those animals are happy are sick people who have no soul let alone a heart.
- Anne Hunt, 9:25 AM on Fri 16 Apr 2010
I don't think pigs should have to suffer in an inhumane and cruel environment like those who have committed a crime in this country and deserve what they get. No pig deserves to be held for their entire life in a confined space when in their natural environment they are able to walk around freely and graze at their leisure. An unstressed pig is more likely to produce better in an open less stressful environment than in a crate! They deserve the chance to have the life like any other free range animal or pet - there is no excuse to be factory farming let alone one good reason!
- Chelsea Millar, 9:23 AM on Fri 16 Apr 2010
its hard enough being born to become someones breakfats side anyway, these animals deserve a healthy civil life while they are alive!!!!! free the pigs!
- georgie Lineham, 9:21 AM on Fri 16 Apr 2010
I believe it to be inhumanne and cruel. Studies have shown that children who are cruel to animals often go on to be violent as adults. Factory farming also has an unacceptably high environmental impact . Because of my concerns about factory farming, I have chosen to become vegetarian and I am increasingly moving towards a vegan diet. My teenaged daughter has chosen to be fully vegan for the same reason.
- Mojo Mathers, 9:07 AM on Fri 16 Apr 2010
we need to treat pigs and all animals in a civilized way.
- Dean Schneider, 9:03 AM on Fri 16 Apr 2010
Mr Keys, Mahatma Ghandi said "you can understand a nation by the way they treat there animals". And I wholly agree with him. I am appalled at the management of factory farmed pigs and to think some people think this is acceptable shows a lack in that person. I do not agree with veterinarians who accept this practice based only on a visual of the animal and say "they are in good health". I can look at all the offenders in our country and say "they are in good health" but that would not be a true. Do not discriminate between species, ask an "expert" in the field of holistic animal welfare for a true picture. So Mr Keys how will our nation be judged?
- Lynne Cooper, 8:56 AM on Fri 16 Apr 2010
it is unnecessary. There are some examples of piggeries that are able to keep pigs in humane circumstances and make a profit, proving that it is still an economically viable proposition. If you accept that we must take better care of these animals, why delay in improving these conditions, why not do so immediately? Any delay simply enables the industry to keep on doing what they are currently doing up to the deadline and then squeal about having to change. You know the old story…”it is to expensive, we are already doing the best we can…, etc, etc. The delay does not serve a purpose, get the job done now and improve the conditions of these poor animals and sort the industry out for its own benefit and that of our country.
- Helgard Wagener, 8:54 AM on Fri 16 Apr 2010
when we think back to how pigs would have lived if they were left to be wild, they would not be in crates their whole life and treated so badly, this is just cruel. Pigs need there space and freedom just like we do, to be treated with respect and love.
- Dani, 8:53 AM on Fri 16 Apr 2010
this is the 21st century, and we have come a long with research and technology, and do not need to be using out dated, barbaric practices on our animal friends. There are too many people opposed to sow crates that it is illogical for this cruel practice to keep going.
- Claire Robson, 8:52 AM on Fri 16 Apr 2010
even though many people and cultures depend on animals and their meat as their primary source of sustenance there is no reason for the animals to suffer and endure such cruel farming practices before their ultimate demise. Have a heart and please put a stop to this cruel and unneccessary practice. Farmers who make their livelihood off of these animals should respect their 'business" partners and treat them better. Afterall, if it were not for the pigs they slaughter, they would have no livelihood!
- Rebecca Polachek, 8:52 AM on Fri 16 Apr 2010
I can't believe how cruel it is. My flatmate visited a pig farm for uni because he is studying agriculture, he is a hardened farmer, grew up on a farm and happily will slaughter animals. But even he was so disgusted by the farm he saw that he stopped eating bacon and ham (one of his favourite foods). I really think our pigs deserve better than that! If my flatmate was so affected by it, I am sure that all NZers would be. I know I wish we treated our animals better. Please stop being so cruel to our pigs!!!!
- Jenny, 8:47 AM on Fri 16 Apr 2010
the rights of animals must be improved. humans hold the power. please show you care.
- arron clark, 8:24 AM on Fri 16 Apr 2010
The current pig farming guidelines are barbaric and cruel and need to change urgently. Please, please, please make changes to ensure that farmers CANNOT use farrowing crates and sow crates. The farmers say that we won't have enough pork in the market if we don't use intensive cruel farming practices. Then so be it. I am currently happy to pay a premium for certified free range pork products and if there is less pork around, then so be it. Pigs are far too intelligent to be kept in these revolting conditions. New Zealanders don't want to see farmers profiting from these dreadful farming practices. And we don't need cheap pork badly enough to warrant this level of cruelty.
- Andrea Bruce, 8:23 AM on Fri 16 Apr 2010
Its disgusting, unnatural, and is making us look like the rest of the world with their cruelty to animals.
- Hannah Shearer, 8:14 AM on Fri 16 Apr 2010
I abhorr close confinement of any animal and pigs are no exception!
- Helen McCabe, 7:57 AM on Fri 16 Apr 2010
Pigs having feelings too. They are helpless, have no say in their life and rely on the goodness of humans to look after them correctly. They do not deserve to be stuffed into crates!
- Deborah, 7:51 AM on Fri 16 Apr 2010
it treats animals like they are machines, and they're not. We have a moral and ethical duty to treat animals well, and factory farming has never and will never treat animals humanely. Pigs are wonderful creatures, and I simply refuse to eat pork products until I know that they are treated humanely by ALL farmers in New Zealand.
- Dawn Walter, 7:50 AM on Fri 16 Apr 2010
although I do not profess to know anything about pig farming & its' ability to show a profit, I do know about the basics of humanely keeping an animal on my property. eg: horses, dogs, cats, sheep etc. It is not rocket science to see that these pigs (or any other animal) are caused gross discomfit, & it would be an easy fix but for the money involved. For some reason that I fail to understand, pigs (especially sows) are ALLOWED to be legally kept in such narrow confines for LONG periods of time in tortuous crates. How can this happen in NZ? I realise that we have to farm & kill animals for their meat, & I have no problem with this, BUT, I do expect to be able to rely on government controls to keep them from suffering in order for us to do so. I have been let down in a way that I do not want to be a party to, & I no longer eat pork or bacon that is farmed in this way. If a person was keeping dogs or domestic animals in an inhumane environment, the practice would be stopped immediately & possibly the animals removed from their care. Why then is the practice so different for pigs, who are very intelligent animals? SHAME on us all for letting this practice continue.
- Brenda Allen-Baines, 7:35 AM on Fri 16 Apr 2010
John, every morning i go out and feed my wee piggy (shes huge actually) prudence, she runs up to me and snuffles and snorts i couldnt imagine her in a crate....please ban all crates and confined spaces for thee gorgeous creatures...
- lynda HEBDEN, 7:30 AM on Fri 16 Apr 2010
It is not natural for pigs to be locked up all day and night. People are now opting to buy free range eggs verus Battery farmed eggs, i think this is because the public is being made aware of how cruel confining animals is. I live on a lifestyle block and i see how the pigs and chickens are when they are allowed to have the freedom of moving around and sunlight. NEW ZEALAND NEEDS TO SAY NO WE WONT SUPPORT THE CREULTY OF ANIMALS AS THESE PIGS ARE SUFFERING AND IT NEEDS TO STOP!
- Lana-Maree Foster, 7:26 AM on Fri 16 Apr 2010
I believe that animals have the same rights as humans to a peaceful life full of enjoyment. Locking pigs in sow and farrowing crates is completely inhumane and they simply don't deserve it. You have the power to make a change, to spare pigs from a cruel and tormented life. And please, don't eat pork from factory farmed pigs. The control is held by consumers, together we can make a change.
- Tiana Hancock, 7:25 AM on Fri 16 Apr 2010
noo animal deserves to be treated that way. If you were that poor little pig would you want to live in those horrible little pens, i dont think. All animals should be free range farmed. This is unfair treatment to innocent animals.
- Amanda Griffin, 7:24 AM on Fri 16 Apr 2010
I want to be proud of what our country produces, not ashamed. Change will benefit the pork industry as it will differentiate NZ pork as a better option. Thanks for considering this important legislation change. kim
- Kim Mundell, 7:18 AM on Fri 16 Apr 2010
animals think and feel. Personally, Prime Minister, I don't like pigs, but that doesn't mean I approve of their suffering. Please do what you can, sir, because we loose part of our humanity when we allow cruelty to animals of any kind. Thank you and God bless you and your family, as you lead our nation. Respectfully yours Heather Naomi Andersen
- Heather Naomi Andersen, 6:54 AM on Fri 16 Apr 2010
it uses methods (for profit) that are cruel. In addition,becuase of the filthy and over crowded conditions pigs are forced to live in they are fed antibiotics, which get into our food chain and reduce the effectiveness of these vital drugs. Factory farms of pigs in the USA, Canada and Mexico were resposible for the swine flu pandemic last winter. Humans got off lucky that time. Industrial pig farming would not be so profitable if those involved had to pay the downstream health costs of their business practices.
- Ellen Dunckley, 5:40 AM on Fri 16 Apr 2010
New Zealanders are better than that, our reputation in the world market should be better than this. In so many ways we have shown ourselves to be world leaders, this is just one small way that we can show our clean, green image in our farming practises to the rest of the world. We have it in our dairy industry so why should our pork industry be any different. I understand that they are animals and will eventually end up on the dinner plate but should they live in these conditions as well, as we are farming them, should their short lives that they have on the planet (knowing how they are going to end up) at the very least be in some comfort and shouldn't we as the consumers demand some sort of humane conditions for them??
- Michael Blockley, 5:29 AM on Fri 16 Apr 2010
As someone that cares about the wellbeing of all animals, I believe sow and farrowing crates should be banned. Animals are voiceless and I would hate to see New Zealand take advantage of this unnecessarily. As a first world country I would expect New Zealand to treat all living creatures with respect. To put profits before the wellbeing of vulnerable animals is barbaric.
- Jessica Tasman-Jones, 5:27 AM on Fri 16 Apr 2010
If someone had a dog living in a kennel the size of what they keep the pigs in, the spca would be over to your house straight away investigating to find out why you are keeping your dog in such horrible surroundings. Why is it ok to do this to pigs? Just because they get slaughtered for meat doesnt mean they cant have a good life before that happens.
- Julia Dempster, 3:49 AM on Fri 16 Apr 2010
there is another way. We don't need our pigs to suffer just for the sake of economics. People who claim that pigs need to be kept in crates for there own protection are clearly wrong because frre range pigs are reared successfully. Please change the law to protect these animals. I am not some freak who is against farming animals of any kind I just think that we must do it as humanely as resonably possible.
- Jeremy Barker, 3:47 AM on Fri 16 Apr 2010
HELP PIGS!
- NEKANE, 2:54 AM on Fri 16 Apr 2010
animal cruelty is inhumane! PLEASE ban sow and farrowing crates. Your conscience will thank you for it. Thanking you in advance.
- Pat McElroy, 2:53 AM on Fri 16 Apr 2010
from what I have seen in the pictures it is cruel even barbaric. I urge you and your Government to outlaw these cruel farm practices in line with other countries that have already wised-up. Thank you. Lindsay Best
- Lindsay Best , 2:01 AM on Fri 16 Apr 2010
No living thing should be raised in a cage,who are we to decide such an awful fate for these poor animals,all you'd have to do is go to one of these places and see for yourself,look into there sad eyes,it would make you change your mind for sure,eyes are the windows to your soul and these poor animals are screaming out for help,there souls go to the same pl we do,you should treat all living things with respect and dignity and if you don't what sort of Human Being are you?????????
- Jewel Cole, 1:36 AM on Fri 16 Apr 2010
I'm a meateater from farming background. But there is a difference between a farmer, farming animals for meat, and being outright CRUEL. A compromise is needed. Could we consider starting with a rule regarding space an animal may be confined in? I understand that this will be a major cost to Pig Farmers in NZ. That this change could make you unpopular. But this footage also wrecks NZ's clean green image. Please I beg you, be brave and make a change to the living conditions of farmed pigs in NZ. Please John Key, this change is within your grasp. TeAra Dirkse.
- Te Ara Dirkse, 1:34 AM on Fri 16 Apr 2010
every living being, whether pig, human being, or our dear pet, every one is the same as you, Prime Minister,in that they feel pleasure and pain and seek happiness whilst trying to avoid pain and discomfort. These are innate instincts and we can easily recognize them. While we clearly see this obvious reality, how can we be so ignorant and cruel by causing these poor animals to suffer intensely in these crates? Please have compassion for pigs and employ an immediate ban on sow and farrowing crates. Yours Sincerely Olivia Stevenson
- Olivia stevenson, 1:01 AM on Fri 16 Apr 2010
different standards were enforced for other farm animals. Why should just pigs suffer, especially as they are highly intelligent animals? Please take the time to think this over.
- Claire Duncan, 12:37 AM on Fri 16 Apr 2010
it is disgusting and we as humans should not have right to put any living creature through so much grief,pain and depression. All i can say is that its not fair and have you seen the impact on the lives of these pigs by these types of farming.... watch please http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WBoKKjscJQM please put an end to the suffering of these animals from Julian Carr
- Julian Carr, 12:34 AM on Fri 16 Apr 2010
Tena koe Mr Prime Minister, Please take a minute to consider the welfare of the animals involved in this travesty. I, and many of my colleagues are saddened by the current state of affairs and plead for a swift amendment. Naku noa, Angeline Richards
- angeline, 12:22 AM on Fri 16 Apr 2010
It is proven that pigs are as intelligent if not more intelligent than dogs, If dogs were treated in this manner the perpetrators would be heavily fined and possibly even recieve a jail sentence. There would certainly be a huge puplic outcry, but because pigs are seen as a food source rather than an intelligent creature with the same rights as any to a life of dignity and respect, farmers have been allowed to get away with this barbarism. PLEASE HAVE THIS STOPPED. Thankyou Helen
- Helen Ferris, 12:02 AM on Fri 16 Apr 2010
it keeps animals in conditions which are inhumane. Animals are not objects. They are sentient beings who have as much physical sensitivity and capacity for fear, boredom, stress and contentment as ourselves. Animal behaviour scientists increasingly emphasize this. As animals, we all need to be able to express our natural behaviour; most basically, to freely move our bodies and use the senses and faculties we possess. For pigs as for persons, extreme physical confinement brings mental and physical trauma. Please use your power to help change cruel farming methods, which are based on outmoded and discredited attitudes toward animals.
- Kristen Wineera, 11:25 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
your children would be against it! xo Summer & Gypsybelle Wadsworth
- sophia, 11:24 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
They deserve better then this. It would be horrible to keep letting this go on. Would you let dogs live in small cages for there whole life? NO. They are more intelligent then dogs and make great pets. Factory farming pigs is just a cheap and cruel way to make money. Its unnatural.
- Bonnie Smith, 11:24 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
it is cruel and unnecessary to farm this way to achieve a good product. WHAT HAPPENED TO GOOD OLD FARMING..
- karen , 11:19 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
I have a pig as a pet on our farm and understand what amazing and intelligent these animals really are.It is cruel, evil and wrong to keep them in tiny cages, they deserve to have a quality life. Please help them!
- Ruby Chapman, 11:12 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
I have been living overseas for a while now and it’s always made me proud to say I’m from New Zealand because our country is often at the forefront of modern thinking and breaking the mould when it comes to issues such as this. It would not only be incredibly inhumane but also extremely shameful for us to allow the use of sow crates to become common practice in New Zealand. We as a country are better than that, and I hope you sincerely consider all these emails of protest at such a cruel and unnecessary practice. I want to be proud of being a New Zealander and I hope you help me remain so.
- Claire Loader, 11:06 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
it is beyond cruelty and any government who stands for it as will have have a lot of explaining to do in the future...
- Alexandra Speedy, 11:01 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
not enough people understand the needs of animals, or appreciate that they are real, feel pain and misery. No animal should be born or raised in such appalling circumstances. Not for our food consumption or any other reason.
- Sharyn Tyler, 10:56 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
pigs are more intelligent than dogs. They are loving and loyal, and make great pets. If we wouldn't put our dogs in these pens, jammed in for their whole lives, why do it to pigs? If you would just give pigs a chance, I know you would love them. Please go out to some farms where they are free ranged, and meet and pet them. You will change your mind, I guarantee. Please - the law says "no cruelty to animals". But, Mr. Key, isn't there a moral law, that is even more important? Look to your conscience.
- Kath Worsfold, 10:53 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
animals are living beings who feel pain and suffering both physically and emotionally They have strong family bonds with their fellow creatures and other animals and human beings. A pig is said to have the intelligence of a two year old child equivalent to a dog Allowing animals to be kept in such barbaric conditions dehumanises those people who have to work there And there is evidence that cruelty and abuse to animals goes hand in hand with cruelty and abuse to children So please use your power to stop this terrible suffering of animals in your country
- Patricia Lessells, 10:50 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
Research has shown pigs to be intelligent and, more importantly, highly social animals. There is no valid reason for pigs to be kept in the conditions in which they currently are. Please do something to ease their suffering.
- Kate, 10:50 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
its disgusting and wrong how they treat animals how can anyone treat animals like that they are living breathing creatures aswell the deserve freedom to be free range not locked up like prison i hate seeing animals treated like that im an animal lover myself and is sad to see them like that and it brings tears to my eyes to see them treated like that. Not to notice that behaviour people would have to be absolutely heartless so please stop this abuse to animals and ban this nonsence, Thankyou
- Daniel, 10:49 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
it is cruel and unnecessary to farm this way to achieve a good product.
- Pat Boston, 10:48 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
PIGS ARE MEANT TO BE VERY INTELLIGENT, CERTAINLY NOT DUMB, SO I HATE TO THINK THAT THEY ARE KINDOF AWARE OF THEIR SUFFERING. Thanks for listening! Take care. Kindest regards from Jillx
- Jill Autridge, 10:43 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
it is an extremely barbaric practise. Animals have the right to move freely and be treated with respect.
- Julia Rainsford, 10:37 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
As an Auckland University student studying political studies, sociology, management and ethics I find it hard to understand how a practice like factory farming socially advances our society or positively adds to our national identity. As the tourism minister you must evidently see how factory farming impacts detrimentally to our 100% pure image; how would the allowance of factory farming showcase our 'sustainable environmental practices' and 'innovative spirit’ at the forthcoming Shanghai Expo? Should we not be setting an ethical example to China, an economically dynamic country yet one battling with corruption and exploitation of people and animals?
- Jessica Woodcock, 10:35 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
Pigs are smarter than most people and animals are badass and should not be treated mean
- Hayden Walsh, 10:34 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
I was brought up on a real 'kiwi' farm, the way pigs should be treated, and eventually slaughtered. We are not America and we do not eat like America, therfore we should not eat like Americans. Please listen to us, the people of New Zealand who care. Its important. Warm regards Penny Reid
- Penny Reid, 10:33 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
the animals are treated as little more than machines and yet each one is an individual with a distinct personality. The use of these methods reflects very badly upon New Zealand and does nothing to strengthen our international reputation.
- Diane Smith, 10:22 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
it's inhumane allowing this to go on... just terrible what is happening to the poor pigs. they deserve a life too!!
- Cortley Spencer, 10:16 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
these animals suffer enormous distress just as a domesticated animal would suffer under these conditions. These living conditions would be deemed cruel and illegal treatment of a cat or dog but is inflicted on pigs in the name of profit. “The greatness of a nation and its moral progress can be judged by the way its animals are treated”. Mahatma Gandhi Sincerely Robyn Irons
- Robyn Irons, 10:08 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
pLease help the pigs (: i dont like how they are treated.They deserve more freedom :)
- Chanel Mou-hi, 10:06 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
noone would treat another human in such a way without punishment - and a human can at least tell us theyre hurting. An animal can't. Lets give them a voice Johnnyboy :)
- Hayley Swan, 10:04 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
I have taken a sacred vow to protect all sentient beings. In my eyes, you, me and the pigs are as worthy of consideration as each other. I trust you can't fail to see the sense in the wise counsel of the Dalai Lama, who implores us to 'be kind whenever possible, it is always possible'. In this case, it shouldn't be so hard.
- BN Trudgeon, 9:58 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
in the year 2010 we have advanced in the way we farm and look after farm animals that the confinement of sows for breeding purposes is long outdated. I was from a farm and the pigs roam free in a fully fenced paddock and dad had no trouble at all with sows fighting or hurting their young. They are lovely mothers!! Please look after the 'mothers' of our planet be they human or animal. I trust you will action change this year and not leave it to drag on for years to come. Please make change for our beloved pigs.
- Jennifer Stuart, 9:49 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
crate farming does nothing to help our clean green image, but most importantly, it's not humane. It is a disgusting and cruel way to raise these beautiful animals. Free range is the only way to go, happy pigs, happy future.
- Rachel, 9:46 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
It's cruel to pigs.
- daniel turner, 9:34 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
factory farm pigs is so wrong i live on a sheep and beef farm and know one would ever think of putting them in crates and sheep leave there lambs all the time
- Amber Gwynn, 9:32 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
it is unnatural and very cruel and environmentally destructive. New Zealand is thus losing her reputation for being clean and green.
- Judith Kasputtis, 9:30 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
it is blatantly cruel and does not allow pigs the basic rights they are legally entitled to - fresh air, dust baths, sunlight and grass. Pigs should not be subjected to the cruelty of crates because they are confined in minimal spaces with barely room to stand up without hitting their heads and can barely even turn round. This is most unnatural for any creature and does not fit with NZ's clean, green image. If we wish to retain that image we must abolish sow and farrowing crates forthwith. This cruelty goes against the principles of the Animal Welfare Code, which does not allow cats, dogs, rabbits, goats or donkeys to be kept in such conditions as for our pigs, and we should therefore not allow it for pigs. Please give your most valuable support to this vital matter and help our nation to abolish cruelty to pigs. Your support will be greatly appreciated, not only by myself but by hundreds of thousands of caring NZers. S M Bassett (Miss)
- Shirley Bassett, 9:25 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
There is simply no good reason to do it, and it's a terrible thing to do. I hope we can see some changes around here for the better.
- Aaron Croawell, 9:25 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
it's unnecessary and unpleasant and should be banned.
- Helen McLeay, 9:21 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
I do not think that we need to farm animals in this inhumane way, we are after all a civilised nation who is not desperate for its food sources. I can only imagine that this type of farming is being done to reduce costs in some way, but I believe that pigs should be farmed in a natural way and the consumer needs to pay the full and correct market cost it takes to do this. Reducing costs by treating animals in this fashion is not okay ever.
- Neave Ross-Wallace, 9:19 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
Pigs should be treated the same as chickens - think of our image to the rest of the world when we comprimise in our own backyard
- Curtis, 9:18 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
it's an obscene waste of humanity's potential. We are better than this. And it is ridiculously cruel to expose intelligent, charming animals to such obscenely horrific standards of living.
- Anna Krepinsky, 9:08 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
This method of farming is insane, how dare people treat other living creatures like this. Its all about money Mr Key nothing else, and its got to stop.
- Amy Wolland, 9:08 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
Pigs are intelligent animals and physically very close to humans. Why do we even need to eat them let alone keep them in small filthy cages to fatten them up first.
- A redstone, 9:02 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
it is time, that as human beings we show care and compassion to those that cannot speak for themselves.I urge you Mr Key, from the bottom of my heart, please support the ban of sow and farrowing crates.Thank you Mr Key, from myself, and those pigs that will have a better life when this barbaric law is changed.Kind regards, Pania.
- Pania, 8:56 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
intense unnecessary suffering is caused to the animals. It is ethically and morally wrong. 'The greatness of a nation and its moral progress can be judged by the ways its animals are treated.'~ Mahatma Gandhi
- Julie Weir, 8:55 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
no animal should be kept in conditions like that, let alone kept that way simply to add a few dollars profit and keep a few more pigs per farm. I grew up a farmer's daughter, I wouldn't see that done on my own property and neither would my father have done anything like these practices. There's enough land in our country for farmers to free-range all the animals they grow, this is just importing dirty practices from countries overseas that don't have our natural advantages of plentiful land and a heritage of looking after our animals well.
- Kerry Tankard, 8:54 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
how would you like it if when you were born you were told you would be put in a cage for your entire life (untill youre ready to be eaten) ravaged by sores in a crate thats so small you cant even turn around to see the other lil piggy behind you? NOT VERY NICE IS IT!!!
- Ben barton, 8:54 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
New Zealand to the rest of the world represents 'clean and green' '100% pure and natural' why would these images of our fair country allow this type cruelty to be condoned, this sort 'farming'is anything but natural or pure. Either we are false advertising our exports overseas or we are hypocrites. We are not asking for much, just for a little bit of humanity before their inevitable fate. Please consider our submissions Kind Regards Natasha Stewart
- Natasha, 8:45 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
we are living beings, pigs are living beings and if you wouldnt want to be kept in a sow or farrowing crate then they must be banned. its as simple as that
- kate thomas, 8:40 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
it is not fair on the pigs and they deserve the right to freedom like you give us. thank u ps. i think ur hot
- bonnie mckenzie, 8:40 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
it is cruel and inhumane. How can you look away from the little piggy in the picture without doing something?
- Jason Richards, 8:38 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
I cannot believe that this cruel method of farming is allowed to continue in this country. This is New Zealand for gods sake not some third world country. Pigs are a highly intelligent animal that at least deserves to farmed with some respect.
- Sarah McMichael, 8:36 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
animals deserve better. It's possible to farm productively without these cruel methods.
- Nathan Rushton, 8:36 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
... I think this sort of cruelty can be easily avoided. People are being blinkered when they need to see what mass meat-eating is doing to animals, to themselves and to the planet. If no crates means more expensive pork products then so be in, people can eat less of it or none at all. Regards Mary McCallum
- mary McCallum, 8:33 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
it is such a miserable life for those poor animals. What have they done to deserve such a life sentence? Once again it is exploitation of human power over living, breathing, feeling beings. Please put yourself in the pigs shoes? How would you feel if somebody gave you that life sentence for doing nothing other than being a human! I hope you can find it in your heart to do what you know is right! Thank you.
- Debbie Handisides, 8:31 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
As New Zealanders we should stand up for animal rights as well as a green environment
- sally, 8:27 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
it is an unnatural way to farm animals. It does not show any due care or respect for a living being. STOP SOW CRATES NOW! NO EXCUSES!
- Diana Morton, 8:25 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
it is a cruel practise, and pigs are living beings, that we need to protect (from ourselves). Pigs are very trainable, and the closest animal in intelligence to a human. Their skin is very similar to ours, and they are loving and kind animals.
- Joanna Bishop, 8:24 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
Its fucken disgraceful how you are letting these animals live like this, they have the inteligence of a 5 year old child. PLEASE HELP THESE POOR ANIMALS!!! NZ is supposed to be a developed western country that is clean and green, we have the worst international reputation for our treatment of pigs here. THIS IS TOOO CRUEL HOW CAN YOU SLEEP IN YOUR MANSION KNOWING THESE ANIMALS ARE CONDEMNED TO TORTURE FOR PEOPLES HAM LOVING. revoulting uneccessary cruelty
- sophie jardine, 8:18 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
it's hypercritical that we could persecute the same level of cruely if it were shown to any other animal. Pigs in sow crates cannot even turn around. Pigs have a natural instinct to 'nest', yet they are forced to stand on a hard and cold concrete surface. They are denied the privilege to engage in any form of natural behaviour. I find it disturbing that in NZ, we pride ourselves in having a 'Clean Green' image, when we continue to allow such cruelty to take place. Please stop this inhumane treatment of one of the earth's beautiful creatures.
- Jamie Himiona, 8:15 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
it is highly unfair for any animal to be kept in such a disgusting, horrible, restricted environment. Pigs or any other animals do not deserve to be treated like this. Please, please help them live a better life.
- Leanne Houston, 8:06 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
New Zealand is regarded as a country that cares for its environment. It markets itself as NZ Pure - we earn millions of dollars because of the integrity of this logo. Why we let not only pig farmers and now greedy dairy farmers jepardize this is beyond me! Once this image is lost - we all loose. Why does NZ not lead the way as we used to in environmental and animal care? Surely this also is part of good partnership in terms of the treaty also! This is not what kiwi's want in my opinion. Keep it GREEN John!
- Beth McEachen, 8:05 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
its disgusting the way the pigs are kept and handled.
- lyle innes, 8:01 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
I was told that in a foreign country, instead of putting Horses in dog meat, and eating Cows like over here, they put Cows in dog meat and ate their horses. The thought of us eating Cows horrified them, just like the thought of them eating Horses would horrify most of us. My point is that all animals should be treated with respect & care, even if they are doomed from the day they die. Because in my opinion, murdering an animal for just a meal, is horrifying. But putting it through a life of hell as well, is just disgusting.
- Alicia, 8:00 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
its extremely cruel, and terribly in-humane. study has proven that pigs do in fact feel pain, they also have emotions. no living thing should EVER have to be put through the the torture that these poor pigs endure. sow and farrowing crates dont allow pigs to behave naturally. they cant even turn around! the way pigs live is cruel and we need to put a end to it NOW.
- Astrid Watson, 7:59 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
we should be trying to treat animals in as ethical a way as possible. If we are going to farm animals, they should have as good a life possible while in our care.If they are killed, they should be killed in a humane way. Anything less is both a crime against them and diminishes us as a species. We don't have to use cruelty for profit and nor should we. Thank you.
- Peter Clayworth, 7:58 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
We are not here to dominate animals through cruelty, we are here to respect and protect them. In this regard we can also be good models to our children.
- Claire Payn, 7:54 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
inflicting cruelty on living creatures is unnecessary. Not all people wish to forgo meat however many are distanced from where their food comes from and would without a doubt be horrified to see the conditions in which these animals are kept. All animals deserve to be well treated even those bound for slaughter. Please listen to this reasonable request for a law to ensure adequate treatment for living creatures. Thank you
- Libby, 7:53 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
I simply can't abide animal cruelty of any kind.You are in a position to do something about it.I can't understand why our government is so slow to react to this sort of thing.I pray it is not a case of ignoring the facts for business sake.Please make a stand and help us ban the sow and farrowing crates.End these pigs suffering now.
- Paul Ferguson, 7:52 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
it is no way for an animal to be kept! Pigs are living creatures, not baby making pork machines. They are very unhappy living in the crates - let them free! The cruelty shocks me to the core.
- Helen, 7:50 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
it's all about greed and profit at the expense of innocent, intelligent animals who are kept in the most horrendous conditions. N.Z should be ashamed of supporting such farming practices - clean and green? What a joke. Those people involved with this have become desensitised to what's actually going on and so it's time for legislation to step in and ban this abhorrent treatment of sows.
- julie williamson, 7:35 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
it is unnecessarily cruel & not natural. It makes me sick to think that the meat I get from the supermarket comes from that background. We prosecute people who abuse animals & yet this is abuse & is allowed.
- Melissa Jones, 7:33 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
it's sick. Pigs are pets to some people. Would you let your dog or cat be treated like this? As lame as it sounds, I went to butterfly creek in Auckland last weekend, and realized that all animals have feelings. Even sheep - which are considered to be some of the most stupidest animals ever. This is not right. People should not be treating animals like this, it is extremely disturbing.. and for what?? a bit of meat? No. Mr. Key, this needs to stop. Please stand with us all opposing this sick sick thing. Thank you for your time, regards, Rebekah Carter.
- Rebekah Carter, 7:28 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
we are all born free, both humans and animals. And it is cruel to take freedom from any living being.
- Minnie Hayes, 7:25 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
it just shows how barbaric we are. There is no stoping the slaughter of animals however we all have a say in how we treat them when they are still alive. Pigs are highly sensitive creatures. They feel happiness, sadness, fear and they definitely feel pain. What right do we have to stick them in a crate no bigger than themselves with no way to move around. In New Zealand we pride ourselves on our farming of animals, our nuclear free stance, our green living and our good nature. How can we be proud of this. Do not disgrace us!!!
- Amber Johnson, 7:22 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
Animals are entitled to a life before we kill them. Where is the respect for what they give us. Please pigs have feelings and value their lives. What makes a great civilization great is how they treat the most vaneralble and innocent.
- Fleur Connor, 7:14 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
Please John Key stop this barbaric farming of our lovely pigs, they deserve to have a happy life before their ultimate destiny. Please John do away with these farrowing crates.
- Josie Heritage, 7:12 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
Isn't about time to start putting the welfare of our animals before the mighty dollar. Please show some humanity and ensure that the appalling practice of factory farming is brought to an end, you can do it, please try. Margaret McConville, Dunedin 15 April 2010
- Margaret McConville, 7:08 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
hi I am a dairy farmer and sum of the rules you people put on us suxs big time.... Just think for a minute where all the food comes from in this contry???? Yes I no Pigs are food but come on I am damn sure they don't need to be kept like they are.... And as for this pay more for pork or woteva if they were to roam free is aload of bullshit. Animals have feelings just like us and put yourself in there pens and see how you would feel????? Please Mr Key just think about it.... I think to myself treat our animals how we would like to be treated.And need I remind you that we charge people for crulty to animals why arn't we doing the same ova the pigs??? cause wot they are doing is cruel damn cruel
- Tania M Rowe, 7:01 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
It is unfair on pigs, restricting their space and therefore their ability to display natural behaviours.
- JOSh Foster, 7:00 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
Change this, everyone wants it to happen!!
- Hannah Owens, 6:58 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
We have a position of responsibility to practice good animail husbandry, while we exploit the animals as a resource we have a duty of care to ensure they are humanely treated. Pigs are intelligent animals who do not deserve to be cruely confined. It is unneccesary and only serves to line the pockets of wealthy farmers.
- Pauline Goetzlof, 6:37 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
I don't believe that animals should suffer for the benefit of humans - just so we can eat cheap meat. We have a position of responsibility to practice good animail husbandry, while we exploit the animals as a resource we have a duty of care to ensure they are humanely treated.
- Jesse Moriarty, 6:35 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
it is cruel and abhorrent. Pigs are highly intelligent animals that suffer horrifically in farrowing crates,and it must end. As New Zealanders we are so proud of our clean green image, but we should be ashamed of how we treat our pigs. Please Mr Key, let the suffering of these beautiful creatures end, and show them the paradise of NZ, that we as citizens experience. Thank you for your tme and consideration on this matter.
- Jo Templer, 6:29 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
it conflicts with our 100% pure image. It is unnecessary to be cruel to animals just to make a profit.If animals are kept in cruel and unsanitary conditions they are more likely to develop diseases which could be a risk to human health.
- Paul Callaghan, 6:29 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
Other animals enjoy the outdoors in New Zealand, why not pigs?
- Kerstina Jade, 6:28 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
it is clearly unethical by all measures of ethics. Your government has the opportunity to do something about this injustice, and if you do not act then the suffering of these animals is on your heads.
- Michael Brenndorfer, 6:25 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
It is cruel and horrible, pigs are so smart although do not have a voice of their own so we have to be the voice for them to stop this terrible treatment. Please help! I refuse along with alot of other people to buy pork now but if this is changed and the pigs are treated better than im sure pork sales will increase too therefore a benefit for both parties. Thank you for your time.
- Jessica Poynton, 6:15 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
to go down this route, would once again put paid to NZ's clean and green image. So far National have decided whaling is a good idea, mining in the national parks is a good idea, experimenting on animals with GE is a good idea... what next? Please ensure you do your best to ensure that pigs reared in NZ have a reasonable life, not an unreasonable one. People will pay more, even in these hard times, for humanely treated meat.
- Claire Insley, 6:15 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
no being should be subject to unjustified confinement, least of all when the sole reason is for profit. If prisons allow people who have committed horrific crimes to maintain their basic liberties, how can innocent animals who have committed no crime nor offence to anyone be justifiably subject to the appalling conditions of factory farming. These animals are not here by chance, they have been bred by farmers for profit. Therefore from birth they are destined to have their lives cut short to satisfy the taste preferences of New Zealand consumers. The absolute least we can do for these innocent beings is allow them as natural a life as possible, that they may enjoy in whatever way possible their time on this planet. The fact that these practices exist is despicable and an end to this treatment of pigs is overdue.
- Tess Munro Pedreros, 6:15 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
Dear John Please consider the unfair treatment of animalls in out pigeries and put through some laws to protect them.
- Bruce, 6:15 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
it is inhumane. There is no need to treat animals with such cruelty just because we will eat them as the end result. No animal has ever existed in such conditions in its natural state. It is damaging to the pig. It is damaging to us as people that we would condone this. We need to take a stand and ban factory farming.
- Clementine Presling, 6:13 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
it is inhumane. I can not believe that as a human being, you are allowing this to happen. It is disgusting. Please stop this. Kelsi Johnston
- kelsi johnston, 6:09 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
Pigs are intelligent creatures and should be treated with respect. Who are we to treat them so inhumanly. I feel very strongly about this.
- Jane Sears, 6:02 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
The pigs deserve better from human beings
- Des Cochrane, 5:57 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
making animals suffer for our own gain is simply disgusting and wrong,money isnt everything,if people want to eat pork then it should cost what it costs to give these animals some dignity
- tim, 5:56 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
pigs are extremely intelligent animals and I can only imagine the sort of life they endure stuck in a crate their entire lives and then slaughtered for their meat.
- Gillian Ashworth, 5:54 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
it is cruel, plus free range pork is much tastier.
- thomas mclean, 5:54 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
We're supposed to be civilised. This is an appalling way to treat any animal, let alone one as intelligent as a pig has been shown to be.
- Steve Hirst, 5:52 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
There is no need for these animals to be kept in these conditions. Permitting animal health travesties like this is damaging to our reputation and has a negative economic and health impact. Consumers do not demand this maltreatment because they demand cheap meat. Please raise the bar of how we treat our livestock.
- Karen Yates, 5:51 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
I have a very strong view about how animals should be treated. Animals have the same right to live on this planet as we do. Yes we use them as food to eat, but do we need to treat them so incredibly badly as these factory pigs are. Some say we learn from experience, maybe a few humans should share their "home" for a week.
- Margot Spraggon, 5:49 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
it is cruel, inhumane and no creature should ever be kept in these conditions
- Jacqueline Renwick, 5:48 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
I only buy free range or organic pork because I respect the environment and my health. As a new Zealand citizen principles of fairness and respect to our environment (which includes animals) is more important than cost or profit considerations. In addition to updating the Animal Welfare Act so that cruel practises are removed, I believe NZ should introduce labelling regulations for overseas pork suppliers so that Nz citizens can make more informed choices about where their pork has come from and how it has been farmed. I would appreciate your help with this.
- Belinda Hodson, 5:47 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
Stop letting pigs being mistreated in the short life that they do have.
- Phill, 5:46 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
We have free range chooks and thay are happy, contented and thrive here. The nation's pigs deserve to be farmed in a similar humane and considerate manner!
- Anne Magill, 5:44 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
Dear John Key The poor little animals are powerless against these people. Who knows what they are thinking in there little minds. I cant even imagine being in there shoes they are better off dead than going through all this cruelty. Can you please stop this as you are the one who can really make a change you have the power to stop this. If you do this I know there would be alot of people who would seeing you as a bit of a hero thanks..geoff and Stace
- Geoff and Stace, 5:43 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
I believe free range is the only humane option for our pigs. Legislation should be amended urgently to initiate this desirable change!
- matthew Magill, 5:39 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
To be cruel to another living creature that is totally defenceless is something that humans seem to excell in. It is time that we evolved and matured into a better species.Treat animals with respect.It is not to late to learn from our past and stop the suffering ,just for a few extra cents. Also ban all imports that are produced with cruel procedures. Make the hard choice John.People will respect and admire you for it.
- Greg Parsons, 5:39 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
I have personally seen one of these pig farms my self. The pigs were chained to the ground and could only stand up and down and were water blasted to keep the place sanitised. Imagine if you had to live your life like this.
- Pearl Girdlestone, 5:31 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
I believe that all animals, whether human or not, deserve to be treated with love and respect. Pigs are beautiful intelligent creatures that should have the freedom and good health that they deserve. Keeping them in small cages of any kind is unacceptable. I hope that you have heart enough to fight for these wonderful animals who cannot fight this battle themselves!
- Briar, 5:24 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
I don't admire your position. "With great power comes great responsibility"--Yes, I am going to quote Spiderman with all seriousness for the first time in my life. One of your responsibilities is heed the messages of your concerned public. Further still, I think you have a responsibility to the welfare or animals. The fact that THERE IS something you can do about suffering animals means that you HAVE TO do something about it. Pigs are smart creatures. I'm sure a man as educated as you are would know this. This means that they are very capable of feeling both emotional and physical pain, and don't try and argue with me that they don't undergo both of these. You know very well they do. Thank you very much, Samah Seger.
- Samah Seger, 5:24 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
even though I am not vegetarian I don't think it's particularly fair for pigs to live like that. How would you feel if that's how you lived?
- Alex Tiley, 5:17 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
you have done enough damage all ready. It is evident you used to work for a bank, It's all about the money, money and power, most of all greed. You have blood on your hands of creatures and environment that can't defend themselves. You ought to be proud of yourself, at least the people of your country care, maybe enough to make up for your lack of. I would love for you to actually read this message, although you most probably will not. I beg you to have empathy and compassion not just in this situation but in all situations. Be the change you want to see in the world, we could lead an example for the rest of the world. However at the moment I have lost faith, in my country. I'm only 19 years old and I am afraid.
- Hollie-Rose, 5:16 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
its inhumane.
- Rory, 5:08 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
it is truly sad to live in a country where such horrendous cruelty is allowed. Pigs are intelligent animals who suffer greatly when subjected to factory farming conditions. I don't know how people can stand by and let this continue when they have the power to change the law. Do you really want to live with the fact that you could have done something to stop some needless suffering but didn't? What do you want to be remembered for?
- Susannah Edwards, 5:07 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
all creatures (great and small) have the right to live a life without pain and suffering.
- Renee Fletcher, 5:03 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
it should have never been able to happen. It should not be happening anywhere in the world let alone NZ.
- Megan, 4:55 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
You have lost my vote over this issue John, win it back.
- Martha Geary Nichol, 4:48 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
it's inhumane
- neill parkin, 4:40 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
This type of farming is in-humane, and must be stopped. Any farm practises like this must be banned. Please do the right thing here. Much Love Jennifer
- Jennifer , 4:40 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
it's a method of torture. Society finds it unacceptable to torture a human, so why should it treat an animal differently? You have the power to affect the way people think. You have the power to make a change for the good. Please use it.
- Emma Brannam, 4:36 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
it's a method of torture. Society finds it unacceptable to torture a human, so why should it treat an animal differently? You have the power to affect the way people think. You have the power to make a change for the good. Please use it.
- Emma Brannam, 4:35 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
imagine if you were them , they are living animals too . would you like you be locked up tight all day every day . im sure you wouldn't ? . then why do we do it to pigs ? .
- Kaycie O'Connor, 4:21 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
it is unacceptable to deny any animal the freedom to express it's natural behaviours. All animals should be treated with respect and while farming them is at present un-avoidable with the demand for meat by humans, the farming processes should aim to give the animals a good quality of life.
- Janine, 4:19 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
the suffering of any animal is NOT acceptable.
- Teresa van der Horst, 4:19 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
it fails to provide for even the most basic necessities of pig welfare. The Animal Welfare Act 1999 stipulates that Codes of Welfare must be designed to ensure that the needs of animals are met (including the expression of natural behaviours) in accordance with section 10 of the statute.The draft code does not address the needs of these highly intelligent animals. I implore you to ensure that the draft is ammended so pigs can express their natural behaviours. And, Sir, eveyrone has the right to a little fresh air and sunshine! Thank you for considering my submission.
- Rosalind, 4:18 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
it is unhuman. Pigs are intelligent creatures, some say as or more intelligent as dogs. They should be able to live in a natural way as sheep and cows do.. and chickens should. i only purchase free range pork and chicken as i simply can not support products from any other sources. please please do something about this. i am not an activist or greenie.. but a national supporter. along with the latest idea of factories of dairy cattle this current treatment of pigs should cease immediately. thank you for listening.
- carrie Harrington, 4:16 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
pigs are just like us. They have feelings and it absolutely disgusts me seeing images on T.V of pigs in crates biting the bars, and pigs can also cry, just like us. I'm a fan of pigs, not the actual meat pork. And pork would sell better. Pak'n'Save on Moorehouse Avenue in Christchurch seels only freedom farm pork and the staff are refilling the shelf every 20mins of that pork. The other pork doesn't sell as well. And also can I please ask you to get rid of caged Chickens?. All animals deserve a loving, caring environment and the freedom to be able to run around. But thats not whats happening.
- Jacinda Nicholl, 4:14 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
I strongly disbelieve in the cruel act upon pigs and other animals that have been forced to live and grow in these horrible conditions. There is no justice in any of how these animals have been forced to live an as the sole person in charge of what is to happen with these animals, it is your responsibility to take immediate action in preventing this from continuing. Letters like this should be enough for you to take action. If that isn't enough, see for yourself the poor quality these animals are forced in, and try living in the conditions they have to live in for their entire lives, with no choice.
- Aaron, 4:13 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
I believe animals must be treated as more than a mere resources. They are living creatures that are capable of suffering on a level comparable to that of a child, in that they most likely struggle to understand why such inhumane things are being done to them by a species they initially tend to trust. The abuse of that trust is something society should be ashamed of, and I'm sure more people would be if they were exposed to the realities of the way animals are treated in many of our industries. Thank you for your time.
- Nicholas Coulter, 4:06 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
I find it difficult to comprehend the human race, they have to exploit everything. I hoped NZ was different. No animals should be treated in an imhumane way just for money. Can't we learn by other's mistakes and the problems generated from badly looked after animals and birds overseas. Sadly NZ is heading in the wrong direction.
- Alison Hunt, 4:01 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
You say you want to be a prime minister who makes a difference, here is your chance to do something now. My children ask why nothing is been done and what they can do to stop it. I have advised them and we do not eat any pork products in our house any more or when we go out. Please do something that will put the faith back in our government. Stop the needless cruelty.
- Elaine Cooper, 4:00 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
the practice of harming these wonderful animals should never have begun in the first place; and now you have the opportunity to stop it permanently. I like you as a prime minister and I'm sure you'll do the right thing.
- Daryll Pugh, 3:57 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
Dear John Key, factory farming pigs is unnecessary and cruel. The less pigs factory farmed, the cheaper free range meat will become, and the more beneficial for everyone! PLEASE stop this cruelty!
- Sarah Bogle, 3:54 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
in this day and age, this is just not acceptable. Pigs are supposed do be more intelligent than a dog. How can we allow this to go on?
- L wills, 3:53 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
it is cruel and needless. There is a better way!
- Jenny Grant, 3:50 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
it is just plain sickening.
- Rebecca Essex, 3:46 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
please stop this it is inhumane and sickening. treating any animal in such a way for a bit of extra profit is repulsive and new zealand shouldn't be seen in this way. treat pigs the way they need, and deserve to be treated.
- Mark Fyers, 3:44 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
it is cruel and inhumane treatment of a sentient being.
- Holly Genovese, 3:41 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
They are such intelligent animals who deserve to be stimulated throughout their life. I believe that if animals are to be farmed for meat or other products they at the very least deserve to be able to live their life as they would normally, to be able to breath fresh air and run around free as they please.
- Christy Rintoul, 3:40 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
I am opposed to factory farming because it is so inhumane, i cannot fathom how it has gotten to this point at all. Seeing sows in crates so small they cannot move, chewing on the bars, sitting in their own muck and getting sores from the conditions is sickening. As pigs are in fact very intelligent, this is even more harmful to their mental health (Although intelligence should have no bearing on how a living creature is treated). The reasons FOR the pigs being kept in such conditions are no more than monetary gain and the like, this is unacceptable! NZ should be an example on the world stage for how we treat animals as well as people. Please, please take these submissions into consideration and free these animals from this cruelty. Thankyou for taking the time to read these. Courtney White
- Courtney White, 3:39 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
it is inhuman. Who allowed this in the first place?
- sharon Moore, 3:38 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
I don't get how some people can be so cruel that they would restrict a pig's happiness just for a buck! I understand that some of us, my family included, can't afford all free-range food, but we do try. And that's what NZ consumers need to do. With your encouragement and seeing your change in the way you buy free-range food, they can change their shopping habits and put these cruel and disgusting factory farmers out of business. Please, please try your best to help these beautiful creatures.
- Chelsea Bishop, 3:37 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
aside from the fact that it's repulsive and depressing, it's just completely and utterly unnecessary.
- Clare Wieck, 3:36 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
...pigs are living creatures, too. I know I wouldn't like to be treated so badly! Would you? Why should it be different for the piggies?
- Danielle Greene, 3:35 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
no human has ever had to suffer/live like this for their short time on earth ready to be killed, just because these innocent pigs are unable to verbally express themselves they have to suffer such emotional traumatic unfair lives... at least do it in a decent way and let them have peaceful lives and don't continue this inhumane way. regards B.R
- Bonnie Rogers, 3:30 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
We went to Marshalls animal park in tauranga on my birthday 12th april and the cutest little piglet followed us all the way around- like a wee pet dog- it was soo cute and my daughter was crying when we left because she loved it so much. I hear they make great pets. They certainly- like any other living creature deserve to be treat inhumainly. They are a life and didnt ask to be made into a sandwich following the most horrible life...and death- FREEDOM FARMS - if any!!! We too can help!!!
- Michelle Holland, 3:30 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
cruelty is a terrible thing and since we like to eat animals, I believe it's fair to treat them with respect and to kill them with the least stress possible. At the end, all those hormones and toxins they secrete while under stress, stay in their muscles (meat) and that's what we eat.
- Alejandra , 3:26 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
it is a totally inhumane way of treating an animal. We throw up our hands in horror at pictures of bears in China being kept in cages for their bile and give money to organisations working to stop such practices, and yet our practices with pigs, hens etc, are similar. If we treated our dog or cat in that manner we would be prosecuted. But as soon as an animal is considered to be an "economic unit" our care and concern vanishes out the window. Clean and green means nothing when we tolerate this sort of treatment to animals. Thank you.
- Barbara Morris, 3:24 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
I love to eat pig, please may it be guilt free!
- Joseph, 3:19 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
i know bacon is delicious. but it is stupid and ignorant to eat the flesh of animals who have lived a life of utter cruelty. would you eat the corpse of a holocaust victim? just asking. lets do something about this aey!! yea!!! ps. if you could just stop the over fishing too? that would be great! i want my kids to be able to swim in the sea in the future. thanks man. i'm sure you understand.
- Morgana O'Reilly, 3:18 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
It dosen't allow pigs to show there true behaviour and is unfair and cruel theres no need for it in our clean green New Zealand MAKE IT STOP NOW
- Georgina, 3:17 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
You said you were appalled at the cruel shooting of some dogs recently and that you would do everything you can to stop cruelty to animals. So I expect you will also be appalled at the cruelty to pigs. Please legislate immediatly to ban these cruel practices and ensure minimum requirements for pigs' well being, such as being able to live in their natural way with enough room to move, soft straw and fresh air to breathe.
- janet bogle, 3:17 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
I believe that we (humans) have been given dominion over the earth and as such, it is our responsibility to respect the other creatures that inhabit our planet, to care for those in our charge and above all to ensure that we do everything we can to protect them from those that would do them harm. Money and larger profits are no excuse, in fact probably the worst excuse, for allowing these beautiful creatures to live lives of suffering.
- Helen Geraghty, 3:12 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
there is no need for animals to suffer.if they have to be killed, surely they deserve some sort of decent life before that happens. lets hope you dont come back as a pig in your next life eh john? from a pig lover and a pork lover !
- belinda liley, 3:11 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
Its not natural! Pigs should be allowed to wander in a field & do what they do naturally. Humans have basic rights & so too should all animals. I don't want to eat an animal that has been treated cruelly or is forced to behave against its own natural behaviour. That is why I only buy & eat free range organic chicken & eggs. Lets improve conditions for all farmed meat. Animals are not objects & just because we farm & eat them doesn't mean they're lives are automatically disposable. I want to eat healthy meat from an animal not something thats been stuck in a cage 24/7 or a barn or pumped full of growth hormones just to make things cheap & conveniant. I'm sick of supermarkets etc hiding behind "thats what the consumer wants" Actually as a consumer its not what I want.
- Tracy Tye, 3:07 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
Farming once upon a time used to be "free range farming" before became "Intense farming". Our chooks on the majority used to live in the open spaces as did our pigs... These days we have opted for making more dollars and less sense at the cost of animals humane welfare as well as lining the pockets of those who could care less. I would rather save the extra dollars and pay for free range. New Zealanders are tired of the lies that go on in the Corporate world we are also tired of being dictated to. As our Prime Minister you have the power and ability to listen to the people who voted for you as we thought you are not only intelligent but for the people. Please do something about the factory farmed pigs - put a ban on the sow and farrowing crates. Not only do the pigs live more humanely but we actually end up with a taster meal... Better quality of life for the sows and a certainly taster for us. So really its a win win for all.
- Donna Burson, 3:07 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
it is inhumane and disgusting. Please stop this now!!
- Peter Salmon, 3:06 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
it goes against what New Zealand stands for. Pigs are a very intelligient animal and it is beyond cruel to keep sows in crates. We have acres/hectares of land that they could graze on during the day. There needs to be a standard in which pig farming for commercial use abide by that takes care of the animal welfare issue surrounding farrowing crates. Why do we allow imported Pork products into NZ if it keeps sows in crates to be competitive... easy answer - ban imported Pork products - upgrade current NZ standards of commercial pig farming.
- Karen Bedogni, 3:02 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
The pig is a very noble beast, and should be kept in such a manner. Think of all the good things they supply us, like Chops, Ham and Bacon.....Its just plain wrong to treat animals in such a way and the least we can do is provide them with a comfortable home. Plus I like eating Pigs, and feel bloody guilty if they've had a crap life! Free range all the way!
- Ben , 2:59 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
the pain and suffering inflicted on the animals for profit. I would pay more for cruelty free products. NZ has the chance to stand proud and to promote it's products as not only "green" but animal friendly.
- Jennifer Hunt, 2:56 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
it is disgusting and cruel my kids were horrified and will never eat pig again
- Lisa Felstead, 2:55 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
pigs have feelings and a life too, like humans, they should be able to roam around and breathe fresh air, not be covered in mud, and stuck in a tiny crate all day. It is unfair and cruel to make pigs suffer, when they have done no harm. Please ban the use of crates for any animals, because it is not right. Thankyou
- Annaliese , 12, 2:53 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
Imagine if you were kept in those kind of conditions. Would your life be worth living?
- Alysha Calder, 2:51 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
it's unethical, cruel and unnecessary. I think there's a lot of people who'd like to be in your shoes, to have the power to provide a decent life for the animals who then die for us. Use that power for something good John.
- Nicole Munro, 2:50 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
We have a chance to lead. To be an example. What ever happened to morals and ethics?
- Luke Derry, 2:49 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
We are not a third world country, lets stop behaving like one. Animals need to be treated humanely. Thank you
- Janice Paisley, 2:45 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
it is against basic ethics, animals suffer enough to feed man the least we could do is offer them a clean and healthy environment while they are alive. If the animals we consume lived a happy and healthy life in conditions deemed fit for any farm animal, they are likely to be healthier when turned into food. So banning the factory farming regime will not only benefit the animals and be more humane, but it will benefit those who consume them. I hope you will take this issue very seriously as I believe New Zealand to be one of the few countries that are fair and place importance on equality and wellbeing of all living creatures and nature.
- sophie Gao, 2:42 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
these intelligent animals suffer unnecessarily. They spend most of their lives in these tiny crates and are then killed. There must be something you can do.
- Karen Walker, 2:41 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
of the conditions pigs are living in. Please watch the videos of how they live, how they are treated. It is complete cruelty and needs to stop now. Pigs can be farmed in a much more humane way and this is not it. Please do something for these pigs. Their fate lies in your hands.
- Sarah Payne, 2:40 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
I have a small free range pig farm in the Wairarapa. Sow and farrowing crates is a terrible way to treat pigs and detracts from our Clean and Green New Zealand image. Please ban the use of these immediately.
- D Vaughan, 2:40 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
it is cruel and unessasary and as a hunter of many animals feel this practice should be banned . it also dosnt do our green reputation any good . at the very least make it compolsory to mark all animal products with ther origin and let consumers decide .it is working with eggs and chickens .dont make me vote labour next time as i never have and i am a national supporter but this needs adressing along with no gst rise so we can afford free range pork .
- stephen constable, 2:40 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
it is obvious how cruel and barbaric this treatment of intelligent animals really is. We wouldn't let this happen to our family dog, and yet every day it is happening to millions of animals just as intelligent and social as our beloved pets. I am a meat eater who enjoys pork but only from free-range farms and I don't mind the additional cost. I see this as the true cost of a quality NZ product versus the cheap and very nasty alternative. Please make the right call and ban these crates. Help keep New Zealand the beautiful and brave little country that we are so proud of.
- Teina Herzer, 2:39 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
What sort of person, especially a Prime Minister, would not do all that they can to help animals? It's about time New Zealand becomes a role model for how animals and in this case pigs are to be treated - the way a society treats its animals is reflected in how it treats its people. Put away the political card and step up
- Athena Cotidis, 2:37 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
I am living in the United States where cruelty to more than just animals is the norm. I live in a nation that is so stuck up it doesn't give equal rights to its own citizens. But I feel somewhere in the world there could be a better place. And maybe it can be with you.
- Daniel Davis, 2:37 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
I believe it is cruel, outdated and quite frankly, intolerable. We have an opportunity to change the future of Animal Welfare in this country, and to show that, as New Zealanders, we are an intelligent,educated and compassionate society.As an economy, NZ relies heavily on animals, and I find it absolutely disgusting that their welfare is of such little significance. As Humans, we have a huge influence on the future of so many other beings in this world, so PLEASE, let us choose to stop the suffering!
- KATRINA SCHRAFFT, 2:36 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
Dear Mr Key as I'm a buyer of NZ raised meat products, as well as being opposed to factory style farming, I am sure that rearing animals in such conditions of close proximity to eacxh other that there would be reason for a fair ammount of antibiotics used to maintain a required level of health. THis concerns me as I would prefer my meat to be as free as possible as can be for the health of the animal and the consumer of it's flesh. Yours sincerely S Greenshields. PS I was rural raised and do understand the restraints that farmers are faced with.
- S Greenshields , 2:32 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
we can do better.
- S Hill, 2:30 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
It is insanely cruel. If we treated our pets this way, we would get prosecuted! Pigs deserve a happy and healthy life like all other animals. Please stop this cruel mistreatment, Key.
- Emma Cameron, 2:26 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
In our modern world today there is no excuse for the pratice of cage farming of any animal and we as a nation need to abolish it completely and help lead the rest of the world as we do in other issues like the No Nukes motto. Please support our efforts in this matter.
- Kim Macdonald, 2:25 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
It think it is cruel and barbaric to treat animals in such a manner. I have no problems if animals are slaughered for meat if they have had a good life and are cleaning and humanly killed. WE AS A SOCIETY NEED TO HAVE MORE EMPATHY. This is not a 3rd world country, lets stop acting like one!!!
- Debbie McCallum , 2:24 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
we do not have the right to subject any animal to unnecessary suffering. I am not a soppy bleeding-heart type; I am not even a vegetarian. I enjoy eating pork and bacon but I don't buy either while I know that the pigs lived in misery before their deaths. It is quite simply unacceptable for a civilised society to allow sow and farrowing crates to continue to be used. I want them outlawed straight away, not in several years' time. Even one more day is too long. Please see to it.
- Pamela Wade, 2:23 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
it's cruelty to animals pure and simple. If we treated cats or dogs or any other domestic animal in this way we would be prosecuted (and rightly so). Please please ban this cruel practice.
- Melissa Ranaldi, 2:21 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
we are better than the rest of the world. We have the opportunity to become the best place in the world to farm meat and crops. Lets be the world benchmark for safe and healthy farming practices. PS Leave Canterbury's water system alone we don't want dairy farms on the plains.
- Keeley Pomeroy, 2:20 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
At the end of the day it isn't a lot different from how many chickens are treated - and that is another disgrace. Clean green NZ - what a joke!. Any sort of factory farming where animals are caged up in tight cubicles should be outlawed. DO SOMETHING.
- pete action, 2:18 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
I might only be 13 but my whole family can't stand animal crulety in New Zealand. There is a chance that we could get sick from factory farmed pigs if we eat them. The toxins and diseases that are ocupying the poor pigs body even after it has been slaughtered for people to eat.Even with battery hens we can still get sick they might be animals but they can still get hurt because of us. Just think of how it would be you were one of these animals or hens getting crammed into a small pen or cage being eaten alive by diseases and hoping that this totrue will be over soon so you don't have to suffer anymore please save the pigs and any other animal thats being treated this way. Thank you for you Time
- Stefani , 2:18 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
Factory farming of Pig is simply Cruelty at its worst. Its so inhumane it disgusting. Please do your up most John Keys to stop this here in New Zealand.
- ngaere mercer, 2:18 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
it is cruel what they are doing to the poor innocent pigs that just want to live the rest of their lives in peace. pigs dont deserve this kind of thing. i have seen very disturbing videos/photos of dead/dying pigs on the ground, and cripled pigs because thay aren't getting enough sunshine or nature that all animals need. i would like to see a huge improvement in this and i would like for you to join this petition. and they also force feed the poor animals. pigs have feelings too, and we need to respect that. PLEASE HELP THE PIGS!!!
- Sharnae Clarke, 2:17 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
I feel that animals feel pain and emotion and deserve equal rights that we as humans get.
- LEANNE WARD, 2:15 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
Like most kiwi's I like to travel and when I do, I boast to those I meet about how beautiful, clean and green my country is and how priviledged I am to be born and live in a country where the people are passionate about the environment. Our produce is superior because of this. I would also be very proud to say one day, that we don't have any cruel farming pratices and that New Zealand meat products are the best in the world because of it.
- Maggie Bartels, 2:14 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
having grown up on a farm, I know there are alternative ways to combat any problems with farrowing sows please stop this dreadful business. I have not bought any pork products for the past two years due to this situation
- Jennifer Marx, 2:13 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
how we treat animals should reflect how we treat each other. Every life deserves to be a good one, whether it walks upright and talks or not.
- Andie Spargo, 2:11 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
Its disgusting that we can treat any living creatures this way. Pigs are intellegent beings and require at the very least an area to live where they can be free to express their natural behaviours. We need to have alternatives to factory farmed pork readily available for everyday New Zealanders to make a choice whether they want to support this injustice or buy from a source that supports animal welfare.
- Andrina Kelly, 2:11 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
it is so unnecessary, cruel, unfair
- Sarah Le Breton, 2:09 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
at the end of the day there is value in finding a balance between profit and humanity. Animals may indeed, in part, exist for our benefit, however they were never meant to be treated the way we do. Unnaturally farmed, causing them pain and suffering through their life is not humane or more importantly necessary. It is our greed to save a few dollars here and there that drives it. Please let us set an example as the famous Gandhi goes “The greatness of a nation and its moral progress can be judged by the way its animals are treated”.
- Alexandra Hamilton, 1:55 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
I am one of few vegetarians in America. Being originally from New Zealand, I like to think that my upbringing of animal welfare and concern for their rights in New Zealand is a major factor in this decision of mine. I truly hope that New Zealand continues with its world wide firsts of being concerned with animal welfare and all that it entails, including this topic. It means a lot to take a stand, and be the first to show what they believe, one reason I am proud to say I am a kiwi.
- Kea Cottle, 1:50 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
Here's your chance to show New Zealanders that the John Key they have come to know (that doesn't listen to the people of NZ regarding anti-smacking laws etc) to show that maybe you do listen to us after all!
- Tania, 1:48 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
there are many things more important than money, and this is one of them! Pigs are obviously suffering in current farming conditions. Put this right, and let's show the world that New Zealand is better than that!
- Rosanna Olsen, 1:46 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
it is gross and disgusting disregard for the life of the animals.
- Carolyn Hayward, 1:43 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
This is a terribly cruel method of farming. Please, please put an end to this.
- Kathryn Guthrie, 1:32 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
it is an inhumane practice, and anyone who doesn't oppose to it is sick in the head. Pigs are smart creatures and like battery and broiler chickens deserve to be treated ALOT better. What would you do if their was a sow in a cramped cage in front of you? Do what you would do in that situation.
- Alexandra Reid, 1:21 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
Since coming here 15 years ago I realized just how cruel people here are, there more cruelty here than in UK. Even the Government backs up the cruelty. These poor pigs! I haven't eaten pork since the cruelty came to light, and I won't eat pork until they are free range.
- Frqnk Gausden, 1:21 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
it is disgusting that any LIVING being has to live in such appalling conditions. New Zealand takes so many things for granted. The sun. Grass. Space. clean air. A safe environment to live in. health care. These pigs never get to experience these things. New Zealand is always being portrayed as a clean green country That takes pride in what it does. This image is being destroyed. So please. Take some initiative to regain that image. These animals are finally getting the voices they deserve. So listen. Please. I hope you make the right decision.
- Beka, 1:17 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
it is inhuman and we do not want to be a society who endorses this!
- sarah Ellis-Kirifi, 1:17 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
this practice models to our next generation what hypocrites adults are, and how lacking in integrity we are.
- Robina Maria Broughton, 1:17 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
It is inhumane. In a country like New Zealand we do not need to keep pigs in this way. I only eat free range pork as the animals have been fairly treated. This needs to stop.
- Emily Moon, 1:14 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
Factory farming threatens New Zealand's reputation as a provider of quality foods, thus damaging both the tourism and meat export markets.
- Walter McGinnis, 1:13 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
the way we treat animals reflects on our nations ability to have compassion for other living beings. Pigs are very intelligent creatures and to keep them in such inhumane circumstances just because they taste good is disgusting. You seem like a kind man who has a heart, please help us end animal abuse. Kind regards, Vanessa Hirst.
- Vanessa Hirst, 1:04 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
we should never subject an animal to a situation which a human would find unbearable. were humans subjected to these same conditions it would be considered an atrocity. the golden rule should apply to pigs, cattle, sheep, and fowl alike, not humans exclusively.
- Bryne, 1:03 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
what would happen if dogs cats and any other animal be treated like pigs they are no different they have feelings and can easily be taught just like a dog so if you can sleep at nights and ignore this plea for pigs then good luck to you
- Nyiri Broughton, 1:01 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
of the disturbing images I have seen on TV1 and TV3 news stories. We have a responsibility to treat other living things with respect and this is currently not the case where factory farmed pigs are concerned. As a consumer I would rather pay more for pork, bacon etc that has come from pigs that have lived a good quality of life.
- carol smith, 12:56 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
I actually stayed on a pig farm for about 4 months when I was younger and since then, I have not been able to eat any pork product (bacon, ham, pork, saussies, you name it). I wasn't surprised to see the images on Close Up, I thought "good on them for telling everyone but this is nothing new, and certainly not an isolated case". I beg you to consider the publics comments on this issue, and if you can stomach it, go and check it out for yourself and you will find it very difficult to turn a blind eye. Thanks for your time John.
- Christine Main, 12:51 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
I have moved to New Zealand when I was 13 years old, i think New Zealand is the most beautiful country I have ever never been, how can they treat the pig like this, imaging that you stay in the darkness same as the pig, how you would feel? why they needs to be in the factory farm? I felt so sad when I watching the video, so please please help them, they should treat as other animals.
- C. Z Lin, 12:39 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
Mr Key New Zealand is the leader in so many things, why are we so far behind in this? The world is watching and this is one thing we can change...
- H. Clinton, 12:38 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
it is clearly a very inhumane, immoral practice. This is a classic situation of greed & money taking precendence over values. There are not that many ignorant people, but there are unfortunatly a small amount of people who will ultimaltely control the outcome of this situation and one can only hope that they are not soley influenced by money as are so many people. The suffering of this highly intelligent animal needs to end. It is very sad and so unnecessary...what are we teaching our children, very sad.
- Luke Sharp, 12:37 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
Animal cruelty and torture must NOT be tolerated! Like many other people, I can no longer eat pork products, knowing what the pigs have suffered. If we are going to eat meat, the very least we MUST give them is a good life and a humane death. Thank you for your urgent attention to this matter. Katie Alice New Plymouth
- Katie Alice, 12:36 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
of the horrible conditions for such an intelligent animal!! It's disgusting. clean green New Zealand is a joke!!! free range pigs!! I have experienced piggeries first hand in 2005 and since then have not eaten or bought pork or pork products. the rubbing sores and steel harnesses are disgusting .
- Shontelle, 12:33 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
As a country, we are only starting to get rid of battery hens, also we are trying to object to factory farming cows. How can we not fight against cruelty to animals and keep our "clean and green" reputation. People also think we are the nicest people in the world, according to many people that I've spoken with.
- Kana Border, 12:21 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
i was born and lived in new zealand all my life, ive always beleaved we are a great, safe , caring place, yet im starting to wonder if i have been wrong for all theses yrs, if we were safe our animals would be too, if we were a caring place our animals wouldnt suffer. if we are goin to use animals for meat, milk and money, we should give them the best life we can while they are here, but a animal living n a space were they can only stand n lie down makes me sick.oh and the vet that was speckn bout it was talkn rubbish those pigs were eatn by pigs, im 19 and i can see that, ive been livin n workn on farms all my life. they shouldnt live like that just coz you dnt wna spend money grow up its our tax payers money use it for good instead of just giving it all to people that are to lazy to work n go on the doll.BE A BIG MAN STAND UP AND SAY ITS WRONG.
- sara, 12:19 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
No animal deserves to be treated like that. We are not a 3rd world country and unable to make changes Mr. Key. You hold the power to better the image of our country. Will you choose to do it? Your responsibility is to us, the people. Well, Mr. Key, we, the people, are telling you that our responsibility is to these animals. Do something about it.
- Sarah Sulzberger, 12:16 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
its cruel
- Tania Bowen, 12:14 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
This has been going on for too long! Why is that people go to jail for stealing or committing simple unlawful crimes, but an act such as pig cruelty is repeatedly ignored!!!!!! And it’s worse because the pigs didn’t choose to live a crappy and demeaning life. Some people just say “their just animals” yeah well we are just humans that probably deserve to be worse of than them... well I’d like to see those people carrying out the lives of these animals for a day… “one doesn’t know, unless one experiences”
- patricia, 12:13 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
it is cruel and inhumane and a society is judged by the way it treats it's poorest - in this case, animals.
- F Dodd-Parr, 12:13 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
These wonderful creations have a short enough life as it is, Why make that life misrebill with no sense of love or happiness, They deserve to see sunlight and Experience love just like every single one of us humans do. So do it for the team, Do it for the pigs! Dont you think they need love because they have a heart, A brain, 2 eyes 1 nose like the rest of us and they also have feelings! So instead of those feelings bein Hurt, Sadness and Pain turn it around to love, happiness and joy.
- Kellee, 12:10 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
It is a woeful statement on humanity that we are able to submit any animal to needless suffering in order to satisfy our appetite for large quantities of cheap meat. Humane farming practices must be the way of the future. I like to envisage that one day, future generations will look back in horror and disbelief at some of the farming practices being employed today.
- Alexandra Harper, 12:09 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
Its discusting and now animal should every have to suffer wether they are raised to be slaughtered or not.
- Larz, 12:09 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
These wonderful creations have a short enough life as it is, Why make that life misrebill with no sense of love or happiness, They deserve to see sunlight and Experience love just like every single one of us humans do. So do it for the team, Do it for the pigs! Dont you think they need love because they have a heart, A brain, 2 eyes 1 nose like the rest of us and they also have feelings! So instead of those feelings bein Hurt, Sadness and Pain turn it around to love, happiness and joy.
- Kellee, 12:09 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
seriously!! this even needs an explaination is beyound me, this is your country, your clean green image! what is clean or green about the conditions we farm our pigs and chickens! happyer pigs and chickens mean yummyer bacon and egga and a whole lot of activists supporting you, when are the next elections?! getting campigning yet?! i will personally promise my vote to you if you can prove to me you understand animal welfare starting with these poor creatures.
- Hannah Chisholm, 12:08 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
Do it for the love and happiness of the pigs because they cant live a happy life locked in a cage, We are the ones that can make a difference to this wonderful animalls life.
- Kellee, 12:03 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
there are other ways we can farm the pigs adn if we encourage enough people to buy free reange pork, ham, bacon then farmers could be forced to free range farm. Please support this cause if we all do our bit we could make a change to this cruel way of farming.
- shannon skelton, 12:02 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
It is a cruel and disgusting crime that has to be stopped! You don’t see any humans being forced to live in tiny cages for their whole lives, with hardly any supply of water or food, without the possibility of ever seeing sunlight unless they are taken out to be slaughtered by having their head cut off. So why is it any different with animals? Their lives are just as valuable as ours, just because they can’t complain or sue doesn’t mean we should ignore them.
- mia, 12:02 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
I believe that animals deserve fair treatment and that we as humans should always strive to help those that are neglected and not always on our minds. The conditions that Pigs in particular are forced to endure is cruel and upsetting and these conditions need to be addessed for the sake of the Pigs and the future of our planet.
- Dorian Alexander Probet, 12:02 PM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
I think it's horrible to treat pigs like that, they have feelings just like us, humans, dogs, cats cant be treated like that, why can they??????
- Jamie Tasker, 11:58 AM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
it is a miserable existence for an animal to be kept under such conditions. New Zealand should provide itself on animal welfare for all animals including livestock. Afterall Anchor butter's tag line abroad is the free range butter. http://www.thefreerangebutter.co.uk/
- Jenny Webster, 11:56 AM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
There are other ways of farming these little critters, its just that the government is not willing to step up and take action. You put all your money etc into worthless tasks instead of looking at what we already have and improving it, Look at ways on how you can help farmers, we are your blood line, admitt it you need the farming industry to survive, really create New Zealand as a safe, clean and green image and stick to it, you succeed with the Banning of Live Export, best thing that has happened so far. So why not take the challenge and Ban Factory Farming.
- Marni Berghan, 11:56 AM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
The way the pigs are treated is inhumane and goes against everything our country should stand for. It breaks my heart to see how the pigs are kept, no creature deserves to be treated the way that they are. Please support this ban!
- Kelsey Burgess, 11:52 AM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
I think it's horrible to treat pigs like that, they have feelings just like us, humans, dogs, cats cant be treated like that, why can they??????
- Nancy Wang, 11:48 AM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
It does not have to be that way, Pigs dont deserve to suffer, Why does there life have any lesser value then ours? Please do this for them because this cant keep happening to our wonderful creation of pigs, Do it for the happy life that they should have, Not the life that pigs have now which is suffering misseribly. Thnakyou for you time to read this and please help make a difference to the lives of these inascent pigs
- Kellee Candy, 11:47 AM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
Why would we treat an animal with such utter contempt, when we would never let that kind of cruelty of any human go unpunished.I hope that you look past your ignorant business view of everything and do whats right!
- Tom Sommerville, 11:45 AM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
it is an outdated and cruel practice that yields an inferior product. Fear, terror, panic and misery are all chemically quantifiable in the amalgam of associated proteins and amino acids that are produced from emotional responses which animals are capable of feeling. "You are what you eat" so it follows that raising & slaughtering animals in better circumstances will yield in the end a populace who is consuming less of the chemicals produced from these atrocious practices which are so rife in our agricultural industries. The use of farrowing crates with pigs is particularly abhorrent.
- Marc Mateo, 11:42 AM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
Pigs are intellegint, amazing animals who do not deserve a life of cruelty. It is horrible the way they are treated, and just down right sick and wrong. How would you like to be put in a tiny cage, in darkness, on hard concreate walls even for 1 minute, you wouldnt. Think about how these poor pigs feel, born there, and die there. It is not right, so please John Key, do your bit and help these poor animals.
- Scarlett Fairhall, 11:40 AM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
it promotes animal suffering and human apathy. To be fair however, pigs are not due any more consideration than chickens or other animals that suffer in this manner. All animals deserve and have been given the right to life and the pursuit of their own SAFEty, just as we have been given. All this cruelty is for profit, but its not the only part of nature we've ignored for money now is it John??
- jef ikenn, 11:40 AM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
Hi John, I visited a pig farm in Northland a few years ago. I was horrified at the conditions..even cried as i looked a big sow in the eye and saw the terror and sorrow in her life. please look into this..they are extremely sensitive animals and deserve respect. Thanks, J Brennan
- Janine Brennan, 11:39 AM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
hey john when we know better we can do better so goes the saying and WE KNOW BETTER thanks Deborah
- deborah, 11:39 AM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
It should not be that hard to sort out a system that ensures the kind and humane treatment of another living creature. Pigs are smarter than dogs, yet if New Zealanders treated thier dogs in the same way the SPCA would have a heart attack. Please get it together NZ goverment, I really hope you make a positive choice and not one for $$.
- Laurelle Jones, 11:38 AM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
This is cruel, it is inhumane and disgusting, I don't understand why they can't be more humane to these anmials, it's bad enough we all eat them.
- Nikora Hemana, 11:36 AM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
the fact that we are going to eat these pigs later does not mean that we should be so callous and cruel as to expect them to live in constant pain.
- Claire Smith, 11:36 AM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
Pigs are intelligent and feeling creatures and deserve our protection. and to be kept in humane environments.
- Julie Green , 11:33 AM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
Just because we eat Pigs doesn't make their lives any less valuable and animal welfare laws should not allow such poor treatment of any living creature no matter what their purpose. In fact because we eat them shouldn't it be more important?? It has been proven that the quality of the meat is often down to the quality of treatment to the animal. Time for New Zealand to step up to their "clean,green" image. Rights for all animals in New Zealand, big, small, edible or not.
- Tracey Reid, 11:30 AM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
No living creature deserves this treatment. Please take action on what you know to be wrong. Your role of Prime Minister ensures that all New Zealanders rights are upheld but what about the rights of our animals? Its time that strict laws are put in place to prevent cruel treatment of not only pigs but all animals in Aotearoa.
- Rachel Moller, 11:29 AM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
its extremely cruel, just because their animals doesnt mean its okay to treat them that way. Imagine if someone put you in something like that, in dirty conditions how would you feel? This is not right, factory farming of pigs needs to stop, we are not a cruel society, we cant support cruelty to animals otherwise we can animals ourselves and not the good kind of animals. Having factory of farming in New Zealand is one of the downfalls of this beautiful country, we dont want overseas visitors seeing the state we keep animals in, when the word spreads over the newspapers and on television thats when people are going to see that New Zealand isnt as beautiful as they thought and we dont want that! Do something about it, it wont stop on its own, it needs support.
- Lara Stewart, 11:23 AM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
the way pigs are treated at the moment breaks the five freedoms. Pigs deserve as much respect as any other animal however with the current laws they are allowed to be treated cruelly.
- Toni Reiher, 11:19 AM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
I believe we need to speak for the voiceless. I believe New Zealand should be a humane country.
- Cathy Lai, 11:13 AM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
Its cruel and unnessecary!!!!
- Debra Jacobsen, 11:11 AM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
Dear John Key Do you know just how intelligent pigs are? On par with a dog pigs are very intelligent animals. And I think its rather sad that we allow them to be treated in such an appalling way. I once had a couple of pet pigs, they are personable and affectionate and i dont feel at all comfortable with the way they are kept on pig farms. I know how unhappy my pig would have been to be treated this way. Please consider changing the legislation.
- Pip Reisch, 11:09 AM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
we should treat animals with the same respect as we treat humans, pigs have feelings too and it much tastier to eat happy free range organic pigs, and i know you know you prefer eating happy pigs.
- Rana Aston, 11:08 AM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
How would you like it to happen to you!?
- Gaylene., 11:05 AM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
STOP FACTORY FARMING OF PIGS!!!!
- Gaylene., 11:03 AM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
like you I have seen the disturbing footage from inside these farms. It has been over 10 years since public pressure started seriously mounting to remove these cruel practices and now we have the chance for change. If my dog was kept in these circumstances I would be arrested and publicly vilified. Like Dogs, Pigs are intelligent, sentient creatures who do not deserve to be treated like machines.
- Tom Anderson, 11:01 AM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
As kiwis we are world leaders of so much that is so great compared to overseas(clean green, nuclear free, not fighting in Iraq etc)lets make sure all our animals are treated humanely also, stand up for what we want, and this is what we want!Be another world leader!Thanks so much Heather
- H Tietjens, 10:59 AM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
We would never condone this in Dairy Farming why do we allow it for Pigs and Chickens...doesn't add up. Please do something sooner rather than later Mr.Prime Minister. Andre Van Kesteren
- A.Van Kesteren, 10:52 AM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
tortured meat tastes abosolutley AWFUL! The better lives they have before the end makes everyone happier!
- Kitty Stewart, 10:51 AM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
Dear John We have plenty of space in New Zealand for pigs to enjoy a natural life outdoors. It is cruel to confine these intelligent animals in stalls. Cheers Daphne
- Daphne Squibb, 10:46 AM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
I have faith that you understand how cruel this really is and have the compassion to make it right.
- Tracie Tait, 10:44 AM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
Pigs are intelligent animals, we would never be allowed to treat our dogs in the same fashion. I am not vegetarian but I refuse to buy pork from NZ or otherwise due to the appalling standards in which the pigs are permitted to be farmed. It is time the law changed and treated these animals with the same rights we bestow upon other animals farmed or domestic in NZ.
- Natasha Robertson, 10:41 AM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
there is absolutely no need for such cruelty. most people will pay a couple of dollars extra to know the pig didn't have to suffer its whole life before being euthanised. And if you change this horror to a living thing DO NOT leave huge loopholes in the reform as happened in caged chicken policies world wide.
- Dane Anderson, 10:40 AM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
it is a disgrace to treat animals in this disgusting and inhumane way.We have plenty of room in our wonderful country.Give these animals a fair go John. Richard.
- Richard Hughes, 10:37 AM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
it is cruel and unnatural. Free range pigs are much better and the meat tastes a hell of a lot better. And it is not as if we are short of land in NZ so there is no real reason to continue factory farming.
- Daryl & Jill Biggar, 10:34 AM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
these practices are cruel, inhummane and unnecessary. I fail to understand why it seems to be acceptable that these poor, innocent creatures endure such disgusting treatment? Is it because they they can't speak for themselves? They may not have their own voice, but that doesn't mean they don't suffer, and feel pain, exactly as we do. Pigs have been proven to be more intelligent than dogs, and just as intelligent as young children. Mahatma Gandhi was quoted as saying that "The greatness of a nation and its moral progress can be judged by the way its animals are treated.", so if New Zealand coutinues the allowance of sow and farrowing crates, what does that say about us as a nation?
- Alexandra Larsen, 10:26 AM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
it spoils New Zealand's clean and green image, which we must retain if we are to remain a prime tourist destination and filming destination.
- Amy Bowie, 10:25 AM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
those pigs are as intelligent and aware as our home pets, dogs. We wouldn't do this to them- locking them up without any freedom and light, torturing them with boredom and no hope. This is animal cruelty of the highest degree, and shouldn't be allowed to continue in an enlightened society. Don't wait for 8 years to ban this type of farming- you have the choice now to do something to help these poor helpless animals. Surely, there is a way to make a change which supports both the farmers and the animals...
- Nicola Cliff, 10:23 AM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
It is a farming practice that has long passed it's "used by" date. There are many New Zealanders that admonish factory farming under which intensive pig farming and the use of sow and farrowing crates sit well within. These wonderful, intelligent creatures deserve better than what we are giving them. I urge you and your government to take a stand and give these (and other factory farmed) animals the lives they deserve, no matter how short those lives may be. Im afraid that a law change in 2017 is simply not good enough. If Sow stalls can be banned in countries such as the UK, Sweden and Finland, then why cant we? Many Kiwi's feel strongly about this issue, but unfortunately, do not feel that by having a say they can change the law, lets prove otherwise!
- Dominique Mallard, 10:21 AM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
Please help prevent animal cruelty, it is sad we have laws protecting some animals and not others. There should be more consistency in this area,with regards to farming and animal welfare. Surely no one if they have the choice would eat tramatised meat.Please help our nation respect our food sources. Regards, Tennessee.
- Tennessee O'Donnell, 10:16 AM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
Time to put our money where out mouth is. We pride ourselves of being a nation with respect for nature and good farming practices. Present pig farming standards do no reflect those principles. We were at forefront in woman rights, anti nuclear policy and wild life protection. Lets be at the forefront again, ensuring we have real good farming practices.
- angela cintra, 10:13 AM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
I think it is unjust to treat animals in such a way. Farming is New Zealands biggest industry but it should not mean we need to cut costs by farming animals in such horrible confining ways. Lets lead the world in treating the animals we farm in a humane way.
- Charlotte Collier-Holden, 10:09 AM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
I cannot even begin to imagine how a pig must feel being kept in such small & unsanitary conditions. We as humans could not understand I guess...because over the years have become used to being told what to do....and how to act. We are now evolving back to a place within our hearts...called love & compassion....I know you have a family & a big heart, you feel this change too. Please take some positive steps towards helping Pigs...Why should they be so cruelly treated when we have so much land and fresh air in this beautiful country of ours. Space is not an issue. Let them have the life they are entitiled to. Warmest of intention, Terri South
- Terri South, 9:51 AM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
I think that it is disgusting that in a modern forward thinking country like New Zealand, we can still treat animals so badly. We have so much land here that could be used for farming, there is no reason that pigs should be crammed into cages so tightly that they cant even turn around. If domestic animals such as dogs were kept in these conditions it would never be allowed, how are pigs any different?
- Bronwynn Holtshousen, 9:46 AM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
this kind of behaviour is not only cruel and unjust it is also inhumane. Anyone that can treat an animal with such blatant disregard can only be discribed as a monster of the worst imaginable kind. Animals have rights, just as much as humans do and if New Zealand continues to claim itself as a just and true country, then these people should be subjected to the same treatment that these pigs have suffered for years and years. Please put an end to was can only be described as ancient and babaric way of life. Thank you
- Melanie McGhie, 9:37 AM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
it is as unacceptable to inflict avoidable physical and/or emotional pain to animals as it is to people. Many civilised countries have changed their attitude to animals kept in zoos, have abolished small cages and created environments as closely imitating the natural habitat as possible. We must create the same awareness in regards to animals bred and raised for consumption. This requires education, publicity and a strong stance from our leaders. I beg you,John,help to make humans more humane. Friendly regards Inga
- inga muller, 9:36 AM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
it's absolutely sick! Pigs are animals - creatures...they breathe and they have feelings. Do YOU want to be locked? You have absolutely no sense of decency if you say YES to these awful state of things!!!
- Jennifer Fischer, 9:35 AM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
We live an environment where is not necessary to adopt such inhuman practices. Pigs are highly intelligent and trainable.Nothing in this world should suffer in order to support the needs of others. Please be gentle with these giving creatures. They are innocent and exploited, and to give their short lives the freedom they deserve in that they give their all to our dinner table is not unreasonable or impractical.Let us show the world what a great country we are.
- Tina Cotton, 9:34 AM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
I believe it is cruel to confine pigs (or any animal) in such small, barren and restrictive conditions. The pigs (and chickens) have endured these conditions for far too long. While I welcome some of the suggestions made by the NAWAC on the pig code, the proposed phase-out periods for stalls and crates is far too generous. Pig farmers have been aware of opposition to sow stalls and farrowing crates for years before now. Eight years is too long a time to continue to inflict these conditions on pigs - we know it is cruel! Please, help put and end to this unfair treatment of animals, please put a prompt end to caged farming. Thank you.
- Amanda McIlhone, 9:24 AM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
Its inhumane and wrong. Animals deserve the same right as humans. It makes me sick knowing that people can be so cruel to animals. How would you like it if yourself or someone you know who didn't even have a chance at life had to be locked in a cage day in day out? I don't think it's fair that because animals can't communicate with us we feel like we can treat them however we want for whatever benefit we want. This needs to stop TODAY!
- Jessica Wallace, 9:17 AM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
I have 2 pigs and know for a fact they have real feelings. Just like you and I need to have space to move, feel the sun on their skin. Pigs are social creatures and need to have space and at LEAST room to move.. OUTSIDE is their real habitat and for them to thrive and most importantly be HAPPY they need space to move, sun and company!
- Brylee Kearse, 9:13 AM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
I can not believe we are allowing such cruelty in New Zealand towards pigs. Farmers who do not provide feed etc for cows or other livestock are prosecuted why should this be any different for pigs. It is disgusting that this is being allowed to happen right in New Zealand. Please change the legislation towards cruelty of pigs. There is a huge response from the public that feel very strongly about this and you and your government are the ones who can help change this. Please John Key listen to your fellow New Zealanders and make a change. Im sure you and your government or any New Zealander would not like to be treated this way and it should be no different for any living thing including PIGS!!!!
- S. Maxwell, 9:05 AM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
It alarms me that this practice is allowed to continue. If this was a human being treating another human being in this manner they would be before the courts and there would be serious consequences for their actions. The only voice these animals have is ours, and I would very much like to see their safety and welfare a priority- it is long over due.
- Debbie Hawkey, 9:04 AM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
all factory farmed animals are sentient (i.e. capable of feeling pain and pleasure). Animals that are factory farmed are denied pleasure and subjected to enormous pain and an early death. We can all agree that pain is a bad thing when it happens to humans - a thing which ought to prevented where possible. Given that pain is a bad thing when it happens to humans there is no good reason for thinking it is not a bad thing when it happens to animals. The pain of factory farming can be prevented. Therefore, factory farming should be banned.
- Julia Tanner, 8:43 AM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
how can you be so cruel to something so cute and lovely as a wee little pig???
- Zoe Kemp, 8:42 AM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
it ruins our "clean and green" image.
- Dylan Fox, 8:36 AM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
our pigs are breed in wide open spaces. are happy and the meat we end up with john is a toatlly different taste altogether. i havent brought factory farmed pig meat for years. this is so wrong that we new zealanders with this clean green image can do this.
- Darrell Wehi, 8:36 AM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
i would like to see sow crates and any crates used to farm pigs be completly banned!!! I have seen free range pigs and piglets and all seem happy and content! so why is this practice continuing!!! Pigs are very intelligent and clean animals if given a chance. I should know I have had a lot to do with them in the past. I plead with you as with the rest of NZ bann these barbaric crates and encourage free range. bottom line is how would you and your cabinate ministers like to spend a few days in a farrowing crate with little or no room to move around and not being able to nurse your family properly!!!
- carolyn Symmans, 8:34 AM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
I have lived next to one here in the South Island and I hated every minute of it. The pigs when you looked in were not in a clean environment and after seeing that me and my family and many of our friends that saw this too have refrained from eating pig meat again. After you have seen something so savage and cruel you would not eat it either. Please stop from factory farming, not just for pigs but for all animals.
- Nicketa McConachy, 8:33 AM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
all this makes me think twice if i really want to buy pork related products, i wouldn't hesitate to buy if i knew their life had been lived out in a humane way.
- Carol Turner, 8:28 AM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
It is embarrassing to think, that, as a country we are more concerned with the capitalist return of farming in this manner, than the humanity of life forms. This is a reflection of our individual and national morals. Regards,
- Josie Blade, 8:12 AM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
It is cruel and unnecasary. As humans on this planet it is our responsibility to protect the animals, pigs included.
- Claire, 8:08 AM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
it takes away from the pig many basic functions, and it totally cruel. An animal deserves to be able to turn around, to exercise, to not be so cramped that health problems develop and she is constantly under stress. it is time now to ban this barbaric behaviour.
- rosemary segedin, 7:57 AM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
Its a very cruel and horrible way to farm. Listen to the public and ban these crates!
- Megan, 7:52 AM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
Dear John Key, the public want to see this cruelty to pigs and other intensively farmed animals STOP. Please listen to what the public wants. These animals suffer and its in breach of our welfare laws. How can we allow this to happen?
- Janet Leary, 7:39 AM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
We don't believe any animal should be treated in this cruel, harsh & archaic environment. We can only imagine how awful life must be for these unfortunate pigs. Please support a law change to stop the cruelty to these intelligent animals. Thankyou
- jaynie keir , 7:09 AM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
its a hideous way to farm and we sholud have more respect for everything on our planet regards jules thornburgh
- jules thornburgh, 12:45 AM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
We as Human Beings need to stop the cruelty of these animals. It is cruel and inhumane. This is just another example of how cruel humans can be but aslong as someone is getting a paycheck it doesnt really matter. The crates need to be banned immediately there is no purpose for them but to inflict a life of misery on animal that is providing food an money to us all. It is a living creature that feels pain just like us. Stop the suffering now.
- alisha, 12:12 AM on Thu 15 Apr 2010
it is absolute torture for them to be young piglets and be able to walk around in the tiny pen they are made to so called "live in", then grow slightly larger and not be able to turn around or move back and forth let alone walk, especially in a country with so much land. these animals are very intelligent and should be able to run around and live without being driven to complete insanity. I thought jail was for criminals. Thank you A.Lee
- Abraham Lee, 11:27 PM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
I dont believe that we need to allow the pigs to suffer unnecessarily, for the sake of a farmer making more money. The farmers have a moral obligation that comes with farming animals for a living. This obligation being that the animals be able to spend their time in a manner that more closely ables them to maintain more natural behaviour, as with cows who are able to live relativley normal and happy lives while still contributing to our food needs and our economic needs! I believe stongly that New Zealand should be world leaders in animal welfare for farmed animals, and to set an example. We already have made many bold statements to the world and this would be another good statement to make.
- R Melling, 11:16 PM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
Dont be a fool John. Listen to the people for once.
- James, 10:57 PM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
without question, these animals are deeply affected by their living conditions and the suffering of their fellows. With huge pressure on this country to become the food basket of the world, it is even more important to make bold decisions concerning compassionate farming policies, with care and quality being among our main goals, not bulk and misery.We have led on nuclear-free: lets lead on compassionate farming in the 21st century!Let's also make the point that eating meat to the degree we do contributes hugely to global warming!
- EM SKINNER, 10:38 PM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
it is wrong to treat any creature so badly
- simon fern , 10:20 PM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
of the obvious unnecessary nature of the whole institution. There is no logical basis for the awful treatment that factory farmed animals, especially pigs, are forced to undergo in our country. A country that claims to be clean, green and friendly. The way we treat pigs is none of those things Mr. Key and you are one of the people who is empowered to stop this abominable behaviour. As many years ago we condoned racism, segregation, sexism, slavery, if we now fail to act in tha face of obvious cruelty we will look back in awe of the complete disrespect we have shown for these intelligent, sentient, innocent animals. As our Prime Minister you are uniquely empowered to effect change in our country, and it will be you who is looked back on in years to come when this important issue is considered. You will be looked on either favourably, as a leader who knew when he was seeing something inhumane and grotesque and did everything in his power to stop such behaviour; or in a more negative light, as the man who failed to act because of pressure from a powerful industry supporting the cruelty, or simply due to a lack of empathy and care.
- Natasha Vine, 10:14 PM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
I watched the Sunday documentary on factory farmed pigs with Mike King. The footage was disturbing and, in Mike King's words, harrowing. NZ needs to be a world leader with agricultural standards in sustainability and farming methods. Thanks Mark
- Mark Saunokonoko, 9:55 PM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
Come Awwn we Cant let this Happen. If you want to be in after the next allection DO SOMETHING
- Carl Finlay , 9:52 PM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
Dear Prime Minister, Please support the upgrading of New Zealand farming Practices - we do have the space, skills and compassion to farm both profitably and humanely. Thank you
- Charles Allison, 9:47 PM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
it is wrong, both for the sake of the pigs and the pork industry. what should pigs suffer like that when better quality meat can be produced free range. Pig farmers who do this should be prosecuted and a law should be brought in that all pork from NZ is free range. I really hope you can do something about this and close down these terrible farms.
- Aimee Bennett, 9:45 PM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
no living thing should suffer no matter what it is intended for. We breed these animals so we can eat them, at the very least we have a responsibility to ensure they are treated with respect and the short lives they have are pleasant and free from pain and suffering. I would think this would be the basis of all farming - why is it not??? We as consumers can no longer bury our heads in the sand - if we eat animals that are farmed this way we are a link in the chain of abuse.
- Shelley Pishief, 9:44 PM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
This is a very inhuman way of farming pigs. This is sick and just isn't the way new zealand should treat animals. Pigs are very smart beautiful creatures and if they are in demand for food, it doesn't mean we treat them like products and forget that they have feelings and intellect. I know we cannot stop killing pigs for food, but if we can give them a fair life until they are slaughtered then it should be done. I think pigs deserve better than to spend their whole lives in these conditions. Please think about what you are going to do! Please try and find some compassion and do the right thing, otherwise your as bad as the heartless corrupt minds that try to rule the world and cause pain and destruction for their on beneficial greed. This world needs a change and you can simply start by not going through with these horrible environments that which pigs must be put in. Thanks
- Corey Friedlander, 9:33 PM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
I know you have enough emails to get through so il make it short. If theres anything you can do in your power to help this cause you will forever have my vote. All the best
- Ash Macgroucutt, 9:31 PM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
It is a melting pot for disease. It has been proven that over crowding in humans and animals living - causes all sorts of diseases. The inhuman housing of any animal as we see pigs is an insult on the rest of humanity that believes in a decent repectful life for all living creatures.
- Simmone Eaton, 9:30 PM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
I think that we have a responsibility as human beings to protect other creatures that have the ability to feel pain and stress. I am a vegetarian but I condone people eating animals as long as they have a good life and are killed humanely. You have the power to make a difference, please use that power.
- ellis Prince, 9:30 PM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
this is not the way to farm animals. Come on NZ sort it out!
- Leith Olsen, 9:30 PM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
You have the power to change this. So something, now.
- Jessie McQueen, 9:27 PM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
it is unnecessary - all living things deserve respect. There is plenty of spaces for them to be farmed naturally without harsh treatment.
- Terry, 9:27 PM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
come on john,you know its not ok,have a heart.
- kezia young, 9:23 PM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
Hi John. Just wanted to say that pigs are more intelligent than dogs. NZers do not get away with mistreating dogs without being dealt to by our Justice system. How does this make any sense at all? These pigs are clearly depressed. If you had a family member or domestic pet that appeared to be in this state of mind, you wouldn't mistreat it and make the situation worse unless you were a very cold and heartless person. Please help encourage NZers to do the right thing. If anyone feels the need to eat pork, remember this - a mistreated animal = bad meat. Thank you.
- Julianne de Waard, 9:13 PM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
it is too easy for us to accept what is wrong as the norm when it is behind closed doors and we. don't have to confront it
- Joanne Wilson, 9:08 PM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
New Zealand is proud to be a green country. With your help we could set standards for the rest of the world, or at least be proud to have our own. It would help you win election votes too. Cheers matey.
- Clove Pywell, 8:52 PM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
Pigs have the exact same feelings as us. Love, hate, empathy, happiness, and most of all pain! How would you liked to be locked in a cage so small you cant move?
- simon Dyer, 8:35 PM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
pigs don't need to be treated like they are now.
- SUSAN ZAPOLSKI, 8:34 PM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
it is inhuman and is giving our country a bad name which will impact on our image as a nation.
- Nick Jones, 8:24 PM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
pigs are sentient beings, furthermore they are more intelligent than most animals (Singer, 96 and several others). If New Zealand hopes to become part of the first world countries (democracy/education etc) and already leads the world in anti-nuclear policies it does not fit that such basic animal cruelty is still allowed, when it is outlaws in much of Europe.
- Dr Beverely Steffert, 8:22 PM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
they create horrible and cruel living conditions for animals. No living thing should live this way. Thank you, please help make a better life for all the pigs out there!
- lani Isara, 8:21 PM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
no creatures on earth should be submitted to this misery. If we all speak up, we can lead to change, and live with compassion in our hearts.
- Ami Holifield, 8:21 PM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
As human beings we have control over the welfare of other creatures on this earth. Therefore we have an obligation to prevent their unnecessary suffering, especially when we benefit from their existence, such as when we farm them for food and profit. As leader of our country you have the power to condone of prevent the suffering of millions of farm animals, now and into the future. I ask you to think about this and exert your influence. Many thanks.
- Nicola Manson, 8:16 PM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
it is cruel and the pigs don't deserve it
- alice cuthbert, 8:16 PM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
I have not eaten pork/ham/bacon for over 5 years since I found out the way pigs are farmed. for me this is not a recent thing.
- katie Harris, 8:14 PM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
it is an evil practice based on greed. As the son of a former 'old school' pig farmer I am appalled by the methods deployed by factory farming and ashamed this goes on in NZ in this day and age. We cannot move forward as a civilised society while the Government condones and allows this awful practice.
- Dave W, 8:04 PM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
there is no reason to continue treating pigs in this way except for the following: 1) We, as a nation, lack the capacity to care enough for the welfare of living things in general. 2) Our taste for cheap pork overrides our conscience that tells us to make a stand for what is right. I, for one, do not want to be part of a nation that struggles with these issues and I hope that you share these same sentiments.
- Diane Davenport, 7:49 PM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
I believe that all farmed animals have the right to live in conditions comparable to their natural habitat, where they can exhibit natural behaviour.
- Alice Cranston, 7:43 PM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
I don't understand why creatures that have the capacity to feel, pain, fear, love - just as we do, are subjected to such horrific conditions. Once again, the almighty dollar acts as justification to exploit and torture sentient beings. Maybe consult your heart instead of your wallet once in a while.
- Ben R, 7:33 PM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
I eat pork and all other meat just like the majority of our country, and im sure most of us have a certain idea of the mistreatment animals deal with for us to enjoy these comforts, yet we all hold a blindfold over our eyes to shield the obvious truth. Why should pigs go through this suffering just so we can add an extra dish on to our menues? Do somthing about it!
- David Smythe, 7:31 PM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
this degree of animal cruelty is unacceptable in a civilised country. Free range pork farming is a viable alternative; I promise you free range pork tastes great and is not too expensive. There is no justification for factory farming of animals in New Zealand! Yours sincerely, Judith Stehr
- Judith Stehr, 7:30 PM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
1. It is cruel. 2. All animals that we farm deserve to roam freely within their natural environment. 3. Lets maintain New Zealand's valuable reputation that we care for not only New Zealand, the planet, human being and animals.
- Laura, 6:58 PM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
these beautiful creatures needs to be given a decent live if they are to be farmed.
- Deidre Jackson, 6:58 PM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
Wow I would expect New Zealand to know Better I use to think as a first world country the government will have better laws for the welfare of all animals ....But pigs, cows, and chicken are worse treated here them in some 3 world countries. I can't believe how blind and ignorant some people on our government are, even a kid can tell that this is cruel and that our animals are in pain ...we needed a new law five years ago. How long more can you sit on your table and eat your pork knowing that he never had a chance to live before die, how much worse can you wait things to get before you do something? And I believe 100% if you want so save animals stop eating them.
- Joselayne Macdonald, 6:56 PM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
With all the beautiful countryside we have in New Zealand why do we need to keep these defenseless animals in crates.They deserve to be cared for properly,allowed to roam free in paddocks & forage naturally.The rogues that keep their animals in crates give the rest of the industry a bad name.Please BAN sow & farrowing crates.
- Beryl Nichols, 6:53 PM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
Is eating pork really worth all the pain and stuffering that pigs have to go through everyday? I know i'd rather go without it rather than know that i payed money to consume an animal that has gone through so much trauma and stress.
- becks, 6:47 PM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
I believe all farmed animals should be able to roam freely within their environment, just like all other farm animals.
- Craig Rook, 6:47 PM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
It is horrendous and disgusting. Most people don't ever see what conditions animals live in and try to pretend like it doesn't matter. It sad that as a race we are so heartless towards other living creatures with an equal right to live on this world. Selfish and wrong.
- Rebecca Gordon, 6:45 PM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
I don't want pigs to suffer because I want to eat their meat. They should lead normal lives until the day they die in a paddock. I would rather have less meat available to the consumer than a plentiful supply. Lots of people waste food in NZ, some of us are overweight due to overeating, it wouldn't hurt NZ for there to be less meat available. Nor would it hurt the countries we export to. I'm sure there is a way farmers can supply the market without cruelty, the price may go up but so be it, that is the price of a 'free range' pigs life. Yours Sincerely
- Melissa Shiels , 6:41 PM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
Animals don't build complex tools or plan like humans, but they have the same range of feelings. This is a double hit for them because they can't fight back against our exploitation. Please encourage change that gives as much freedom as possible back to pigs and other sensitive animals.
- Rob Reid, 6:38 PM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
NZ has always taken a leadership role in the international community for its enlightened approach to human rights, animal welfare and the environment. Let's maintain that reputation by declaring that we value all parts of the planet.
- Robyn Bailey, 6:37 PM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
dear John, dont let these poor pigs suffer anymore have a heart,new zealand sends out a clean green message to the world but we have this in our closet come on deal to it now
- judy, 6:08 PM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
It is cruel it breaks my heart to see those pigs unable to move nor turn there needs to be a stop to it it is just not fair for any living thing to have to live or shall i say suffer like this.
- Donna, 6:06 PM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
I have two Kune Kune pigs and they are the most lovable, intelligent clean animals and are no different to owing a dog and we don't treat a dog like these poor animals are treated. These pigs deserve to have a better quality of life whilst they are on this earth. Do the right thing and stop factory farming. :(
- Helen, 5:59 PM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
A) It is incredibly cruel and inhumane. B) A farmer's wife told me recently decent farmers know to keep pigs free to roam and clean hence preventing disease and fetching them a better price ultimately. So I suspect the type of people who use crates are rogues who a good many farmers would like to see prevented from using crates and giving the industry as a whole a bad name. Lastly, from a personal viewpoint my family and I haven't eaten pork for years. I have worked with animals and we understand pigs especially are very intelligent. Thanks and regards (Mrs) Ann Rook 3A Manon Crescent Greenhithe 0632
- Ann Rook, 5:55 PM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
Humans.. Humans the creator and master of all. Just because humans have decided to factory farm pigs does not make it right, factory farming of pigs is a sign that we as the human race need to wake up and say NO. We as the human race are for ever turning this amazing world which we live in, into a world of dispear where we are left thinking why are we letting this happen.
- steven Clunie, 5:53 PM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
it does not even follow the "five freedoms" as defined by the Farm Animal Welfare Council. This states that farmed animals should have: 1. Freedom from hunger and thirst 2. Freedom from discomfort 3. Freedom from pain, injury and disease 4. Freedom to express normal behaviour 5. Freedom from fear and distress Factory farming in sow and farrowing crates does not allow for at least four out of five of these "freedoms" (the only one which is usually followed is freedom from hunger and thirst, but even then, this is not always followed). Something is very wrong when animals are denied these basic rights. Factory farmed pigs are known to be uncomfortable (restrained in such a small space, who would be), they suffer more from disease and can easily injure themselves, they are not free to express normal behaviour, and although harder to prove they do show fear and distress under factory farmed conditions. NZ has a reputation to uphold and factory farmed pigs does nothing positive for our reputation! Please support a ban, effective immediately, as something needs to be done now.
- Willow van As, 5:52 PM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
If a dog was kept in these conditions the SPCA would be informed and the animal would be removed from the situation. Why should an animal be treated like this just because people like to eat them. The ones we slaughter for food should be given the best life to provide the best quality meat. Something needs to be done now. Life is not just about greed.
- Paula Meijer, 5:49 PM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
Its cruel and unfair! How can you hurt these beautiful animals.
- Ally James, 5:47 PM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
it is a most disgusting display of prejudice and greed. Please look at the bigger picture, put money and buisness aside and put yourself in these animals shoes. We have all been desensitized for years to see animals as a product to use and consume. This is unfair. However the world is unfair and if it must be this way then atleast give these incredibly sensitive and intelligent animals the gift of not having to suffer a tormented, cruel life. Will you die with a guilty conscience or not?
- Emma'Jayne Thorpe, 5:45 PM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
As New Zealanders we need to think about what kind of country we want to live in and this includes how we treat our animals. Pigs are smart enough to think, suffer and feel miserable. So lets ban sow and farrowing crates and let them live lives that enhances their existence. It is incredibly cruel for any animal, let alone a highly intelligent, super social animal such as a pig, to have to spend it's whole life in a tiny, tiny pen where it can't even lire down, let alone do all the many things pigs love to do. When a pig lives in these types of conditions, its body produces a lot of extra toxins which will cause your health to deteriorate if you eat it. Please, please, please don't eat pork, bacon or pig products that are not labelled free-range (which is most pork products). If a pig has to die for you - at least let her have a happy life! "The greatness of a nation and its moral progress can be judged by the way its animals are treated." Ghandi
- Charmaine , 5:43 PM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
my partner and i are from France and we came to New Zealand because we wanted to live in a country more aware about issues like this one, a country more respectful, fair, and one who's not afraid to commit against animal cruelty. hoping that New Zealand would lead the way in terms of animal's rights and nature conservation. plenty of foreigners came to live here for the same reasons. New Zealand image is really important for the world, lets not be ashamed of it.
- lise, 5:36 PM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
it is against our image to the world as a clean green country that respects our nature. Although I am a vegan, I respect others wishes to eat meat. If we are to farm animals in New Zealand then I can only support methods which treat the animals with as much respect as we give our pets. Factory farming does not show this respect.
- Maree Stachel-Williamson, 5:28 PM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
this is total cruelity to pigs and pictures/hearing about this has stopped me eating pork under any circumstance!! what's wrong with the old way of farming, free range!!!! Well done to the people that have bought this into the news, more people need to know what's happening to these poor animals
- J Holt, 5:25 PM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
I find it very upsetting. It is even more upsetting when parliamentarians try to justify factory farmed pigs.
- Prem Prasad, 5:19 PM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
because i beleive it is inhumane, when did animal cruelty become legal?! There are laws against cruelty to dogs and cats. so why should we let this legal form of immense cruelty go ahead, why should these animals have to suffer in order for us to buy bacon cheaper? If we let this continue which animal will be next?
- Amanda , 5:03 PM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
cruel conditions in which the pigs are made to live.
- Pia Reid, 5:03 PM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
cruel piaconditions in which the pigs are made to live.
- Pia Reid, 5:02 PM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
even if you ignore the moral argruments e.g. care and respect for other living creatures, it makes NO business sense for New Zealand to treat animals this way. We are viewed as a high quality producer of animals products e.g. our lamb and beef are free range. This fits in well with our clean green image. Farms that do treat pigs with respect and care e.g. Freedom Farms are leading the way. Outlawing sow crates is actually a sound business decision! Thanks.
- Michael Janisch-Lawry, 5:01 PM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
we must show compassion for our animals and set an example to the rest of the world. If a country can have a conscience, please let it be us. Do not let dollars cloud our judgment. Free these poor animals from hell I implore you.
- Susan Brennan-Hodgson, 5:00 PM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
All animals deserve to be treated humanely and with respect and to enjoy a resonable standard of living. This foul and inhumane practice continues to undermine our international reputation as a country where the live stock enjoys the benefits of our fresh pastures, clean air and glorious sunshine. Justifications of any form of factory farming based on supposed animal welfare would be laughable if they weren't so evil and malicious. The ONLY REASON farmers factory farm is MONEY. This is proven by operations like Freedom Farms who produce large amounts of FREE RANGE pork without the need for SOW and Farrowing crates. Please listen to the people who speak for the rights of the animals - the SPCA and SAFE and not to those who have their 'snouts in the money trough' like the Pork board and Federated Farmers.
- Karen Fahey , 4:58 PM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
I dont think it is fair to have pigs in stalls, they should be in paddocks with shelters for them and their piglets. I bet you wouldnt want to work in a place where the sows are covered in flies and probably dont even get to turn over because they are over crowded. Up to you to help out
- Tania Welsh, 4:58 PM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
I am adding my name to the petition to safe-guard the welfare of our pigs. I wholely agree with the ban of farrowly crates as we owe the poor creatures some humility during the short duration of their lives. It is out and out cruelty.
- L Harvie, 4:44 PM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
Animals are reared intensively in battery cages, overcrowded chicken sheds, sow crates, zero-grazing dairy systems, cattle feedlots or veal crates. The animals are forced to grow super-fast, pushed to their physical limits in the quest for more cheap meat, milk or eggs. At the end of their brief lives, millions of animals are transported over great distances in terrible conditions, only to be slaughtered at the journey's end. Industrialized agriculture treats them as little more than meat-, egg-, and milk-making machines. The welfare of animals often loses out to the economic interests of factory farmers.
- Rafael Jovel, 4:43 PM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
it is cruel and unnecessary. I don't know if you've ever had the pleasure of knowing a pig personally. Like all other living beings we share this planet with, they each have their own unique personalities - they're friendly and sociable, funny and clever, and they deserve, have the right, to be treated with much greater empathy and compassion. Mahatma Gandi famously said "The greatness of a nation and its moral progress can be judged by the way its animals are treated."
- Stefanie Young, 4:36 PM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
all animals deserve our care and respect and not to be treated simply as 'economic units of production'. They are sensate and sensative beings with feelings and intelligence. They need stimulation and space.
- Darryl & Maureen Milner, 4:24 PM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
We just need to go by the age-old, but forgotten rule: Never say or do anything to anyone (or any living creature) that you wouldn't have said or done to yourself. It is only greed that leads the farmers to forget their humanity. Let them be penned up, as these pigs are, to experience what they are inflicting on the animals. Absolute Pricks!
- Cherry Estcourt, 4:12 PM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
no living creature should have to endure conditions so far removed from what is natural for them. How would you like to be confined in a space barely large enough to move, to live on concrete, unable to feel grass under your toes or to breathe fresh air? Cramped crowded factory farming is not only cruel it will probably, eventually lead to an outbreak of a new virus which will decimate humanity. New Zealand can do better than this. As our Prime Minister we look to you to stop the suffering.
- Lynne Gilchrist, 4:09 PM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
it is hideously cruel and quite unnecessary. The industry will survive just fine if it swaps to free range farming, and the furor in the media clearly shows that this is what most of the NZ public wants. Not to mention the good it would do to our slowly tarnishing "clean green" image... If you've seen the footage yourself, you should know how those pigs suffer and have a duty to change things. For the voting public if not yourself!
- Miriam Williams, 4:05 PM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
I am a vegetarian and animal lover. Pigs are thought to be one of the smartest animals and their genetic material is reported to be similar to that of humans. I feel that we should treat animals the way we treat humans. We all know that sweatshop work is wrong, why make our animals suffer a similar fate.
- Rebecca Flavell , 3:46 PM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
it is unneccessary for these beautiful creatures to be treated in this manor. Pigs need to be treated well and treasured for what they are. Humans are an excessive species- we will use whatever is in abundance without a care and only appritiate what effects us personally. Pigs- these living creatures should not be factory farmed in these cruel conditions as it makes them just another uncared for resource where they should be treated well and appritiated.
- Sarah Fursdon, 3:35 PM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
it is wrong on so many levels. Have you ever owned a dog? Would you make a dog live like this? A life of misery in a cage without being able to move, only to be finally released to be killed. I am proud to be a New Zealander and I think this country is an amazing place. I believe that we should lead the world on matters such as this and show that it is NOT alright to treat animals in a cruel and thoughtless manner. If we truly 'are what we eat' then surely it is much better and healthier for all concerned to give pigs a bit of respect and let them live what little life they have in a happy environment rather than a miserable one? PLEASE DO THE RIGHT THING and support the ban of sow and farrowing crates. Thanks.
- Tina Suter, 3:28 PM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
the cruelty to all animals must be stopped. There is no need to farm the pigs in such a cruel manner, there are always options. Please help!
- Ros Shutt, 3:27 PM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
it is inhumane. Many citizens are greatly concerned about violence in NZ society. We can hardly expect to live in a kind and caring society if we believe it acceptable to treat defenseless animals in such a cruel manner. I sincerely hope that you will do your utmost to stop this cruel farming pratice. Thank you, Marika Czaja
- Marika Czaja, 3:26 PM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
I am opposed to all cruelty to harmless and helpless creatures. Make NZ stand out even more in the world by upholding high standards of decency toward animals, even piggies! Please!
- Colleen Strother, 3:18 PM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
no animal deserves a life of such torment, cruelty and suffering. Let NZ, like Sweden, set an honorable example to other countries that such animal cruelty is intolerable and that we are a caring nation. What shame I feel for the blind eye we currently turn!
- Carla Sargent, 3:14 PM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
Can you really sit down and enjoy a pork meal after seeing the filthy, disgusting and inhumane way these animals live for their short lives? If they were farm animals they would have better lives and their products would be healthier for us. I wish N.Zers would have the generosity of spirit to stop buying pork across the board until conditions were changed.
- Rae Johnson, 2:55 PM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
I feel that, as with children, we have a responsibility for animals who can't speak for themselves. If we are going to produce and use them then we must be accountable for their welfare.
- Phoebe, 2:54 PM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
Because it is animal cruelty which puts economics before the health and welfare of the animals please stop ignoring this issue of animal welfare and cruelty. I am sure it is also much healthier for humans to eat animals that have had a happy life.
- Helen Oakwood, 2:45 PM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
New Zealand should be leading the world on humane farming. There is no way such confinement of sows in farrowing crates can be considered humane. The reputation of the New Zealand agricultural industry is at stake, and such farming practices show the world we do not care about farm animal welfare in this nation.
- Annie Potts, 2:40 PM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
I think that no matter what economic gain farmers get from this cruel method of farming the suffering is far too great to belive this is acceptable. Consumers are becoming more aware of where their food comes from and surely no-one that has decent morals can think this is fine. Lets get the "clean green" New Zealand image back and stop sacrificing our environment and animals for econic gain. Its shameful!
- Suzannah Dodd, 2:39 PM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
it treats animals as if they were inanimate and without senses. If we were to travel to another planet and witness there some strange alien race 'farming' other creatures on their planet the way we farm pigs here on Earth .. then we would be truly horrified and consider that species evil. There is no reason for us to assume that we have some God-given right to imprison and torture other creatures simply because we are driven by a market economy.
- Bridget Sutherland, 2:39 PM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
it seems both inhumane and unnecessary. I would like New Zealand farmers to aim for quality above quantity: quality of life for the animals, quality of product for the consumers, quality of New Zealand's reputation in the world community.
- Diane Thomson, 2:35 PM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
This is a complete outrage!!!! How completly unacceptable, appalling and ridiculous is keeping any living creature in cage where they can hardly move and can't even turn around!! It's going to be stoped sooner or later! Anyone that thinks these pigs are having ok in these coditions is a complete idoit and/or is being paid to say it! We all know it!!!! If it was ok why would these animals be hidden away ! Why not make the chage now! Everyone wants it and you know it's the right thing to do! Please do it!!! I would be forever grateful X X X X From me and my animals who like to turn around
- Rebecca Baket, 2:21 PM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
its shocking to know that we will make animals suffer just to provide us with cheap meat. If we look for a way to provide high animal welfare both here and with regulations on what is imported we're pushing for a postive move within society, surely this is what we should always be trying for, instead of just looking for what is the cheapest and convienient. If these animals only exist to be killed for us to eat, we could at least offer them a nice if only short life.
- alex knight, 2:14 PM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
surely in New Zealand we have the intelligence and compassion to find a better and kinder way to farm animals. The government has the ability to make a positive change regarding this matter. Please take action now, do the right thing. Ban sow and farrowing crates. Ensure our farm animals are not subject to unnecessary suffering.
- Jane Olsen, 2:13 PM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
all forms of life deserve respect and should be able to live as nature originally intended, rather than this being perverted to satisfy various forms of greed. We ourselves demand certain standards and a quality of life. Surely this should flow into a concern and quality values for those that we raise and care for, be they animal or human. The shoe is on the other foot here and we, unlike others, have the ability and opportunity to choose right from wrong and to do the right thing.
- Victoria Littler, 2:13 PM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
it in human and very cruel, i am a pig owner and our pigs live a free and happy life i dont think people quite ounderstand how intelligent these animals are they are true characters and each with there own personalities , would you treat your beloved cat or dog like this they are more intelligent than a dog and are fully aware of there surroundings , so please think long and hard about your decission , Kind regards Lucy Bain
- lucy bain, 2:11 PM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
I am not an individual with an extreme perspective. I do however find hypocrisy abhorrent. The law states that animals should be allowed to exhibit their normal behavioral patterns and where this is breached it is deemed as animal cruelty. Oh, but not for pigs or chickens folks because that impacts upon our bacon and eggs too much! The people of New Zealand need more "friendly pork" as an option at the supermarket so we can demonstrate with our purchasing power that we find this treatment of pigs unacceptable. Please make an attempt to remove your political cap for a moment and consider the matter from an ethical viewpoint. Is that too much to ask?
- Corban Neeley, 2:11 PM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
We don't need to make pigs suffer! There is no reason for it. Pigs are extremely intelligent animals and will inevitably suffer from the current appalling conditions. Please help us push this issue through to parliament so these conditions can be reviewed and changed. Thank you.
- Heather Johnson, 2:09 PM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
..ANY animal, including pigs deserves the right to a "free" and clean environment to roam at it's will and breath fresh, clean air just as we humans do! I absolutely abhor seeing the conditions of the "caged" pigs, chooks, and also hearing that the dairy cows may suffer a similar fate! I cannot believe that any such behavior his practiced in this country, let alone any other. PLEASE put a stop to all this cruelty and change the NZ and SPCA's policies and laws!! You have the power, I am sure, PLEASE HELP THOSE WHO CANNOT SPEAK FOR THEMSELVES! PLEASE SET THEM FREE AND GIVE THEM THE DIGNITY THEY DESERVE! PLEASE!!! PLEASE!!! PLEASE!!! PLEASE!!! AND... fine those who have kept them in this cruel, cruel way! I implore you!! PLEASE!!!
- Winsome Anderson, 2:08 PM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
of the suffering of being in a confined space for such long periods of time. Pigs don't mind some dirt, but being confined to a small space is very cruel. Look how we keep pigs to help with medical science - for people with heart problems etc. They are all the same species and should be treated with respect.
- G Bonnar, 2:01 PM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
As a consumer of pork I want to know that the meat I purchase has had a reasonable and comfortable life which includes the ability to exhibit natural behaviours and most of all breathe fresh outdoor air.
- Ruth Vaughan, 1:58 PM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
It is a disgusting way to treat animals!!!!! i am sickened by what is happening when i know that there can be a simple solution. please please stop this now
- komal Achari, 1:54 PM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
its breaking the law.its cruel.we need to stop the nonsense, enough said
- a.ngaia, 1:54 PM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
I am a total animal lover, I do not believe we as humans have the right to farm pigs in such a cruel manner. The industry will never cease to exist as there is such a demand for it in society today but we can change the way in which this industry is run. Please set a good example by going against factory farming, I feel that it is so wrong and if you lead by example hopefully others will follow in your footsteps to make that change
- Shakira Camp, 1:43 PM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
What sets humans apart is our ability to protect this planet. We are the only life-form with the ability to differentiate right from wrong. We should not arbitrarily allocate the rights of other life by its intelligence, looks, or taste. Ask yourself, If life from another planet was treating our animals how we do would you find this acceptable? If no, then why do we have the right to do it. You may not be able to change the world but you are in a position to change the laws in New Zealand. Please do the right thing.
- Ben Wilson, 1:43 PM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
I believe that although humans need and should eat meat. It should be raised in a humane way. The distress of all animals make me severely sad and I don't think these animals deserve in any way to be so poorly treated.
- Julie Hansen, 1:34 PM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
Dear Mr Key, We urge you to listen to overwhelming public opinion to ban sow stalls and farrowing crates. Since it is the Code of ‘Welfare’ for Pigs that is being reviewed – please let the ‘welfare’ of the animals it concerns be paramount. The Government should also focus on protecting this country's image on international markets, and look at the premiums which consumers are prepared to pay for cruelty-free products. Allowing the confinement of pigs to continue will cost this country dearly in both reputation and export losses in years to come. LET IT BE THIS GOVERNMENT WHO MAKES THE STAND TO STOP THE BARBARIC PRACTICE THAT SHOULD HAVE BEEN STOPPED LONG AGO. NAWAC continues to argue that stalls and crates cannot be phased out until other "viable options" for pig farming are developed. This is nonsense. All NAWAC members have to do is to speak to free range pig farmers, who will tell them that they are - right now - successfully farming pigs without confining them. I am not a way-out animal rights activist but I certainly see the way these animals are being confined for most of their miserable lives is nothing short of absolute horror and legalized cruelty – it must be stopped in New Zealand. Again, allowing the confinement of pigs to continue will cost this country dearly in both reputation and export losses in years to come.
- Fiona Mackenzie, 1:29 PM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
how that poor pig survived the suffering to get to become the bacon with eggs for breakfast, or the pork roast on a Sunday. Maybe close your eyes for a moment and imagine the pigs anguished life. Perhaps then it may not be quite so tasty.
- Kerry Franklin, 1:23 PM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
it is cruel and prehistoric. NZ should set the standard for free range and sustainable rearing of animals. I lived in England for many years and we are falling well behind the standards set there and elsewhere in Europe. Imagine the suffering - why would we allow it when we could take the opportunity to be progressive in this area? NZers care about this issue. Make it your point to care as well.
- Francelle Lupis, 1:22 PM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
Dear John Key, This has got to stop. It is 100% animal cruelty, they say that pigs are more intelligent than dogs, well would you keep your dog like this? When MONEY comes before animals or people there is something drastically wrong. Please Please Please stop this now. If it is not stopped you will never get my vote, animals cannot speak for themselves so they need us. I cannot believe that the SPCA are allowing this to go on. It needs to stop now, not next week or next month but immediately, go and visit farms like we have seen on TV then see if you can sleep at night knowing that this barbaric farming is going on to day. Thank you ...
- Anne James, 1:22 PM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
I will not buy any meat from farms that I consider do not treat their animals decently. Factory farming is a disgrace. No one should be able to profit from keeping animals in such unnatural, disgraceful conditions.
- Jeanette McIntosh, 1:20 PM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
I HAVE STOPPED BUING A LOT OF MEAT, BECAUSE OF THE DREADFUL CONDITIONS AND TREATMENT OF OUR ANIMALS IN NZ, THIS IS APPALING, I ALWAYS BELIEVED THAT OUR COUNTRY WAS BETTER THAN THIS, PLEASE DO SOMETHING NOW NOT IN YEARS TO COME. IF YOU WERE IN PAIN YOU WOULD WANT SOMETHING DONE NOW ,NOT IN A FEW YEARS AFT EVERYONE HAD A TURN TO DISCUSS IT FIRST. WHY IS IT THAT HUMANS THINK THEY ARE BETTER THAN ANY OTHER LIVING THING ON THIS PLANET, WE ARE NOT. YOURS SINCERLY MAREE FOSTER
- maree foster, 1:18 PM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
I think the reasons are obvious enough.
- kate alison, 1:17 PM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
its cruel. Its put me off pork. I thought we were about being clean and green. Cheers, Jo Rolston
- Joanne Rolston, 1:10 PM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
I can't believe that with all our animal cruelty laws for pets etc, that pigs and chickens are kept in such cruel conditions. It is prehistoric. COME ON!!
- Emily and Daniel Hunter, 1:09 PM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
if as Mahatma Gandhi says: "The greatness of a nation and its moral progress can be judged by the way its animals are treated" then NZ has absolutely nothing to be proud of.
- Helen Stancliffe, 1:09 PM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
If people knew the conditions these pigs had to endure to become bacon for brekkie, I'm sure there would be 100% more vegetarians out there! I beleive if you would not personally do something cruel to an animal, then why would you pay a factory farmer to do the same terrible deed. Do to others (including pigs) what you would have done to you!!!
- Jennifer Fink, 1:07 PM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
It is quite shameful the way we treat our fellow animals. These beautiful creatures are killed so we can enjoy their meat; the least we can do is give them the respect any living being deserves while alive & treat them accordingly. Fresh water & food, sunshine, grass under their feet & shelter when needed - it's not rocket science & most definitely time to change these outdated & cruel practices. "Free range" needs to become the only option & if that means there is less bacon on the supermarket shelves so be it! It's not like its even a necessary part of the human diet - the same can be said for all farming, that of chickens included - we are so used to having all kinds of meat readily available, farmed at a rate that boggles the mind. It's no wonder our obesity rates are also way up there! It's quality not quantity we need to get back to. Thanks for listening :-)
- Sonja Reynolds, 1:06 PM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
animals are not commodities and they deserve our respect. If we are going to eat animals, then I would like to have confidence that the animal would have had a happy existence before being brought to the table. The scenes shown on TV recently reduced me to tears and it absolutely horrifies me that such practices are allowed to continue. How can these individuals treat such intelligent animals in this cruel manner? I am against factory farming of ALL animals and only buy free range goods. I am happy to pay a little extra and if more us did so, surely the price of these goods would decline over time. Well done all those supermarkets for stocking free range items. In your capacity as Prime Minister please help eradicate factory farming and all the suffering that goes with it. Many, many thanks.
- Hazel Phillips, 12:54 PM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
As a human being , you must have compassion and understanding of pain and suffering. What these highly intelligent animals go through is totally unacceptable. There is no excuse for treating any animal like this. Please use your pwer to do good for these wonderful creatures and improve their lives.
- Elaine Mander, 12:54 PM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
it is a cruel, inhumane way to rear animals. I am ashamed that New Zealand continues to allow factory farms to continue practicing. New Zealand is a country that is meant to pride itself on its 'clean, green' image. Factory farming is NOT clean and it is NOT green. We should not be so lenient with farmers who continue to treat their animals inhumanely. We need change now, not in years to come. Animal cruelty must stop being ignored, Mr. Key. They are living creatures with feelings and just because you cover your ears and eyes to their pain, does not mean they stop living it, enduring it and suffering through it every single day of their miserable lives until they die.
- Rachel Chapman, 12:48 PM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
please stop this terrible cruelty.
- merv , 12:32 PM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
it is unnecesary in New Zealand. We have the opportunity to lead the world by example with humane farming practices. I am on a farm myself and choose to treat our animals in a natural and humane way. The on flow from this is that we have content relaxed stock that keep healthy year round . Healthy stock are cheaper to maintain- an economic benefit that Factory farming underestimates.
- vicky Bethell, 12:22 PM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
This is cruelty
- Stephen Macnaughtan, 12:16 PM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
New Zealand should lead the world in ethical farming techniques. It damages our international reputation to be associated with barbaric and medieval practices such as the use of sow crates. The Government should lead the way in mandating humane practices for our biggest industry. It is not acceptable for a first world nation such as New Zealand to compromise our standards because of petty economic concerns.
- Jarret Filmer, 12:14 PM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
pigs are intelligent,loving wonderful animals that deserve to be treated with respect and love. pigs as indeed all animals have the right to display their natural instincts. i am disgusted that the pig industry thinks the suffering of pigs is ok.
- angela Gardiner, 12:12 PM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
the conditions that the confined pigs have to endure are disgusting, grossly unhygenic and plain cruel. Evidence shows that these shocking conditions are not isolated incidents but spread across the country as common practice. New Zealand must have standards of decency and stop cruel farming practices that cause disease,pain and behavioural distress to the animals. I hope you can impress upon the Pork Industry officials that they must change and yes it will cost them. They can no longer make profits by squeezing the pigs into filthy crates.
- Stephanie McKee, 12:10 PM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
I like to eat pork and I would prefer to know that the animals were farmed in an environment that provided a quality of life. I also believe that free range type farming creates a nicer tasting meat and that I can enjoy my food without any guilt association. I also believe that all creatures deserve to be treated in such a way that benefits all of us. I don't see how keeping them in cages their whole life benefits the industry? Except to make legitimte eaters like me think twice about what, where and who I buy my food from.
- Helen Francis, 12:03 PM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
Pigs are highly intelligent animals and it is obvious this type of farming pains these animals immensely. No animal in their sound mind would chew off another animals tail unless it was under incredible stress. Would you confine your dog or cat to spaces no bigger than themselves? I should think not. And pigs are far smarter than domestic animals, in fact they are up there with dolphins and apes. Sow and farrowing crate farming is barbaric and there is no place in New Zealand for it. I feel all pigs should be free range and us consumers should just have to pay the difference if we wish to eat pork. To make this work I believe we also need to place a ban put on importing cheap pork products so as to not make it difficult for NZ farmers to raise free range animals. Please listen to us – we are the only voice those poor pigs have. Stop this torture now.
- Roxanne Hawthorne, 12:03 PM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
PIGS ARE VERY INTELLIGENT ANIMALS AND IF THIS WAS ANY OTHER ANIMAL IT WOULD BE OUTLAWED.
- Natalie Smith, 11:49 AM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
It is cruel to keep sows in crates. To say it is to protect the baby pigs is a lame reason as 60% other farms do not use this method. Its just all down to making money. My relatives over from England were horrified that we were still using crates. With our clean green image and all the land we have we should be promoting pigs having a good life outdoors if possible. Please Mr Key show you are an animal lover like John Banks and stick up for these defenceless animals. Regards The White Family.
- Catherine & Graham White, 11:45 AM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
No animal should be subjected to such barbaric treatment, I find it repulsive and offensive. NZ should not be using these sick methods of farming.
- Jared Richardson, 11:38 AM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
it ignores any moral right that other species should be afforded to live in a natural environment, and increases psychological suffering and vulnerability to abuse behind 'closed doors' away from the eye of the public. While affording maximum profit to the corporate 'farmer', it minimises employment opportunities and prevents development of stockmanship and animal husbandry skills on the land, through the use of remote automated systems and minimal stimulation. The objectification of other species for financial gain, while ignoring what should in law be their basic rights, is unethical practice.
- Katana, 11:28 AM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
Ive given up factory farmed products because of this disgusting and repulsive practice .These creatures are more intelligent than dogs and we would never allow dogs to be treated this way .Please do something about this now not seven years from now!!!!
- Rhiannon Crabb, 11:20 AM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
This is a disgrace to New Zealand. we need to stop treating these animals in such a brutal and callous manner. They are highly intelligent and suffer 100% of the time they are in the crates. Please stop this now.
- julie cunningham, 11:18 AM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
I care about the welfare of animals and believe there are other options in ways to farm. Also NZs image to world be can improved by being leaders in animal welfare and being innovative in our farming practices. We should be producing high quality, value added products as opposed to mass production.
- Sharon Guytonbeck, 11:13 AM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
Pigs are the real Beautiful People. And they only want to be our friends. And in return for their friendship we torture them. What kind of people are we to treat lovely animals this way? It is worse than slavery ever was. Slaves can escape; pigs never can. All they have to look forward to is suffering and death. And we inflict this cruelty on them purely for our own pleasure. It is a national disgrace. We should hang our heads in shame. New Zealand's name will be mud around the world. Let us do the decent thing and help these lovely creatures. Stop this vile practice NOW.
- Sarah-Jane Spurdle, 11:12 AM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
It is out and out cruelty,, i know as humans we put our heads in the sand at times, but we rely on our government to enforce compassionate farming of our animals as we the public do not realize a lot of the time how inhumane some farming can be. Please change legislation laws NOW
- Corinne Greenwood, 11:08 AM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
pigs are very intelligent animals and this is pure cruelty to keep them cages in a metal pen where they cant turn around or move freely.
- Clare Hoare, 11:00 AM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
it is cruel and inhumane. Greedy materialism allows us to turn a blind eye to cruelty of animals that provide us with money. Pigs deserve better than this revolting practice of locking up. We need to practise our clean green image and provide all animals with a decent lifestyle before they hit the dinner table. Please get all factory farming stopped quickly. Thanking you, Elaine Butler
- Elaine Butler, 10:58 AM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
Factory farming is un-necessary and cruel. Please find a way to farm pigs humanely. Please find a way to farm pigs the "kiwi way." At the moment the "kiwi way" is to direspect treat animals like they are dirt and to abuse them. If this is the "kiwi way" then I no longer wish to be a kiwi.
- James Rapihana, 10:55 AM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
pure cruelty. im not eating pork until mike king says its humane.
- phil wickliffe, 10:55 AM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
..it does not reflect well on New Zealand agriculture. Pig farming methods can be much improved, act quickly and decisively now. Gaynor Hopkins
- gaynor hopkins, 10:49 AM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
it is totally unnecessary for us to treat animals badly so we can eat well. As a confirmed carnivore myself I am in favour of farming animals but believe we have a moral obligation to ensure all animals in our care are well treated. Economics is no excuse for cruelty to animals. Please support this ban on cruel and unnecessary practices in pig farming.
- Sandra Thomson, 10:44 AM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
It is an inhumane way to keep such intelligent creatures. I have completed a study for my vet nursing course which looked at both the intensive and free range methods of raising pigs .Factory farmed pigs show many signs of stress and boredom ie stereotypies ,tail biting etc .I have personally been to an intensive pig farming operation .It was a disturbing and life changing experience .I am repulsed and saddened to know that even though that visit was 25 YEARS ago nothing has changed for these long suffering creatures !!!-all for the sake of saving a few bucks or a little more space etc. something must be done for these tortured souls NOW !!!
- Theresa van Den Bos, 10:41 AM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
it is a barbaric form of farming that most NZ'ers are only now just becoming aware of, due to the great work SAFE is doing in exposing this practice. The only way forward is to stop this type of farming straight away. The cessation of farmers being allowed to use sow crates in 2017 is too far off and means that these beautiful, intelligent animals are doomed to suffer for another seven years.
- Paul Silva, 10:35 AM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
Humane treatment of farmed animals is essential if we are to remain competitive in the global marketplace. The current pig farming situation is one of NZ's dirty secrets. Doing nothing and allowing current disgraceful standards is not an option if we wish to keep marketing to discerning consumers worldwide, who care about where their product comes from and how it was farmed.
- Rosemary Penwarden, 10:33 AM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
Dear John Key, I seek your support to guarantee, the principles of the AWA are uphold, to immediately ban the totally cruel use of sow and farrowing crates, I am tottaly opposed to factory farming because I find cruel Pig farming methods are unjustifiable economically, CRUELTY IS NEVER OK. PRIME MINISTER, please pass my submission on to the NAWAC, and I ASK FOR YOUR SUPPORT TO ENSURE THE CRUEL CONFINEMENTS SYSTEMS THAT PIGS ARE FORCED TO SUFFER, ARE TO LONGER TO BE SUPPORTED INOVERTLY OR OVERTLY IN ANYWAY. THANK YOU.
- Brenda Waldron , 10:32 AM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
Please John, THE GOVERNMENT NEEDS TO WORK WITH NZ PIG FARMERS TO BRING ABOUT DECENT CONDITIONS TO RAISE PIGS WITHOUT CRUELTY AND UNNECESSARY SUFFERING.NOT EVERYONE CAN AFFORD FREE RANGE, IMPORTING PORK AT CHEAPER PRICES THAT HAS BEEN FACTORY FARMED IS NO SOLUTION EITHER. WE NEED TO SUPPORT THE INDUSTRY AND FIND A NEW WAY TO FARM PIGS SUSTAINABLY, NZ COULD LEAD THE WORLD BY EXAMPLE.LETS MAKE IT CLEAN AND GREEN! THANK YOU FOR
- Jacquelin Cran, 10:22 AM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
I don't ask I DEMAND you put a stop to this cruel act, we put you in the position you are in, we can also take you out, so please following through with the promises that you made, we as New Zealanders are sick and tired of promises we WANT ACTION .........NOW, BE A MAN and take a stance agains what is happening behind closed doors to these beautiful animals
- Sonya Mortensen, 10:19 AM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
Every time I see that poor sad pig on TV stuck in a crate it makes me cry.Please stop this kind of treatment to animals.Just because were going to eat them it doesn't mean that they should suffer and have a cruel life.
- Jennifer Tocker, 10:17 AM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
Please Mr Key animals do not deserve to be treated like this. I am not saying that everyone should be vegetarian but we should treat animals with more respect than we do.
- Roger Pym, 10:17 AM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
I love animals and think that societies and individuals can be judged by how they treat powerless people and animals
- julia struyck, 10:15 AM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
we are meant to be clean, green,have good welfare for our animals. what a joke!We should have another campaign 55% pure!
- roy moore, 10:14 AM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
i know i would not like to live in that kind of style if i was a pig, use our country grass, pastures paddocks etc to give a pig a decent uncaged life - imagine if you were a pig john key would you like to be kept in a cage or crate for all of your life?
- stephen, 10:12 AM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
no creature should have to suffer through what pigs in sow crates are currently suffering through. It is cruel torture you wouldn't allow this happen to a animal like a cat or dog so dont allow this to happen to innocent pigs.
- Tanya Langley, 10:11 AM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
dear john key it is sooo sad how pigs have to suffer like this its not fair.all goverments should stop killing our pigs and stop all factory works.i wanted to write to you because i think it is very important to stop what they are doing to our pigs.When i first seen the add i wanted to cry.So i hope we can try stop themkilling our pigs...your faithful Tameka
- Tameka, 10:08 AM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
it does not let animals express their natural behaviours. Cost will never justify cruelty and NZ should be a world leader in farming and not the last to consider animal welfare.
- Jacqui Eyley, 10:07 AM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
it is arrogant of us as a species to treat other intelligent species in such a horrible, and unnecessarily inhumane way.
- Andrea Crowhurst, 10:06 AM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
It is a barbaric industry It goes against the kiwi identity It is so foul it is hidden behind closed doors If we are to be a proud nation everything we do should be upfront - when put upfront most kiwis are against factory farming. It would do a lot for your profile domestically and internationally to make a stand on this issue.
- andrew mcgregor, 10:06 AM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
it is an unnecessary and cruel practice of pig farming. As farmers and meat eaters we have moral responsibilities to these animals; Their suffering, or lack of it, their happiness, or animal misery are down to us. This is called "animal husbandry". Good husbandry, the most basic responsibility of the farmer- adequate husbandry, if you like- is to maintain the health of his/her livestock. With the rate of premature death reaching 5-15% it seems reasonable to question the true health of these animals. This is not even accounting for the ones that reach slaughter, with broken legs/ bones, tumours and other such defects. It is about time everyone removed their blinkers and stop taking such a narrow minded and helpless view on this issue. Ignoring the problem won't make it go away!
- Nicole Matthews, 9:59 AM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
I was a vegetarian until the age of ten and I cannot tolerate any form of cruelty towards animals. I understand meat is a big part of our economy via exports but I believe with a change in thinking, NZ could lead the world in free range (meat)farming as well as organic fruit and vege farming and sustainable fishing.
- Tahi Vaneveld, 9:48 AM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
of its obvious cruelty, cruelty other animals are protected from. It's unreasonable to allow farmers to treat pigs like this. The Code system isn't working if it can allow such severe confinement. Please step in and help these poor miserable animals. Ensure a complete ban on all cages, partial bans wont be policed. If this is a lost cause the law continues to perpetuate such horrific practices at least rename the Codes 'Codes for Animal Abusers': they don't protect pigs they protect farmers. The system is misleading and disingenuous, it wrongly gives the impression the NZ government cares about our animals.
- Deidre Bourke, 9:46 AM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
The practice of using these crates is extremely cruel to pigs. Pig farmers say that banning the use of crates will result in more pig meat being imported from countries that use crates and that care even less about animal welfare. In this case, government should ban meat imports from these countries, which would encourage NZers to buy local produce that has been ethically farmed.
- Kiri Tuhura, 9:45 AM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
it is disgusting that we allow animals to be treated this way in this country.
- Dallas Maskovich, 9:43 AM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
I am opposed of the factory farming because of the suffering of the animals
- Paula Fisher, 9:43 AM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
it is an inhuman way of farming. We wouldn't treat our domestic animals this way, infact we would be prosecuted if our dogs or cats were found living in these sorts of conditions. Pigs are extremely intelligent animals, who naturally root around in the dirt. To keep pigs locked in sow and farrowing crates for their entire lives is so cruel. Please do the right thing John Key and ban these horrible confinement systems for NZ pigs. Sheena Beaton
- Sheena Beaton, 9:43 AM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
It is a cruel and inhumane practise. Despite its size, New Zealand has been a fore-runner in the liberation of individuals from suppression and tyranny.Like us, pigs are intelligent, expressive and social creatures. Like us, they deserve compassion & respect and to live a life free from abuse, incarceration and exploitation. Without steps taken by you and the New Zealand government, they are condemned to hell on earth. There is no explanation from anybody that can justify what they suffer through.There is no excuse acceptable to your conscience or mine, for not taking action to bring a stop to this atrocity.Thank you, on behalf of those who cannot speak for themselves.
- Monique Le Roux, 9:41 AM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
please protect animal rights
- janaki kandula, 9:22 AM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
This practice is ethically and morally wrong. I would love to see ministerial support for this cause to improve the conditions of farmed pigs. Since this inhumane practice of farming in crates has been bought to my families attention we no longer buy pork products other than certified free range products and are happy to pay extra and know that the animal welfare stardards have been high throughout the life of the animal.
- Leah Hauraki, 9:20 AM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
i know i would not like to live in that kind of style if i was a pig, use our country grass, pastures paddocks etc to give a pig a decent uncaged life - imagine if you were a pig john key would you like to be kept in a cage or crate for all of your life?
- Taija Hooper, 9:19 AM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
it is completely unnecessary, not to mention archaic in our society, to use these farming methods. We know they are inhumane, we know the animals suffer - there is absolutely no excuse.
- Anna Delaney, 9:15 AM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
It is really upsetting to see images of pigs living in cramped, filthy stalls – hardly able move and visibly unhappy. As intelligent animals, their cries for help are unbearable to hear; they are constantly upset and frustrated. The mistreatment and abuse of these clever and helpless animals must stop now.
- Eve, 9:07 AM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
we feel strongly that something has to be done and very quickly. In this day and age of health conscious living, it is absolutely disgraceful that this is allowed to continue. We look forward to some improvements, soon. Yours faithfully, Pam Chapman
- pam chapman, 9:00 AM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
no feeling creature should have to suffer like these poor pigs suffer. It doesnt have to be this way and just like New Zealand was a world leader in becoming nuclear free we can also lead the world in the right and humane treatment of animals.
- Angela Wharerau, 9:00 AM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
It is disgusting and you would have to be crazy to allow this to happen!! Please stop the factory farming of pigs!!!!!!!! The decision rest in your hands! Thanks Olivia
- olivia, 8:59 AM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
It keeps animals situated in stimulus free surroundings where they have little chance of expressing basic behaviours. The Animal Welfare Act certainly doesn't condone this treatment, but many years of cruel industry-designed codes implemented by NAWAC have guaranteed a free ride for pig farmers because of public ignorance of the issue. This has changed, and the buck stops with your government. Either pig farmers will be allowed to continue sacrificing welfare to chase dwindling profits by competing with offshore producers on price, or your government can act ethically to resolve welfare issues and clean up an industry which is currently a disgrace to New Zealand's international image.
- Douglas Horrell, 8:58 AM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
..there is no justification for this cruel, lazy, greedy farm practice and will not buy bacon or ham until there is a change.
- Hugh, 8:53 AM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
It was Ghandi that said " the moral progress of a nation can be judged by the way it treats it's animals " Com'on we lead the world in taking a stand on the No-Nukes thing - let's do likewise with this issue !!
- Campbell Fraser, 8:50 AM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
of the suffering of the animals. Pigs are very intelligent beings and deserve to be kept in natural surroundings with the ability to run free through grass and in sunlight. In Canterbury, there are several piggeries that I know of that keep pigs in this way. The animals are healthy and happy and the farmers obviously find it a viable and cost effective way of farming their pigs. There is no reason why we need to factory farm animals in New Zealand and I ask that you stop this disgusting method of farming immediately. Yours sincerely Anne McAulay
- Anne McAulay, 8:47 AM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
Hi i'm breanna and i'm 11 years old,i feel so strongly against factory farmed pigs because they never get a chance to live a good life, except for the one that they have cooped up in cages all their lives forced to reproduce and then die.How would you feel if that happened to you? I know personally, i would hate it. Please make factory farming illegal, because pigs all over new zealand are suffering a horrendus life. i met you on your visit to open the freeman block at glendowie primary school, and i was strongly impressed, i'm sure you'll do the right thing. Hope to see this new law in place soon Breanna
- Breanna, 8:47 AM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
As you are aware thousands of sows are cruelly confined in tiny stalls and farrowing crates which are in breach of the Animal Welfare Act 1999 (AWA). The pig code is under review however I lack confidence that the National Animal Welfare Advisory Committee (NAWAC) will phase out these appalling confinement systems despite widespread public opposition. This is my submission calling on NAWAC to a) uphold the principles of the AWA and b) ban sow stalls and farrowing crates immediately. Pigs have suffered for too many years. Prime Minister, please pass my submission on to NAWAC and I ask you to use your influence to ensure that pigs no longer have to endure these cruel confinement systems. Thank you.
- Delphine Volf, 8:47 AM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
it is cruel and draconian. How can we as NZ'rs allow this to happen? Please move quickly on a total ban. Regards, Daniel Thurston
- daniel thurston, 8:46 AM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
There is no need to produce meat in a way which is cruel to the animal. I no longer eat pork or bacon because I do not wish to support this practice.
- Irene Cross, 8:44 AM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
It has been found that pigs are more intelligent than dogs. We make a fuss about the our pets and when an animal is seen as food, we treatment to them like dirt. All animals deserve a life that is worth living. Sows in stalls are deprived of the strongest instinct in all living beings, that of nurturing their young. As Annie Besant said: 'The general rule is: support your physical life at the smallest possible cost of pain to the lower lives.' We urge you to usher in a new era in New Zealand where all life is respected.
- Sushma Webber, 8:34 AM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
a national shows how civilised it is by the way it treats it's animals. have compassion, you know it's wrong.
- Vicki Baker, 8:30 AM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
It is not humane to keep pigs this way. New Zealand has a green, clean image. This does not fit the bill. Surely there is more than enough land to farm pigs in a better way. How do these farmers get away with it. New Zealand need tighter controls and proper management that see the end to this kind of cruelty. I believe that a man of your position could stop this? PLease! Thank you for taking the time to read my message and I sincerely hope that by listening to the New Zealand public, this kind of cruelty will come to an end.
- Wendy, 8:23 AM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
we are compassionate people. We are also intelligent and with a little thought, understand how terrible it must be to be confined as pigs are and how inhumane it wild beasts)is to do so. Animals may be bred to feed humans, but we can at least give their life some semblance of dignity and one without suffering. If it were done to horses, their would be an outcry. Please please stop it.
- Mark Connell, 8:22 AM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
All animals have the right to have the sun on their backs and the wind in their face. Just because they are going to slaughtered for meat it does not mean that they are not entitled to a quality life. Just for one moment put yourself in the position of a pig in a crate. The lights are dark and the stench unbearable. In this day and age these practises should be a thing of the past. We should be proud of our animal rearing systems not disgusted!
- Pauline Telford, 8:21 AM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
in order for us to grow as a society, we must treat each member of socuety with respect. This includes the pigs that we use for food. Each non-human animal should have at least a reasonable degree of freedom of movement so that they are able to perform all behaviours in their behavioural repertoire. As a country with laws that are based on respect, we should give our pigs the respect they deserve as living creatures and afford them at least the freedom to move around, groom, socialise and carry out all other behaviours that are necessary to their physical and psychological well being. Please hear our submissions and do what you feel is fair for the pigs of New Zealand,put their well being above monetary concerns. PLEASE.
- Kate Tappenden, 8:17 AM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
Just because they are animials does not mean they should be treated this way it is wrong!!!!! We can get readily available free range chickens now lets get the same for the pigs!!! Please, any ill treatment of animals is always highlighted, this needs to be highlighted and stopped. Humans are the most cruel of all species yet we have the abilities to change that, so lets do it.
- Rachel Bakker-Smith, 8:17 AM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
Animals love people unconditionally and we treat them terribly, all they want is a little care so please ban factory farming and all other cruelty towards animals.
- Jade Nichols, 8:15 AM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
it is cruel and disgusting. It is bad enough that you even briefly considered factory farming cows. Have some heart and stop disappointing New Zealand.
- Ally Garrett, 8:15 AM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
its unnecessary and horrible. I dont support any form of factory farming, and neither should you. We need a culture change in this country. We are a nation that achieves firsts, we lead modestly, without too much fanfare - its one of our strengths. We can do business ethically and still make money. I work on a dairy farm, and feed pigs every day. They are cool creatures and no animal deserves a life of horror and hardship just so we can eat it. Please use your influence and ban the crates. Many thanks, Maria
- Maria Butler, 8:14 AM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
I believe that all animals have feelings and rights and they do not deserve to be treated this way. Pigs are very smart! How can we be expected to treat humans better when we treat animals so disgusting. What have they ever done to us?
- Alisa Nichols, 8:14 AM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
I am a parent and I want my children to learn about rspect, responsibility and accountability. They like the taste of meat and are educated about where it comes from, and the most common conditions various animals are raised in here in New Zealand. Neither my 10 nor 8 year olds will eat pig meat if it is not free range, they understand the lack of respect shown to caged animals. I want New Zealand farmers to respect to the animals they are responsible for, all farm animals should be free to display normal behaviours. This can not be done by keeping pigs in cages for ANY length of time.
- amanda bowen, 8:04 AM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
I am a New Zealander! We do the right thing by the animals, land and the people! We need to stop this cruelty to pigs! we need to do what we know is right and humane.
- victoria kloet, 8:03 AM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
pigs are beautiful animals and shouldnt be treated the way they are. Please stop factory farming
- Libby Lorimer, 8:03 AM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
Dear Prime Minister, cruelty to animals does not become New Zealand. Lets take a stance on this, change the way pigs are farmed and lead the world by example, like our anti-nulear stance. Surely we can find a more humane innovative way. I have not bought pork since I first saw these barbaric pictures and won't until I can buy it without feeling guilty. Karen
- K. Renouf, 8:00 AM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
how can it be fair that an animal which has rights as well be confined to such a small space, we would not allow humans to be treated in this way and just because they are animals and cannot voice their opinion someone needs to do it for them. This is totally not acceptable, it is cruel, inhumane I would think that this would no be something you would allow. How would you like to be confined to such a space? It wouldn't be allowed.... Think about it!
- Rebeccah Wilson, 7:51 AM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
Dear John Key, Factory farmed pigs have suffered enough. Please support a ban of both sow and farrowing crates because they both break the law and are equally cruel. I am opposed to factory farming because pigs are intelligent animals and would be completely miserable kept in this condition. It must stop. I will not buy (anything except free range) pork until it does. Kind regards, Karey
- Karey Walker, 7:49 AM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
what is the difference between cruelty to pigs and cruelty to dogs, cats or horses. Many people are charged for cruelty towards the latter every year, for issues such as malnutrition or not providing ethical living arrangements. There should be no distinction between private pet owners and large-scale farming operations when it comes to animal welfare. Pigs are intelligent, sentient beings; if we were cage-farming worms it may be different, but we're not. As with whaling, we need to keep being a progressive country that recognises and upholds the diversity of the life around us.
- Maria Galbraith, 7:46 AM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
Everyone knows in their hearts that these barbaric practices are wrong, but they forget, and slide into denial. Please stop it now.
- Coralie Hunter, 7:32 AM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
The way we are treating pigs is completely devoid of mercy. The crate is an out-of-date and barbaric method of factory farming and should be illegal in New Zealand, just as it has been in the UK since 1999.
- J Daugherty, 7:29 AM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
pigs are highly intelligent creatures and there is no need keep them in such cruel conditions just so that they can satisfy human cravings for cheap meat. Let's have a conscience and live up to our clean, green name. Pigs deserve much better treatment than they receive!
- Stephanie Trail, 7:20 AM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
we should not consider that we have the right to treat an animal, who has a nervous system, feels pain, raises a family, as solely product for our convenience and subject it to a life of misery. I also feel that the labelling of "method of farming" should become mandatory, as with battery hens.
- Angela Mills, 7:09 AM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
Dear Prime Minister, Allowing pigs to be treated in this way is appalling. I think it is so cruel. To treat any animal (and we are one) in this way is so inhumane. Like any animal they have a right to be treated with respect, just like we do, they have feelings just like we do. This is unacceptable New Zealand. Please use your influence to ban these crates. Animals have suffered for far too long. Thank you D. Watson
- D. Watson, 7:02 AM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
it's inhumane and disgusting! If we don't fight for them who will.
- Leigh-Moana, 6:24 AM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
Pigs are very intelligent & no animal deserves to be treated this way. Our current treatment is 3rd world. My family is appalled at the state of this industry. Thankyou.
- ken hansen, 6:22 AM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
it is not natural for these animals to live this way. We have a responsibility to care for our produce, especially live produce. To ensure the well being of the animal and the quality of this to the consumer. New Zealand should be world known for its humanity and quality, that will set it apart on the planet.
- TRUDIE MOOREHEAD, 6:16 AM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
these practices are draconian and only go to show that humans who cherish money and status above everything else don't care what they do to the planet and the species that they share it with.
- Sam Dixon, 5:59 AM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
Every animal and living being on this amazing planet has the right to live a happy and healthy life like us. You have the power to ensure that the appropriate action is taken immediately to make these poor innocent and extremely intelligent animals safe from harm. I would love to have the honor and opportunity to be in a position such as yours to make this change for them. Please may your actions speak louder than words and may this decision add value and humanity to your life and your loved ones. Help these helpless animals i pray for you to do the right thing. Thank you Joanna
- joanna fletcher, 5:12 AM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
I believe all animals deserve to be treated with respect, even ones bred to be eaten. I'm not a vegetarian but do purchase free range pork because I believe cruel farming techniques, such as placing pigs in sow crates for months on end, is disgusting. This practice is not good animal husbandry, it's done solely to maximise profits. If this is not enough to convince you that we need to act immediately here, I will add this is just another issue that threatens New Zealand's reputation globally. In the past New Zealand could hide these ugly practices through effective PR and canny marketing. Not any more, YouTube and other communication mediums are being used to expose us "warts and all" to the world. The best ham I have ever tasted by far was Duchy of Cornwall ham. I believe after tasting a product of this calibre most people would be prepared to pay more for this privilege. To find out farming should be done please see: http://www.duchyofcornwall.org/aroundtheduchy_homefarm.htm We need to set the bar high now if we want to retain, not only our own self respect, but also those of our friends abroad. Yours sincerely Suzanne McIntyre
- Suzanne McIntyre, 5:04 AM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
Dear Sir, as a family we are appalled to discover where our pork comes from. We no longer eat pork and abhor the way pig farmers are allowed to keep their stock.We live in such a beautiful country, and have so many forward thinking policies, such as our nuclear free state, i encourage you to bring this forward thinking quality to our agriculture as well.I pray the New Zealand Government will be brave and take a stand against this appalling process of producing meat, in our "Clean green country". Let us show the world that like our nuclear free state we can also lead the world in the way we produce our primary products. Thank you for your assistance in this matter. Gordge Family.
- Belinda Gordge, 5:03 AM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
it is cruel to treat any living creature in this way. New Zealanders regard themselves as good, civilised people who lead the world in so many forward thinking issues. Now is the time to take the lead by example and stop this cruel practice.
- Linda Fuller, 4:25 AM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
it's a disgusting way to treat animals. The only reason farmers do this is because it's the cheapest way to farm pigs. It's bad enough that farm animals are shipped off to the freezing works and slaughtered for food. At least their short lives should be of a reasonable quality. At the end of the day it always comes down to money. Personally I don't know how anyone could earn a living treating animals this way, it's unacceptable.
- Philip McKay, 2:32 AM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
Apart from making a joke of our green image (that is, if there is one) cruelty to humans and animals, is not acceptable and reflects badly on us as so called "civilised" beings.
- Patricia Lee, 2:22 AM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
Pigs are cool animals with great intelligence & personalities. I believe that all animals, even if they are farmed purely for the purpose of eating deserve a happy, healthy life & a quick, humane death.
- Sue Tippett , 1:57 AM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
the day I have faith in the national party, is the day they have compassion for animals such as pigs and the fair treatment of them. As to date, since the election, all concerns have been not aimed at humanitarian affairs, but rather political, and economical. Well. Think of it this way. If all of us who want pens for pigs to banned don't eat any pork, or meat which comes from farms which the animals are treated badly, then the economy will take a dive. therefore, to care about economy, you need to care about the rights of others and their well being too.
- Jenna Milesi, 1:15 AM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
Allowing pigs to be treated in this way is appalling and hypocritical. Pigs are as smart, if not smarter, than your average dog, yet if dogs or cats were being treated in the same way the whole country would run riot! Be consistent and have the same rules apply for all animals - dog, cat, rabbit, pig, horse, cow... all of them!
- LHERICEL, 1:00 AM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
New Zealand is better than this.
- Elisabeth Fraser, 12:22 AM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
It is simply wrong and unnecessary....where does it stop? Here we hope.
- Richard Vear, 12:06 AM on Wed 14 Apr 2010
it is just plain old wrong. Shame shame shame. Be a leader Mr Key, stand up. I DARE YOU!
- Mr Michael Muller, 11:58 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
it is inhumane. I am appalled at these practices, that the so called intelligent species of man can dominate and condone this treatment of a fellow living creature. Raise the price, let people pay for the life they eat but make it a quality of life. Respect the laws. Have some integrity and humanity, you will sleep better at night.
- Mrs Jamie Muller, 11:55 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
animals feel pain too. They are sentient creatures and pigs are especially intelligent. If we can imagine being confined to a very small room with no space to move, that's what these factory farmed pigs experience. It's just so cruel. Please use your influence to ban these crates and set the pigs free.
- Isha Edwards, 11:53 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
Pleae Mr. Key, This is not about stopping people eating meat but about caring for animals, they have a right to have some sort of life whilst they are alive, go and have a look for yourself at the terrible conditions. Jacquie
- Jacquie Green, 11:24 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
After watching the cooking programmes last week one contestant was told off for cruelty to crayfish because of the slow death she delivered. She was told that all chefs respect there products. With pork we are unable to say this. We can farm without cruelty so lets do this.
- Beverley Johnston, 11:21 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
John Key how do you think our children feel when they see how much the pigs are suffering and the adults in power are do nothing about it especially our Prime Minister? Why is profit the focus instead or the welfare of our animals NZ was always a country that cared about animals and children so what is happening to all of us that we can let this appalling treatment continue PLEASE HELP.
- Trish Forbes, 11:05 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
Allowing pigs to be treated in this way is appalling and hypocritical. Pigs are as smart, if not smarter, than your average dog, yet if dogs or cats were being treated in the same way the whole country would run riot! Be consistent and have the same rules apply for all animals - dog, cat, rabbit, pig, horse, cow... all of them!
- Sarah Rogers, 11:04 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
I feel that every living thing is entitled to the ability to have a good quality of life. Just because we as humans have determined that this animal is a food source does that also mean we have the power to decide that it is not worthy of having a good life? Who do we think we are to be judge and jury over such a things. I can not imagine what the pigs go through having to spend there entire life couped up in crates. For goodness sake if they are going to be giving there life up to provide us with a food source the least we can do is give them a good life while they have one. PLEASE do the right thing don't allow this type of farming to continue....Thank you
- Marama Tauroa, 10:54 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
The way these animals are treated is appalling.This is purely for humans to make more money from them. The very least that should happen is that the animals should be able to live a normal healthy life. They are not machines.
- sue letchford, 10:49 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
there are obviously far better examples of animal husbandry both here in New Zealand and overseas, in the form of free range or semi free range farming so why even bother farming in such an unnecessary way unless its for profit over product. I for one shall not be buying pork now or in the future unless I know it is free range. So there goes any profit the factory farm pork industry intends to make off me and hopefully many others shall do the same - protest with their wallets.
- Debra Tunnicliffe, 10:48 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
I believe in treating others the way we would expect to be treated ourselves and this includes animals. Pigs feel pain and stress in the same way that we do and it sickens me that this type of farming continues to happen in New Zealand. I am a farmer myself and I know that there are better methods for farming pork in New Zealand. Please put a stop to factory farming!
- Amy Robinson, 10:46 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
Dear Mr Key, I am totally opposed to factory farming of any animals. It is cruel and an unnatural way for any animal to live out it's life. The proposed changes to the law regarding factory farming need to be in place sooner rather than later. There is no feasible reason for this form of farming to be allowed to continue. Please support a ban of sow and farrowing crates. All animals deserve respect and a decent quality of life. Thank you.
- Glenda Duff, 10:33 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
No animal should have to suffer like this. If we are going to eat them, at least we can respect them and make sure that they are not forced to suffer due to the greed of humanity. Such immense cruelty is unnecessary and in the long run detrimental to all concerned. Please act to stop this cruelty NOW!!!!
- Judy Brooking, 10:30 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
it is so very cruel. Animals are sentient beings who feel pain and should live, their often very short lives, as naturally as possible free of pain and suffering. Factory farming is undeniably inhumane. It ignores and perpetuates the enormous suffering of animals. This is a fact which we cannot and should not keep ignoring. Many countries have banned the practice of sow and farrowing crates because it is cruel, and in effect cruelty to animals is outlawed in New Zealand, but why oh why do we still have sow and farrowing crates? All of my friends and family are upset and/or so appalled by it, that they can barely think about it. The measure of how civilized a society is is shown in the way it treats its animals and New Zealand has legislated against cruelty to animals. Please, oh please, put it into practice this law for all our animals! Furthermore, factory farming increases
- patricia callis, 10:20 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
it is just so wrong to see the pigs suffering. They are such amazing intelligent creatures and deserve more from us. As a voter, I voted for you in last election, so please listen to me and the rest of your voters who oppose this torture. Please Prime Minister, make us proud and end this cruelty once and for all.
- Tracy Malone, 10:18 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
Farmers will learn that there is more money to be made from a happy animal than an unhappy animal and the whole country will benifit from this ,just the fact that we would produce the best met in the world would bring about premium prices and having happy animals wold go a long way to bringing this about .Not just pigs ,sheep and beef to _no more cutting dairy cows tails off the country looses a lot in production as cows come under stress from not being able to protect themselves from flies without their tails .This also tell me where the dairy head space is ,in regards to the cattle they are entrusted with.
- Mark Adams, 10:09 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
it is completely unnecessary. Pigs can be farmed in a humane way so why arent they? We have sheep, cows and hens all being kept in 'free range' environments - lets now extend this to pigs.
- Fiona Doull, 10:07 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
Sometimes politicians simply have to do the right thing. Allowing cruelty to pigs is simply evil. If you don't stop this then what sort of a man are you. How can you justify this to your grandchildren.Stand up to big business just once in yuor life
- Denis Burrow, 10:03 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
it is inhumane and unnecessary. it also produces inferior meat. :-) while i don't personally eat pig meat, i have friends who do, and they all insist that free range bacon is better.
- terangimarie, 10:01 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
it's a horrible way to spend a life! A simple way to think about the cage pig farming is would YOU be happy to spend your life in a small cage that you can hardly move in, and that same cage is where you have to go toilet as well? Just something to think about. If only pigs could talk, what would they tell us? Nothing good :-( YOU have the power to change that, go on, so many PIGS and people will be grateful! :-) :-)
- Jodi Hussey, 9:58 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
There is simply no need for this senseless cruelty to these intelligent animals.
- Nicola Barnett, 9:58 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
It is cruel and not the sort of farming we should have in New Zealand. Eat free range and while it is more expensive we only eat half the quantity we used to.
- LI, 9:58 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
It is inhumane and there is no reason to keep pigs this way apart from greed. Why can't pigs roam free like sheep and cows? Although some people want to cage sheep and cows as well, are you going to let them and be personally responsible for the suffering of hundreds of thousands of innocent animals?
- Rose Arthur, 9:49 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
Dear John Key It's a half .No more cruelty ,we have to band the crates.I am a chef and i use free range pork,the test is better ,it,s tender and i don't have anymore complain from the customers,in fact it is now my signature dish on the menu.New Zealand suppose to be a green country.What happen??
- Jean-Philippe, 9:44 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
it is detrimental to the future of NZ's agricultural economy, much like the proposed stall farming of dairy cattle in the McKenzie Country is a short sighted venture that will ultimately destroy our dairy export industry. Pigs are highly intelligent animals. Most people accept that animals are farmed for meat, but I have been appalled by the recent media exposure of animal neglect on farms in ths country. Shame on the NZ Pork Board!
- Georgia Patterson, 9:39 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
pigs are intelligent animals and to be caged like they are is very crewel do something to stop it now
- bill riley, 9:38 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
It is uncivilised and cruel to treat other species badly for our own benefit. If we can't raise pigs humanely we shouldn't farm and eat them at all.
- Cath Hughes , 9:36 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
I am totally sick of everthing coming down to " how can we make more money "regardless of how we treat animals to get "more money". These innocent pigs have done nothing to us, yet , for the short time they live we make sure they suffer. Its time for it to stop because , as a New Zealander , i would rather be known around the globe for being compassionate towards animals. I believe you can tell a lot about a persons personality by how they treat animals Mr Key......
- Adam Child, 9:35 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
Dear John key, Factory farmed pigs have suffered enough. Please support a ban of both sow and farrowing crates as they both break the law and are equally cruel. I am totally opposed to factory farming because of how these intelligent and lovable animals suffer there whole existance. They should be farmed in a way that allows them to live healthy and natural lives.We owe these beautiful animals this before they become food for some. Please help bring an end to there suffering now.
- Anne Nickless, 9:35 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
please please we must help these helpless animals. the are intelligent and affectionate animals and we must ensure they are treated with kindness and compassion and kept in conditions that are suitable. NO ANIMAL SHOULD EVER BE PENNED OR RESTRICTED IN MOVEMENT FOR ANY REASON.
- susan hay, 9:34 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
Dear Mr Key. My name is Jorhum Walker, I'm a 20 year old student at Otago University. I saw the ad for this organisation on television just before and it made me very sad, as all animal cruelty does. Animals can not defend themselves, and therefore are prone to exploitation but we, as a group, must make a stand so those who can not speak, cry, ask for help, or escape, can live a life deserved, outside of an unhealthy cage. I hope this reaches you in any degree, and I hope you can help and lead a significant change. Thank you for your time - Jorhum Walker
- Jorhum Walker, 9:32 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
We have the intelligence and resources to do better than this. We speak out for those that cannot. Stop this cruelty.
- Angela, 9:31 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
It Is Cruel and Barbaric to Keep any Animal in this condition. We have more than enough room in this Great country to keep these pigs in a more Humane way. How could you allow this to go on!! You are in Charge of the welfare of this Country. The Majority of People are opposed to this BARBARIC Practise! And The way we keep Battery Chook's also. The only People that would agree with this are The Farmers Making the money, And people with no Sense compassion or Morals.
- Sara Robinson, 9:30 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
I have followed a chat recently on facebook and feel as if your interest and your full devotion to reading in full would be much considered. Please click this link: http://www.facebook.com/posted.php?id=12635800428&share_id=110900022275164&comments=1#s110900022275164 The post I want your attention at is the one titled: visiting the states.
- Athena Angelou, 9:27 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
Dear Mr Key,this type of so called farmimg does not make me proud to be a kiwi.You think that we would know better and that money does not make this bad thing right.This is a horrible thing that we do in order to profit,how long until we begin to cage people? Is that right?$$
- D van Delden, 9:23 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
1. It deprives an intelligent animal of experiencing life. 2. It is totally unecessary. 3. There are alternative ways if society still wants to farm and slaughter animals, by at least letting them live their short, short lives in tranquility. Please do not ignore this request, follow the example of the U.K and other developed countries. We are civilised, and this should be demonstrated by how we treat our animal companions as well as other people. Linzi (Australia)
- linzi donlan, 9:20 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
If domestic pets were kept in the conditions sows are kept in there would be an uproar in our society because it is a very inhumane practice. Pigs in sow crates can only stand up or lie down and face only one way the entire time they are in the crate. They should be able to do more than just stand up and lie down. They need the relief of being able to stretch and move freely as you would expect an animal in a zoo to be able to do for example. In fact animals in our zoos are treated more humanely than pigs. An alternative must be found for these most intelligent of creatures.
- SANDRA SIMMONS, 9:20 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
We do not need to be so backward in this day and age. Farming in NZ has a proud heritage of innovation and keeping up to date with consumer requirements. It's not worth cheap pork to treat the animals so abymally.
- fiona bateman, 9:19 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
I have a pig and they are more intelligent, loyal and moreloving than dogs they are far too intelligent to be treated with such lack of respect, its unhumane and very said sight to see we wouldn't let dogs get treated this way so why is it that anyone can get away with treating pigs who are more itellagent than dogs that way.
- annab, 9:17 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
I do not know of any other civilised countries in the world which would allow this suffering. But I can think of many in which this sort of animal treatment was regulated a long time ago. Shame on New Zealand's legislation. Every farmer can do as they please.
- Lars Kahle, 9:12 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
I have 5 pet pigs and they are the most intelligent creatures I've ever known. They deserve to walk on grass, roll in mud and doze in the sun. These are animals who interact with one another, they can learn in much the same way as a dog - to sit for food, walk on a leash, etc. Why treat a dog with love and respect but confine pigs to crates - it's disgusting and New Zealanders should all be ashamed of the practice.
- Joanne Dillon, 9:09 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
This is the most inhumane thing I have ever seen, and I cant believe it has been allowed in "clean green new zealand" for so long. We need to stop this right now, it is so unnecessary.
- Simone Ward, 9:08 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
it is morally wrong to knowingly allow any animal to suffer. I accept that not all people are vegetarians and that animals are farmed for meat for human consumption. BUT no animal should suffer for this. Please do not allow this farming practice to continue. Thank you
- Rebecca Bright, 9:07 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
Pig crating is horrendously cruel. I work with youth offenders who often are sentenced for less than savoury acts against animals. Are the pig farmers any different? I guess not! Please stop the pig crating NOW???????
- Carole Fifield, 9:04 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
This is an unneccessarily cruel way to farm animals, pushing them to their psychological and physiological limits. Pigs should have the right not to live in constant suffering before their deaths. Support the ban and support a healthier style of farming, for the pigs, for the consumers, and for the environment.
- Isabella McCarthy, 9:04 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
I find it hard to believe that pigs are still be treated this way and still nothing has been done about it. This is a big issue that needs addressing and should be a main priority for the NZ government. It is not in anyway acceptable the way these pigs are being treated and it disgusts me that people are still allowed to crate farm pigs.
- Lydia Kleindienst, 9:00 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
animals are sentient beings which scientists have found have feelings, emotions and intelligence and pigs are amonst the most intelligent. This means that pigs suffer physically in the crates etc.and also suffer mentally. I have faith in you Mr. Key as a fair minded man, this is why I am appealing to you to help these poor creatures out of their predicament. Thank you for looking more deeply into this matter Mr. Key. I am, Yours sincerely, Lynette McCleary
- Lynette McCleary, 8:51 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
I believe that New Zealand is a country in which we can make a difference. Kiwis stand for equality: between the sexes, between ethnicities, and between species. I feel that we should be able to make the choice to treat pigs more fairly.
- Alix McEntegart, 8:50 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
it just takes logic to see that it is a cruel practise, animals as well as humans deserve respect!
- Rii Connor, 8:49 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
surely we are living in a civilised society where animal rights DO count. If you hurt animals, you hurt us all
- Sally Garner, 8:47 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
There is no need for this or any type of cruel or inhumane farming practice—if a sector of our farmers can farm well and profitably using free range or more ethical and humane methods then it is only the industry that is holding on to outdated methods in order to retain and increase profit margins. I'm ashamed to be a New Zealander when I see what's going on within all facets of our primary production. The greed for profit over ethics and humanity will be the ruin of the New Zealand brand.
- Kathryn Angus, 8:46 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
Good evening Mr Key I would like to see an end to the suffering of factory farm pigs as much as everyone else. I suggest that while we wait for factory farming pork to be ruled out, an good approach to assisting the matter be, that every packet of pig meat should have to disclose whether or not the meat is factory farm or not. Pursuant to legitimacy theory this gives the public the power to allow these organisations exist (or cease rather) opposed to the power of the govt. Regards Stephanie Larivee PricewaterhouseCoopers Hamilton
- Stephanie Larivee, 8:46 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
it is an unnecessary evil inflicted upon another species by humans when what we should be doing is looking after their welfare. It is not enought to say that it happens eldewhere so to be economical we must use it as well. Nonsense. New Zealand has led the world in other matters, animal welfare should be at the top of our list of reforms that MUST happen immediately in this country.
- Joanne Bryant, 8:44 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
Though I have nothing against eaters of pig products I feel that pigs also deserve the chance to an equal lifestyle chance, this treatment is a cruel and unnecessary method in which to provide consumers with meat. Give the pigs a chance to roam free for a while at least! Thanks, Sergio Campbell 17
- Sergio Campbell, 8:40 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
these animals are intelligent creatures who deserve to be treated with respect.
- Sally Butters, 8:39 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
we are supposed to be a "clean green" country - there's plenty of space for all our animals! Let's keep that green image - we don't have to follow the rest of the world!
- Jeanna Rodgers, 8:38 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
it is inhumane. Jane Fichtner
- Jane Fichtner, 8:32 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
pigs need freedom to live out healthy lives, and by keeping them in crates they have to live short lives with a very sad existence. It is also better for business to have free range animals, as the meat tastes a lot better. Please put the welfare of Animals above profits!
- Emma Jellicoe, 8:28 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
it's simply inhumane. It's unhealthy for both the pigs and humans who consume meat produced in such conditions.
- Sarah Lawrence, 8:25 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
farmers are treating animals inhumanely. If you wouldn't treat your own child, family or even your family pet this way, why is it ok to treat pigs this way? Even criminals get better treatment than these innocent animals.
- James Moir, 8:22 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
I can't believe that a man with your power isnt acting on this. It digusts me. All animals are equal and deserved to be treated equal. Would you put a 2 year old in crates and those conditions and treat it that way? because pigs are much lika a 3yr old, They cant tell you how much they are suffering and cant fight back. I think its extremely sad that fully grown men and women can treat these lovely creatures with such disrespect. John, you can make a difference so please get into action.
- Leanna, 8:22 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
Please transform this country into what it is presented to the rest of the world CLEAN...GREEN....HUMANE
- Marion Lubke, 8:19 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
it is time for all civilised humans to oppose cruel treatment of other sentient beings. No matter how entrenched in tradition or cost-effective it is, this is NOT okay!!
- Sharon Borrageiro, 8:18 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
profits should not come before people, or pigs. Please respect life, not business interests, and ban factory farminig altogether. My most polite sentiments.
- Scarlet, 8:15 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
it is insanely cruel to loving emotional family animals... because it means that as humans we are terrible and without feeling and condone suffering
- craig potton, 8:13 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
I care about the quality of food my family and I consume. I believe best farming practices not only should deliver on the businesses bottom line but also the welfare of the farmed animal or plant, so the consumer receives the highest quality product for their hard earnt dollars. I own Food Direct North West, an online supermarket, based out of Huapai. We have a number of ecological and community based philosophies to provide foodies better eating options. As far as pork goes we support Freedom Farms and Harmony for their work on providing ethically farmed, high quality product. Thank you for your time and cheers to putting NZ farming practices ahead of 3rd world processes - Lets have NZ set the pace on best practice! Cheers Chris Stafford Food Direct North West 09 412 8400
- Chris Stafford, 8:13 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
pigs are intelligent animals. They are as intelligent as dogs. If dogs were treated this way there would be a public outcry. Please do not bow to the pig industries baseless arguments. How can any sane person believe that sow farrowing crates are used for the benefit and safety of the animals? This is animal cruelty at it's worst. The pigs are prevented from displaying their natural behaviour in the cruelest way. It's about time the law was enforced. The pig industry should not be above the law.
- Becks Hatfield, 8:12 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
it is needlessly cruel. In 100 years we will look back on this as the Americans look back at Slavery and wonder how it could ever have existed.
- Matthew Ryan, 8:11 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
the way a society treats it's animals is a reflection on the society itself. I beleive New Zealand is above this sort of treatment of any animal.
- Emily Broadley, 8:05 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
Dear Prime Minister, if you do not believe how terribly depressing, stressful and unnatural it feels, I suggest you cage yourself for one day in the same conditions we are allowing some inhuman beings to force thousands of pigs to exist every day of their life. I guarantee you will go totally insane in minutes! The other side of this unfortunate reality is how we degrade ourselves by exercising such cruelty and torture on beings that are helpless in our hands. Please don't allow fellow citizens any longer to downgrade their "humanity" to that miserable and deplorable extent. (How can they???...) The amount of avoidable suffering of innocent beings in New Zealand is already unbearable.
- Raquel Francois, 8:03 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
A pig is a living creature, it has feelings. When a pig feels pain it can scream just like a human. They are intelligent beautiful animals and they deserve to be treated with consideration. Factory farming is a cruel practice that should be banned. You would not treat a human like that so why would you a pig? I am shocked that the inhumane practices carried out on factory farms have not been addressed already. It is torture and it is abhorrent, disgusting and heartbreaking. Many people feel extremely passionate about this and I urge you to do something about it. Please, please do something about this issue.
- Frances Hancox, 8:03 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
Just because lots of people dont necessary like pigs doesnt mean thet should suffer. This is terrible and these farmers should be ashamed of themselves.
- kiri Gregory, 8:02 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
....it is cruel and heartless. Would you like to live in a cage with flies all over you? not able to turn around or walk anywhere or have fresh air. I will stop now or I will cry.
- jacqui, 8:01 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
Its cruel to keep the sow locked up after her piglets are born ... I understand that the sow can be quiet aggressive towards her piglets but there must be a better way ... even having a period of confinement just while the piglets are suckling 3 times a day or however it works!! Farming is not farming when the animals are locked up ... we give our criminals better living conditions and they have been sentenced to be locked up!!
- Cecelia Milner, 7:59 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
the ethical cost is simply too high. Producers like the Freedom Farms conglomerate have demonstrated that there is a great demand for ethically farmed pork. Banning sow and farrowing crates would be a bold demonstration from our government that New Zealand cares for the wellbeing of livestock.
- Bayard Randel, 7:58 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
We have to treat others as we wish we be treated. We live once, it it unfair to let those who can not speak for themselves suffer. This behaviour is cruel and inhumain - thinking about revenue before animal cruelty is backwards. Make the change while we still have a chance.
- Heike Middleton, 7:56 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
Pigs are intelligent animals that lead emotional lives. To be caged like that for the duration of their lives is abhorrent. Please change the law.
- Carisse de Beer , 7:56 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
If humans were farmed in cages by a superior race we would want justice. Pigs do not need to live like this. You can help them. Together we can make a difference for these pigs. Let them see there is more to life than sow crates. Let them see the beautiful country with it's green grass and sunshine that you've been protecting. Let them have a future too. All creatures deserve a fair life. Now's your chance to help
- Heather Follas, 7:53 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
Please please please consider changing the law now for these poor defenceless, highly intelligent animals who unfortunately have fallen into our cruel and greedy hands. New Zealand is a country that is supposed portrays to be caring and green and I can't believe this is still happening and we are allowing it to happen over here you would think we were a second world country! Imagine a life like that for you and your children - tooo cruel for words. Please help them !
- Leanne George, 7:45 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
Dear John I Think It Is About Time The People In Parliment Got Of There Arse And Helped These Animals, How would you like To Live Like This If This Is How People Of New Zealand Treat animals They Should Be Made To Live Like That. John
- John Eddy, 7:45 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
Pigs are incredibly intelligent and suffer greatly for what reason - we are supposed to be the superior being but it appears we may just plain ignorant. Please, Please help end this and get rid of the pain these gorgeous animals go through.
- Angela McNeill, 7:44 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
all living beings need to be respected, even if we do end up killing them for food. Its important to be respectful to the animals, and not be cruel. Thanks.
- Rebecca Dodson, 7:44 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
it breaks my heart every time I see the ad on television with the sad pig. You can clearly see it's unhappy. We should not allow this cruelty to carry on just so we can stuff our faces. Please make your country proud by doing something about it. Thanks.
- Joanna Korporaal, 7:44 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
I wouldn't treat my dog the way these animals are treated. It is inhumane and it must stop! Please consider a law change which bans both sow and farrowing crates. Thank you.
- Maria Henry, 7:40 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
I have been an animal welfare inspector for the SPCA and I continue to be a voice for the animals. The world of cruelty is so common in the kiwi backyard we can barely keep up with it, let alone to have it legal to have animals farmed in the way these piggeries operate. This is not right, that's the bottom line. It is legalised cruelty and it's not right. Everyday you do not change this, is a day in hell for each and every one of these poor animals. We are better than that. We want New Zealand to be better than that. Be that man that changed these standards. Thank you, Rachael Maher
- Rachael Maher, 7:39 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
can not beleive anyone would want to be this cruel and secondly to actually eat an animal that has been treated like they are treated-shame on New Zealand with our supposedly clean green,nuclear free image-behaving like barbarians.
- jane nicholson, 7:39 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
I have actually done work experience in a factory pig farm and it was very disturbing, I dont think its actualy that real to people who have not been into one and actually seen how the pigs live. It is disgusting and should be banned, just like caged chickens.
- Hayley, 7:39 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
it's unethical & immoral & viable alternatives are available.These are intelligent animals, unlike the animals that farm them .
- Claire Reilly, 7:38 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
I hope you listen to all these voices who speak for those who cannot speak for themselves.
- Simon Baird, 7:38 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
It appear these Pig do suffer, and I for one will not be voting National again.
- DIANE BELL, 7:35 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
i cant believe that we still abide such cruelty just because we eat the product of it. if it were any other animal the person in charge would find them selves in front of a jury! If the farmers wont change their habits of torture and suffering its up to the government. Its not that hard.. animal cruelty is illegal in New Zealand.. this should account for farmers also!
- bex ellis, 7:33 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
Pigs are known to be intelligent animals, so to confine sows to a life-time of misery is outright cruelty and a disgrace to the nation. Sow and farrowing crates MUST be banned and made illegal forthith, not in several years time. It staggers me that vets visiting such farms, according to what I've heard, say that these sows are in good health. The Vetinary Association needs to look into the beliefs and practices of such practitioners. The NAWAC and Pork Board both need to be disbanded and replaced with persons who are concerned with animal welfare, not just dollars. I also believe that if the rest of the world was aware about these practices, there would be no international market. Therefore I am going to send this email to all my friends in England, where sow crating has been banned.
- Anne Wills, 7:31 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
Hi John, I already pay more for freedom pork but it is hard to find. Changing the rules to make it more worthwhile to farm pigs without cruelty will ensure the product stays on our shopping list and make more of it available. We don't need to endorse cruelty to make other businesses successful so why should pigs suffer unduly for the sake of a few archaic farmers. I believe we need to draw the line somewhere. Watching the current agriculture minister on TV makes me ashamed to be a New Zealander -the holes and lies in the arguments make me feel like some under educated fool from some back water instead of a world leader in agriculture. Please consider my viewpoint. Thanks
- leslee Blackmore, 7:30 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
it is inhumane and unthinkable that New Zealand, with its supposed 'clean green' image would allow this type of factory farming to continue. Please make a stand and say NO. Some forward-thinking European nations have shown that free-range pig farming is not only humane but economically viable as well.
- Eleanor Griffin, 7:28 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
I cant believe this type of animal cruelty is still happening in this day and age. It truelly saddens me.
- Julia, 7:27 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
...pigs are particularly susceptible to mental and physical pain when kept in extremely confined conditions. Such suffering is perpetuated by a lack of proper regulation, with competitive forces driving pork producers to impose cruel but cost-efficient conditions. As a result consumers save a few dollars, but at a horrific price for pigs. The distance between the realities of pork production and the average consumer means that consumers seldom understand the implications of their purchasing decisions. A ban would remove the economic trap into which the industry is forced, ensuring there is no longer an economic incentive for such cruelty.
- Rob O'Meara, 7:26 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
at the end of the day, it's a matter of principal. You wouldn't keep your dog in a stall, would you? By not taking action, you're saying that pigs are "lesser" animals. This angers and wrries me. Pigs today, people tomorrow?
- Pippa Liley, 7:25 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
Pigs are actually smarter than dogs. i don't necessarily object to eating pigs, only to keeping pigs in horrible conditions. What a nightmare to be born a pig, to be raised in a crate then forced to breed constantly and then slaughtered. They deserve better. I know you are busy, you are the prime minister. eat all the bacon you want. Just make sure that pigs are held in great conditions where they can live good lives. Husbandry can be ethical and humane. Thanks for listening.
- Mon Subritzky, 7:25 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
Knowing that we live in a society where animals are made to live in conditions where they cant even turn around is just not right. Humans are omnivores who need to eat, it is only natural, but surely in the 21st century meat can be raised in humane conditions. I am a National voting dairy farmer who always makes sure the animals I farm are treated well and think everyone should do the same. I don't understand how anybody capable of feeling the human emotions of compassion & empathy can think sow & farrowing crates are acceptable.
- Craig Kuriger, 7:23 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
as a civilized country, there is no excuse for keeping pigs in such a cruel, uncaring fashion. The fact that pigs are farmed sussessfully in free range conditions in Europe, proving that the excuses given for the use of crates and sow stalls are rubbish. ( ie sows will roll on and kill their piglets, or that pigs will fight.) The fact is, farmers want to make as much profit as possible by using as little land as possible. Let a farmer who is confined to a space where it is impossible to turn around or exercise, for one week - then say there is nothing wrong with sow crates and stalls!
- Jane McGowan, 7:19 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
of the cruel and inhumane manner in which the pigs are kept. It is disgraceful not to stop these disgusting practices immediately. No animal should be treated this way. You have the power to act on behalf of these animals - please stand up and be accountable. Gain the respect of thousands of voters. If you don't, the pigs' absolute misery is on your shoulders. Please act for them NOW and sleep easier knowing you did something really decent to stop this cruelty. Thanks. Yours sincerely Sally Evison
- Sally Evison, 7:18 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
it is a very cruel method of farming. It's so cruel that it's banned in some European countries. New Zealand should do the same.
- Guy Treleaven, 7:17 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
the unnecessary infliction of such heinous suffering upon sentient others is an egregious affront to basic human decency. Other countries have already banned sow and farrowing crates - it's time for New Zealand to follow suit.
- jovian Parry, 7:15 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
There's no reason for them to be kept like this. We give reasonable conditions to cows, sheep, horses and every other animal, because it's unthinkable not to. On a shallow note, maybe it's because we can't keep every other animal like this because people would notice and our exports would stop or at the very least loose our premium brand reputation. Say "No" to this, and while you at it, don't let our dairy go the same way.
- Suzanne Green, 7:13 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
it is extremely cruel. I can't believe this is still going on in this day and age. It is high time the laws were changed. Kind regards, Karin van der Lijn
- Karin van der Lijn, 7:13 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
because pigs are in telligent animals. We do not tolerate cruelty to humans -there are numerous ads on tv saying violence is not okay, numerous groups supporting victims of abuse, we even have state funding so homes can be provided at a lower cost so everyone in theory can afford to live in a safe dry environment. New zealanders care about each other so why should New Zealander allow cruelty to pigs, an animal asa intelligent as a three year old child?
- Hannah Bennett, 7:13 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
Take a stand and in the process stop cruelty and encourage our farmers to produce a higher quality of produce.
- Lee Hales, 7:13 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
I believe we can run a business economically with profit as well as treat the animals with dignity.
- craig wright, 7:12 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
Animals have feelings too. They deserve respect and love just like humans do. I have very little faith in the humankind as we are continuously acting in horrid ways. For you to ban this would prove that humans can and do act out of kindness. Please help these creatures. Alyssa
- Alyssa Aanensen, 7:11 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
these crates cause unnecessary suffering to animals. Pigs have been farmed in other ways for hundreds of years and there is no need (apart from commercial greed) to change our practices. There are already people who farm pigs in this country without using these crates and still make a profit and provide free range pork which sells at a premium price.
- Ruth Gerzon, 7:10 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
it is so primitive. With our beautiful clean green New Zealand, surely the pigs have a right to enjoy the outdoors too, instead of being shut in crates.
- Heather Kaufmann, 7:08 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
i think this is absolutely disguisting allowing this kinda cruelty in our so called modern country,surely you have a conscious on animal cruelty ? i ask you to stop this barbarrack act now,theres absolutely no need for this kinda treatment of animals i nthis country.
- mark baker, 7:05 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
i love pigs and its just cruel ur a big meany
- Samantha, 7:01 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
as a mother I am devastated and embarassed to think my children would learn that I ignored this kind of cruelty to any living creature with out protesting. I understand that the farmer's livliehood is supposedly at stake but they have a choice to move to free range and the government should support this morally and financially. It is a slight on the whole country that we allow this. Civilised countries do not allow such cruelty. Please step up. You know it is wrong. Please do not hide behind other ministers. Step up John.
- Elizabeth Cole, 7:01 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
there is absolutely no need for pigs to be factory farmed in this cruel and barbaric way. There is no need for humans to eat animals at all. Everything we need is available in the vegetable kingdom.Farmers aren't kidding anyone. They are in this disgusting and inhumane business purely for the money. How they get it does not stir their conscience. It ought to. If one stands up and says 'No More', then others will follow. In New Zealand, the government has an unusual opportunity to show the rest of the world it leads in what it will allow in the treatment of animals.Farmers who treat pigs in this way bring shame on this country and any government which allows it to continue shares this shame.
- Yvonne Amery, 7:00 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
The suffering these poor creatures endure is inhumane! They have adrenalin and stress hormones coursing through their bodies. Then you kill them and eat them. You also get all those stress hormones. You are what you eat....if it's tortured pigs??? What is happening to you?
- Wendy Vermeulen, 6:59 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
I am a Buddhist & like all Buddhists & many other people, we believe tha animals hve feelings. It is very easy to see that pigs experience feelings like you & me & everyone else. they delight in some things like good food & dont like other things like physical pain etc etc We know without a doubt that pigs experience unbearable suffering in these discusting places you would never put your own animal would you?? Therefore it should not be legal in the same way as other types of torture are illegal. It is just insane not to do anything about this. Its up to you now. See if you can act like you would actually like to be.
- Lozang Hursthouse, 6:57 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
There is aboslutly no need for it. We are not asking to do the impossible. Why on earth would we think it is OK to create this kind of suffering for these poor creatures? Who are we to actively create pain and hardship for them? It is discusting. Please help to make this a thing of the past.
- Leila, 6:57 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
It isn't neccesary, there are nicer ways to do things if they are going to be killed for food they should atleast be treated in a humane way and have a decent life before they are killed. It is cruel and I think if more people knew and watched how they are treated and what happened everyone would stop even buying the meat that isnt free range, people that care anyway.I think New Zealand should make a change for the better and not just pigs but eventually all farming should be free range. Thanks for taking the time to read this I know your a nice person and are a good prime minister and that it's not your fault this is happening but with your power and position you're in you can make a change.
- caitlin, 6:56 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
John i wrote to you as a constituent and concerned member of the public when this furore started , thankyou for your acknowledgement , unfortunately isee nothing to recify the plight of these animals in this code and see no benefit whatever for NZ in prolonging the agony .rather we should be leading the world in Animal rearing standards not 20 years behind Regards Andrew Bonner
- andrew Bonner, 6:54 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
I am opposed to factory farming because, it does not allow the poor pigs to exhibit their natural behaviours for one. Does it not seem abnormal to you that a factory farmed pig can hardly stand, due to muscle wastage and is visably depressed? It's a disgusting practice that obviously seems to be about money and making it affordable to the consumer, whereas more New Zealanders and further abroad overseas do in fact care about where the product has come from and its welfare and the fact it lived a natural life.
- Vanessa Murray, 6:53 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
I believe in a modern society the way humans treat animals reflects greatly on the way we treat other human beings. We have a choice to treat pigs respectfully and humanely. Why would intelligent human beings not treat animals with the respect they deserve when we have the choice?
- Alex Ellis, 6:51 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
it is inhumane. As the species that considers itself the most evolved, we do some hideous and shameful things. Be a role model and stop the slaughter.
- Tania Payne, 6:51 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
It's simple really. It's how we treat those who are weaker than ourselves that defines our humanity.
- Jim McLarty, 6:48 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
As a naturopath and medical herbalist, I am passionate about organic and free range food being as freely available to as many ordinary people as possible, as well as raising any animals which are subsequently used for food in as happy, stress-free environment as possible. Apart from being kind to these creatures, this also produces better quality, toxin-free (stress is a toxin!) food. Yours in health, Maureen H Verrill
- Maureen Verrill, 6:45 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
I believe that if humans can't treat animals with respect then how can they be expected to treat other humans with respect. Intensive farming is unnecessary and I think education of the public is what's really needed. Be honest, what percentage of the population truly understand nutrition and the food they eat?
- Andrew, 6:45 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
I hate it how they call the pigs products there animals if this was happening to a dog or cat these people would be in a lot of trouble.
- Shannon, 6:39 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
they are suffering.
- steve dean, 6:25 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
I don't believe it is necessary to subject an intelligent animal to such cruel practices in order to make a living.
- T Adams, 5:54 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
it is not right to keep exploiting animals just for the sake of making a dollar. All animals deserve to be treated with respect and treated humanely. This practice must stop.
- Tara Richmond, 5:42 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
-The conditions these pigs live in are unatural. -It is bad for our clean green image. -Pigs are highly intelligent animals. -It wouldn't cost too much to change the way pigs are reared.
- Georgina Bridgwater, 5:41 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
i think New Zealand should look to have all farming free range . AS this is probly the best for the interest of the animals , also it can be used as a good marketing tool to go with our cleen and green image. It will also create a higher value product for market. We can also look at banning the import of other countries animal products if it cannot prove to be raised in a free range situation. so our farmers are not at a disadvantage yours sincerely Django Howat
- Django A Howat, 5:19 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
A measure of society's advancement is it's sensitivity to insufferable cruelties on all beings which are unable to defend themselves and it's determination that such cruelties are not tolerated...whether it be for the mighty dollar or not.
- Stephanie Hodges, 5:16 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
Its unnecessary and barbaric treatment of intelligent creatures. Who are bred to give up their lives so that people can enjoy the taste of their flesh. (Sanitarium make an equally tasty cruelty free substitute) Scientific evidence shows that pigs are equally intelligent to dogs. I find it amazingly hypocritical how there are penalty's against cruelty to certain sentient beings and not others. This must stop! The only difference to the holocaust, which overall people find abhorrent, is the scale of the mass murder of innocent creatures. It baffels me how some people are desensitized to what is actually on their plate. Please Sir, help protect pigs!
- Alison Beauchamp, 5:04 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
to treat an intelligent animal in such a way debases us as a society - we need t
- Rachel Martin, 5:02 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
I think its an absolute disgrace, they are living creatures and should be looked after in our wonderful green paddocks for the short life they have. Im amazed you have allowed this to carry on. Please do something about it. Kind Regards Georgina Knight
- Georgina Knight, 4:50 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
They being one of the most inteligent animals around us daily must suffer intensly in crates, if you had a pet would you keep it in a space so small that it could not turn around in for most of it's life
- Chris C wedding, 4:50 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
for a start it looks disgusting having the pigs all covered in their own shit, then the flys and all the dead babies. I have free range pigs they are healthy happy and friendly, the piggerys are not.
- Susan, 4:45 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
There is no need in todays society for animals to be treated this way when there are alternatives to this type of farming. This type of barbaric farming is practiced because farmers are in it for the money and had no consideration for the welfare of the animals. You can do something about this............
- Rebecca Tilsley, 4:36 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
I imagine this as my family if we were taken into some type of prison farm or concentration camp we would want someone to help us....this is the same... Please do something to help. Kind Regards Mandy Horton.
- Mandy, 4:33 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
Pigs are smarter than dogs. If dogs were kept in these conditions the country would be rioting.
- Paul Mannering, 4:32 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
it is inhumane and wrong for us to treat animals this way. We must respect those that give us life. It is the natural law. Please do not agree to this horrible existence for our porcine pals. Thank you.
- Jennifer Bade, 4:30 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
I don't see why pigs should be put through pain and suffering for the sake of us having bacon pork ham etc... There is surely ways to farm them so they live a good and happy life. No animal deserves to be un-fairly treated under any circumstances. They have the same reights as we do, they are a living animal and should be treated the same way you would want to be treated. I know that it is not your chgoice that they are being treated this way, but all I ask of you is that you fight for them and get them a well deserverd life. They didin't choose this to happen to them. I can only do so much. The power lies in your hands. Yours Sincerly, Heather Hansen
- Heather Hansen, 4:25 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
it is cruel and unnecessary. Animals deserve just as much respect as humans, and the conditions they live in with factory farming is simply disgusting.
- Lauren Sharp, 4:23 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
it is cruel. I do not want to live in a country where this kind of behavior is condoned. Do you? I voted for this government because I believed some changes had to be made. Please don't prove me wrong. Yours sincerely Lynne Jamneck
- Lynne Jamneck, 4:22 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
its beyond comprehension that in this country we keep any animal in such disgusting and cruel conditions, it should be made illegal and the law changed to protect the rights of the ANIMAL not the FARMER. I ask you to act now to make sure that no more animals are born into misery and have to live out their lives in such abhorent conditions, it truely sickens me. Thank you for making the change.
- Claire Dann, 4:18 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
it forces other beings to exist in conditions that you yourself have said are very disturbing, purely for economic gains. The New Zealand public has responded in a similar way and now a new legislative approach must be taken to place economics in the context of another being's life, not the other way around. Your support for a ban on sow and farrowing crates would show New Zealand that you are strong leader, willing to stand up for things that matter. When making your decision, please think of those who do not have a voice. Thank you for your time.
- Russell Golding, 4:15 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
it is not necessary to treat animals this way in order to provide cheaper meat. I have now chosed to avoid all pork products rather than risk supporting this abhorent industry. I am not opposed to eating meat, rather to the unecessary cruelty used in farming pigs.
- nicole edwards, 4:13 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
it is an unsustainable practice, based on cheap oil, that has no future. Factor farming perpetuates cruelty to animals, as is so disconected from the public that most are not aware of how food is produced. Furthermore factory farming is resposible for the cheap and overabundant calories that contribute to the growing obesity epidemic. Factory farming - humans and animals both suffer!
- Mark Smith, 4:11 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
it is unnatural and unkind. Consider yourself being confined in despicable conditions minute by minute with no opportunity to free yourself or have others able to free you. There but for the grace of God go you and I. All living creatures, including whales -large gentle giants of the sea that they are. The shooting of those dogs, dreadful as it was, was decryedn by your good self. Have consideration for the pigs and their offspring to at least enjoy a healthy, robust enviroment despite their probable fate. Pigs love to wallow in mud and roam free. At least give them that back and the chance to enjoy their lives. Other animals apart from humans feel pain and degradation. Move now - like today -this minute to stop this vicious practice. Lois Winch
- Lois Winch, 4:09 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
i believe it is damaging our reputation internationally both directly on consumer markets and indirectly on that of out clean, green tourism image. It is not necessary for our economic survival, and has direct parallels with the Prime Minister's expressed opinion about the potential damage to our export industy that the factory farming of cows may have. As it is not necessary for our welfare, we should be looking after that of the pigs. This must be done through legislation, consumers although externally outraged by this treatment, continue to purchase unethically farmed products because it has become the norm; is cheaper and easier than free range. With legislation norms can be changed, this will allow consumers to recognise and realise their moral intentions. The practise of factory farming is cruel and highly unnatural, it is morally, and should be legally, unacceptable. A fate unimaginable and yet a reality.
- Eryn Rogers, 4:04 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
no animal should be forced to spend it's life in cruel, cramped conditions. This treatment of any animal is inexcusable, but A FULLY GROWN PIG IS BELIEVED TO BE AS INTELLIGENT AS A THREE YEAR OLD HUMAN CHILD. Please help to end the torture of these beautiful and intelligent creatures, by banning sow and farrowing crates as soon as possible.
- Annette Camp, 3:58 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
No animal should have to live in those conditions
- maureen bakulich, 3:53 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
the exploitation of sentient beings is wrong. Human rights are based on the prevention of unnecessary and undue suffering and it is no different for animals. They are at the centre of their own conscious existence, just like us. The concept of having a 'human right to exploit animals' is nonsensical as it precludes an animal's autonomy, presuming they have a duty to submit to human interests, regardless of the costs unto themselves.
- Andrew Pasley, 3:51 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
we have the choice and the power to be humane.
- patrick malloch, 3:41 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
it is a race to the bottom, driven by profit over everything else. Without real government regulation and control there is no impetus on companies to adhere to decent animal welfare standards. Everyone knows that sow and farrowing crates are inhumane and wrong. They are, in fact, torture. The problem is that some companies feel ignore the issue in a sad greed lust. Why do we allow this horrendous practise to take place? As a society, when we know things are wrong we enact laws to ban them from happening. If people still go ahead and break these laws then the ability to keep breaking these laws is removed from them. This is the basis of a cohesive functioning society. Instead we currently reward businesses for doing the wrong thing by letting it happen and letting them profit from the extreme misery, pain and torture of others. What does this say about our society?
- Duncan Allan, 3:40 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
If humans were to be treated in this manner and confined to an area that they can move freely in and resume a remotely comfortable position this would be called a violation of their human rights, how can this be any different for an animal?! I am a proud vegan and have been for many years but the horrors that New Zealand a supposed first world country continues to stipulate upon its animals never ceases to amaze me. Shame on the corrupt pork industry and those people who support it.
- Tracey Wardle , 3:36 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
It is needlessly cruel - pigs are intelligent creatures and we can only imagine what horror they suffer because of man's inhumanity and indifference to their suffering as long as their wallets remain their only real interest. I find it incredible that once attention has been drawn to the facts officials can defend the indefensible and delay correcting the situation for even a short time.
- Frances King , 3:33 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
We are not a 3rd world country are we? We are better than this. We are Clean Green New Zealand who shouldn't have to hide our heads in shame over the poor treatment of animals. Keep in mind the effect of boycotting of Cadbury products when the use of palm oil was discovered. Our economy needs to be protected and keep farmers in business in the long term. Please put a stop to the use of sow crates.
- Emma-Jane Climo, 3:33 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
a humane and decent society does not put profit ahead of animal welfare. If the price must go up to make the pigs life better - so be it. Kiwis eat too much meat anyway and our health suffers as a result; so it would be a win/win if we ate less pork because the price was higher. Cruelty is NEVER acceptable and only you can stop this - so please legislate against the present pork farming practices or sow and farrow crates. Many thanks and kindest regards, Rosemary Shore 611 Blockhouse Bay Rd Auckland 0600
- Rosemary Shore, 3:32 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
It's disgusting to see the conditions these pigs are kept in. Much like my wife and I have decided to only buy free-range eggs, we would happily pay more for pork products that were 'free-range' or at the very least raised in barns, raher than stalls. at the moment, it is impossible for us to get free-range pork/ham/bacon (mmm bacon) at our local supermarket - they just don't stock it. with direction from the government (or at least an official position that shows displeasure) to the industry and supermarklet chains, they are much more likely to stock it and cut back on the 'battery farm' pork products. Kind regards,
- Mathieu Apers, 3:31 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
Mr Key There should be only one factor in your decision to ban sow crates and intensive pig farming and that is to view this as animal cruelty. For NZ to been seen in the eyes of the world to be supporting this practice rates us with those countries who support whaling, dog fighting and other sorts of animal cruelty. Improving the conditions for animals may place financial strain on the farmers concerned ... too bad, they have exploited these animals for long enough. You have the support of so many New Zealanders as a Prime Minister with backbone, integrity and a conscience. Can you really go home at night and tell your kids that you support this ? NZ has led the world in so many areas, please make this one of them. Put a stop to this abuse NOW.
- Glyn Taylor, 3:23 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
I hate to see animals suffer. I saw maybe 20 seconds of the video and could watch no longer. It is totally disgusting that this kind of treatment to animals continues in New Zealand and I do not think it is necessary. People are greedy and that is the only reason for such brutality.
- Josee Klein, 3:23 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
it denies the pigs an even remotely humane life - incredible boredom, frustration - we don't treat the worst serial killers as badly as we treat innocent animals. Please, please banish both sow crates and farrowing crates. We have a great PM now in charge - please do something!
- Jane Giliam, 3:15 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
I believe as a health professional that this is not only strongly an animal welfare issue but also a public health issue. We have numerous studies that have shown raising animals in these conditions are not conducive to healthy products. The implications for infectious diseases and mutated strains cannot be ruled out. I am very supportive so far of the policies and directions that National has taken. This is an issue I feel strongly opposed to and I hope our Prime Minister will take our concerns in the final decisions. respectfully yours, Gigi Lim
- Gigi Lim, 3:11 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
Isn't there enough cruelty in New Zealand let alone the world! We stand proud we are different to other countries especially being Nuclear Free, so why can't we free animals from unnecessary cruelty just so you can eat them! (I do not eat animals!) NO living creature could withstand being confined and NOR should it be subjected to it! Make a stand John and change the law across the board! Save PIGS and have harsher sentencing on animal cruelty! Everything is too PC at the moment show crimals that we mean business! I would support public hangings for worthless human beings in this country that don't deserve MY taxes paying to fed them in prison!!!!
- Alex McMillan, 3:05 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
Imagine your life being treated like that!
- Stacey Gillies, 2:56 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
we are supposed to be the more "advanced" species, and in that vein should be more far seeing & compassionate towards our fellow earth inhabitants - even if their future is to provide us with food, they deserve to have as best a life as possible before their demise, don't you think?...we have the anti-nuclear stance - how about anti-cruelty to our livestock too!!
- Josie Whitehead, 2:54 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
it's cruel, it's barbaric and totally unneccesary, our clean green country could have happy pigs being reared free-range all over the place, just like Freedom Farms are doing. Please put an end to the unneccessary crate farming of pigs and encourage your government to insist on Free-range farming.
- Di Morris, 2:46 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
I still eat meat and pork, but I dont want to be part of what i do consider to be cruelty to intelligent animals. We dont need cheap pork meat that much. Please help make this change. It is better for us as humane humans as well as for the pigs. Thanks heaps
- amanda stonex, 2:40 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
There is no need to treat pigs, or any animals this way. They aren't able to speak for themselves so it is up to us to speak for them. Please do your very best to help these animals, cruelty is never the answer. New Zealand should be ashamed of the way these animals are being kept, we shouldn't stand for it! Please help put a stop to it!
- Sarah Johnston, 2:36 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
We need to treat the animals we eat in the same manner as we would treat the animals we have as pets in our home. If we don't learn to repect animals basic rights, we in turn run the risk of not respecting each others
- Kim Brebner, 2:35 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
This is disgusting! How can NZ claim a clean green image?
- John Sullivan, 2:32 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
it represents unnecessary cruelty to animals when there are viable alternatives. I buy Freedom Farms produce, and it costs not much more, so why do we need to let cruel methods of pig farming continue? I would argue we don't.
- Dianne Khan, 2:23 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
This is a apallent practice. I spent a lot of my childhood on a pig farm. this meens that I have seen first hand what happens to these animals. They are made to live in their own filth which no animal shoud have to endure, the are treated extremely cruly, made to live in freezing condtiond in the winter. These animal must and do hate it what is forced on to them. Also I had my own pet pig when I was little. She kept her self clean and her pen clean, so the excuse that they are smelly dirty animals is not a valad one. I voted for you because you are man with a brian who looks to have compation and a hart, please do not let me down on this. one less evil in the world is on the way to making this a better world.
- Peaches Koller, 2:15 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
it's cruel.. They have legs... Why is it that the owners of these factory farms able to take away their right of being able to run freely? Because they breed them? ... If that's the case, my parents gave birth to me.. What privileges of my life are they able to rob from me?
- Daniel Bell, 2:03 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
I cant stomach that we are able to treat intelligent living beings that we share this planet with is this manner. ALL living things that are on this planet deserve respect and to live good lives and are not just here for our selfish purposes. I refuse to buy pork and I have done for many many years because of the horror we inflict on these animals. It is beyond comprehension to me that this practice is deemed o.k - we all know that it isnt. Farm /food animals should be treated with respect and kindness and dignity. It is a damning indictment on humanity that we allow this cruelty and horror in the name of profit. We owe it to ourselves to treat life on this planet with more respect and to enhance life instead of create this horror that is hidden away, but we all KNOW it happens and we all KNOW it's wrong. Please take steps to stop it NOW!
- megan mitcalfe, 1:48 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
Sow stalls and farrowing crates are so small that the only movement allowed to confined pigs is to stand up or lie down. Confined pigs cannot turn around, let alone exercise. Clearly with such limited movement these practices prevent confined pigs from displaying normal patterns of behaviour, despite that this is a requirement under the Animal Welfare Act (AWA) (1999). With an abundance of scientific evidence demonstrating the capacity of pigs to detect pain and discomfort, it is no longer speculation or anthropomorphism to suggest that these poor creatures are suffering as much as they appear or as one would imagine given their living conditions. For me personally it is difficult to comprehend that we could allow such demonstrated suffering to continue for the sake of a small increase in profitability. Further, it is difficult to comprehend how these practices are still allowed when studies (i.e. Colmar Brunton poll 2002) show that the vast majority of New Zealanders wish them to be outlawed; and several European countries (i.e. the UK, Sweden, Finland, Switzerland, Denmark) have banned or committed to phasing them out, suggesting that pig farming could still be economically viable in their absence. I am sure that all of reasonable New Zealand will be hugely grateful for anything you or Mr. Carter can do to help stop these practices. Kind regards Jonathan
- Jonathan Ruffell, 1:43 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
animals are incredible, they provide us with so much joy and a reason to better our interaction with nature. Seeing any animal restricted to a cage, unable to move for weeks on end is beyond my comprehension and I hope you feel the same way? No animal deserves to be treated like this end of story.
- Jimmy Moore, 1:31 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
of the needless suffering inflicted on these sentient creatures. There is no excuse for inflicting such a hellish life on any animal when there are resonable alternatives. As a long-term National party supporter, I ask you to put empathy before profit and contribute to realising a world in which profit is tempered by morality.
- Lesley Weavers, 1:28 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
it is a cruel and unnatural practice of animal husbandry. Sheep and dairy cattle are not confined in his manner why should pigs and poultry be subjected to such an abborent way of intensive farming. The Pork and Poultry Industry Boards should be taken to task and immediate steps should be taken to amend the Animal Welfare Act. This sort of production is not or at least should never be the NZ way of farming and I am disappointed that you haven't stepped in sooner to make things change. Come on John - we put you in for CHANGE! Helen Phillips
- helen phillips, 1:12 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
This is not a decent humane way to treat intelligent mammals. I do not believe that as humans we have the right to denigrate such animals. How can anyone with a conscience support such horrific cruelty. Please do not allow this to continue.
- Sue Ferrar, 1:02 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
it is merely a human shortcut to profit. There are no reasonable grounds upon which to restrict the movement and degrade the living conditions of animals in this way. Farming methods where the animal's welfare is of more concern, clearly demonstrate improved livestock health (and healthy profit margins for farmers).
- Charlotte Murphy, 12:51 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
in this case, at least; it is horrific. I treat the stray cat that comes into my yard, better than they treat those pigs. I now understand why pork chops are always on sale. I won't eat pork anymore. So now, not only are they being cruel to the animals there, they are messing with the pork farmers here in my country. Sorry but I won't ever look at pork the same after this.
- Donna, 12:47 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
it is clearly detremental to both physical and mental health of the animals. these animals are kept in an extremely unnatural environment and are used soley for the purpose of making money. they are exploited and abused and i refuse to accept it. show us you have a heart and make a change.
- emma foote, 12:43 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
everyone knows how intelligent they are, more so than dogs. It is illegal to keep dogs like this so whats the difference? Yesterday the WSPA ad about pig cruelty was on TV. It had no spoken words, only a head shot of a pig in a sow crate, yet my 3 year old son looked at me and said "Mummy, that pig looks really sad. It can't play and it has no friends." That summed it up for me. Change can't happen without someone like you , in the position to do something, backs up the publics view. Isn't that why we voted you in? Isn't that why we live in a democratic society??? Please help them! They can't speak up for themselves.
- Hannah Owsley, 12:39 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
on a purely economic level, this looks terrible for our overseas image. Tourism consumers are cottoning on that we are not clean and green, and unethical farming that is years behind the EU will also affect our exports. NZ farmers already have to fight for the eco dollar due to our food miles, why are you allowing some farmers to taint our image even further and spoil it for the rest?
- Jennifer Lawless, 12:37 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
After watching footage about this issue on TV I was saddened and shocked. It just seems so wrong that pigs are treated this way anywhere but especially here in New Zealand. There must me something that can be done about this.
- Angus, 12:17 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
I can't beleive the powers that be say it is alright to keep pigs and piglets in such horrid conditions. I lived on a farm as a teenager and we had free range pigs. They do have their problems but nothing that deserves their current living arrangements. We are unable to keep domestic pets like this so why can we keep farm animals in this state.
- Karen Morehu, 12:14 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
we promote this country as clean and green and yet we are exploiting these animals - and our environment (that's another issue altogether). Please Mr Key, it is the first time that I have ever voted National. And I'm starting to regret it. Please make it right. The average New Zealander DOES care.
- Joanne , 12:12 PM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
its total cruelty which is totally unnecessary. We live in a country which is heralded for its green policies and it is seen by the outside world as being champions of organic and safe farming practices - its a disgrace of massive proportions.
- connor mcfadyen, 11:59 AM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
There are other ways of raising pigs for slaughter and more humane ways of doing it.
- Rochelle, 11:59 AM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
as long as we allow any cruelty in our society, it's presence in our lives will find a way to filter out into the wider world, and there will be continued cruelty among humans. To stop violence and cruelty on any level, for example between parent and child or between any peoples, we must eliminate it from our consciousness entirely. Therefore, any form of cruelty against any life form must be outlawed. Our spiritual integrity as individuals is completely dependent on the wellbeing and life integrity of every being in creation. Please act, With gratitude for time, My brother.
- Vance Wano, 11:58 AM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
Pigs have feelings too ! it makes me so angry to know that people just dont care about animals . they are feeding meat eaters so the least humans could do is give them respect,they are helpless and Mr.John Key being the president you could change this.Have a heart and please help !please!please!please!
- brooke, 11:47 AM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
dear mr reptilian im sure you will find it in your ....heart to ban the violent actions towards pig do what is right hisssss
- zak akabai, 11:15 AM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
these animals are very intelligent and sensitive. They go through suffering and anguish being kept in conditions like this. It is just not humane. Please help them.
- Rebecca Frast, 11:12 AM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
would you like to spend your life like that?
- Julia Banks, 10:51 AM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
I had a pet pig when I was growing up so I am aware of their intelligence. Please stop this cruelty and prevent it from continuing on in this way. I buy happy eggs and I try to do this with pork so I am prepared to pay extra, are you?
- Jan Turnwald, 10:49 AM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
you only have to look into the eyes of those poor pigs to see the turmoil they are in. You wouldn't keep a cat or dog like that so why should a pig be any different. I have not purchased any pig products since this has been bought to my attention unless I am 100% convinced it is free range. I would rather pay the difference than support a cruel and archaic practice. Please do something about it. Show you are the leader of a county that cares. Thanks
- lisa hilton, 10:47 AM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
as above
- Idan Shapira, 10:42 AM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
How would you feel locked in a crate for your whole life? Just because that's what happens, and it's how it is for pigs, doesn't mean its right. If it breaths, eats and shits it's a living creature, and no living creature deserves it.
- Jordan Selby, 10:38 AM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
The measure of our humanity is how we treat other living things. I haven't eaten bacon for over 20 years because I was so appalled at the way these intelligent animals are treated. If cats and dogs were treated like this there are animal cruelty charges. These should apply to our food animals as well. I think your government is doing a good job in lots of areas, I hope that cleaning up these cruel farming practices will be part of your legacy Thanks, Bridget McKendry
- Bridget McKendry, 10:33 AM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
Stop putting this revolting way of farming on the back-burner, stop it now! These animals deserve, at the very laest, a comfortable way of living. Put yourself in thier place, see how you would like it! This also goes for caged chicken farming.
- Susan Paul, 10:31 AM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
I have very happy free range pigs and could not imagine them locked up in dark cramped cages, with no sunlight or fresh air. These two things are the basis for life after all. I have seen many free range pig farms and feel this is how they should be raised. Please stop the cruelty you have the power. Thank you , kind regards Meghan kelly
- meghan kelly, 10:25 AM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
This sort of "farming" is revolting! So much for promoting New Zealand's clean green immage. this sort of legal animal crulty makes me ashamed of being a Kiwi.
- Elaine Paul, 10:23 AM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
It's ridiculous! In a place like New Zealand, things like this should be absolutely unheard of!
- Kylie Sanders, 10:09 AM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
it engenders completely needless animal suffering. Put a stop to it now.
- Anthony Blears, 9:54 AM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
it's unethical, arrogant and hypocritical. The New Zealand Government should be ashamed to tout this country as clean and green while we employ this practice. Show some integrity and compassion.
- Lucy Arnold, 9:49 AM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
these animals have the right to be treated with respect and these farming practices are certainly not allowing this. The conditions these pigs are being forced to live in are totally unacceptable.
- Carolyn Gibson, 9:49 AM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
it's just unnecessarry hurt. Not in a wishy washy way - appreciate efficiency needs, but what's the difference between a pig and a family's pet dog? If anything pigs are actually more intelligent, and this treatment would never be ok'ed for dogs. It's just good, fair common sense. Thanks John Cheers Stephanie
- Stephanie Fill, 9:47 AM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
It is equally appalling to ban sow stall, but allow the sale of international pork which does not stand up to NZ standards, if you wish to ban sow stall in NZ then please consider banning the importation of stall raised pork in other countries.
- shane mcpherson, 9:25 AM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
we of 'superior intelligence' should be better than to think it's acceptable to treat animals badly.
- Joanna Wilby, 9:25 AM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
my experience raising pigs has shown me what an intelligent animal pigs are. To treat pigs this way is degrading for this species and doesn't at all depict NZ's clean and green image that we try so hard to portray. It is not necessary to treat them like this, their treatment is very similar to the way chickens have been suffering in their crates and chickens in comparison are nowhere near as intelligent as a pig is. Its not like NZ farmers don't have the land necessary to treat them decently, it is the pure greed of the pig farmer that conditions like these still exist.
- Rachel McKnight, 9:08 AM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
there should be a better way. This is very cruel way to house the animals and surely we have enough room in NZ to have farms that do not mean caging the animals.
- Raewyn Brown, 9:06 AM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
Hi Mr Key, This practise must be highly embarresing to you when over seas toting for trade, I bet you never explain to your negotiating partners how NZ pig farmers raise their pigs. [DISCUSTING] regards Patrick Bailey.
- P.E.Bailey, 9:05 AM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
simply; tt is cruel with only little economic gain.
- Johannes van Oldenborgh, 9:02 AM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
if you were a pig would you be happy to be in a small confined space!?? help them ... PLEASE!!!!!!
- Hannah Jensen, 8:55 AM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
To profit of the suffering of another living being is not acceptable on moral grounds and will degrade us as New Zealanders and reduce our moral fibre. I think that is one reason that crime and drugs are increasing here despite harsher penalties At the very least we must promote clear, truthful and legally binding labelling on all products so that consumers can make a clear choice
- marko blagojevic, 8:49 AM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
it is very cruel and very unnatural for an anmimal to be kept in these conditions. This practice should not be allowed and all effort should be taken to stop this way of farming pigs.
- D Bacon , 8:44 AM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
Despite its cruelty everyone is pointing out, my real concern is the end product we're getting - nowadays, who wants a stressed animal for a meal? are we some kind of prehistoric caveman? I would appreciate your leadership and showing an action to support so every New Zealander gets to eat a healthy, tasty pork in a humanly order.
- Joon Park, 8:42 AM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
economic growth does not eclipse everything else, in particular ethics. I am not opposed to farming, but rather to some farming practises. An animal is never simply an economic unit. Demonstrate that National cares about more than dollars.
- Kevin Parker, 8:31 AM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
Do you not have a heart??This is so wrong and cruel.Human greed has caused this now human intervention needs to be of upmost importance.Stop this barbaric practise NOW.
- Mary-ann Oldham, 8:26 AM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
all of the excuses used by the industry for continuing to factory farm are based on economic imperatives, this is about the welfare of animals, not about money. It is obvious to everyone involved, including the farmers, the bureaucrats, and the industry apologists, that factory farming is simply a mistreatment of animals - there is no gloss or reasoning that can be applied that can hide this and anyone who tries to do so needs to take a look at where their moral priorities lie.
- Glen Real, 8:24 AM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
it is a cruel and unneccessary farming method. The UK have banned sow stalls, as have Florida, Arizona and California. We cannot call ourselves a clean and green country while we practice these disgusting farming methods. We must ban these practices and then support the industry by also banning pork imports from countrys that disregard animal welfare. I too, am ashamed to be part of a society that allows these practices to occur.
- Chris Wedding, 8:20 AM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
it is so cruel. I stopped buying pork, because of this. Please stop this cruelty as soon as possible!!
- Elizabeth Dubek, 8:18 AM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
While in England I saw pig farms where they roamed free in different paddocks. They were very well looked after. Why can't we do the same here, why should these poor pigs suffer and not be able to move? Its just cruel! Humans should be more compasionate to animals that they farm. And the picture of the pig is so cute! How can you factory farm that face!
- Hayley , 8:14 AM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
It does not allow pigs to live a 'normal' life and subjects them to unnecessary cruelty. I do not support any farmer who cannot afford the very basic needs of an animal to live in their own natural environment. Pigs also have a right to live in natural light, be free to roam and dig the earth, and breath the natural air, as WE do.
- Sapphire Martin, 8:12 AM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
I have seen how content free-range pigs are when they are in a normal, natural and healthy environment. Being able to do everyday normal pig things - rest under trees, roll amongst grass and wallow in mud. Having a whole life spent within a crate, purely so humans can have a few cheap rashers of bacon, is unbelievably sad.
- Suzy Swanson-Dobbs, 7:55 AM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
even though I am not a vegetarian and belong to no animal welfare groups, I would certainly not want any animal to suffer unnecessarily. We have to make sure we keep a balance between productivity/profit and our humanity in dealing with the world around us and the creatures we effect.
- Danny Adams, 7:36 AM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
As a registered health professional I believe the future of personkind rests on our ability to be compassionate and to have empathy for all living creatures. Please ban sow crates, these animals are intelligent beings having families and a right to live their lives as is intended. Pigs should not be farmed at all, but if that is to occur than at the very least they should be allowed to live some resemblance of their natural life. Sow crates are cruel .Ban sow crates now.
- Loretta Westbrook, 6:57 AM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
It is cruel It encourages factory farming and the endless race to the bottem whereby animals are the ultimate losers. Do we need this much pork anyway?
- Geoff Walker, 6:53 AM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
I love pork and bacon but I also love pigs. Pigs are intelligent and gorgeous creatures that do not deserve years of cruelty and torture. Imagine if we were in their situation? I don't think any animal of any kind should be subjected to such disgusting treatment. Why can't we make their already short-lived lives a little more pleasant? I think it's about time we stopped thinking about ourselves and gave a little thought to the pigs who have no say at all. :)
- Claire Broadbent, 12:59 AM on Tue 13 Apr 2010
I believe the present pig farming methods of confining sows and young pigs is inhumane and reflects badly on us as a progressive nation,we might as well compare ourselves to china who have a very cruel record of animal cruelty
- chris murray, 11:28 PM on Mon 12 Apr 2010
cruelty for profit is not acceptable in a civilised society. The unsanitary conditions in the crates are a reservoir for infections that may be passed to humans- look at BSE- a direct result of intensive farming. You have already sent the message that NZ will tolerate exploitation of our natural resources in class 4 areas; and the proposals in regard to whaling and nuclear energy are also deeply controversial. Please dont send the message to the rest of the world that we tolerate cruelty as well as greed. PROFIT ISN'T EVERYTHING!
- james dunn, 11:19 PM on Mon 12 Apr 2010
animals that we farm for our consumption should be respected & valued & surely deserve a happy life. The law must be changed for these intelligent animals. Any other animal whether farm or pets are protected by laws against cruelty,why not PIGS? The outdated law for pig farming must be changed. PLEASE push for the end of factory farming in this country NOW- for the sake of the animals who give their lives for us, & show the world that we really are a clean green country. Our family will now only eat 'Free Range' pork. We will not support the greed,corruption & cruelty of those involved in factory farming.
- Frances Ransley, 11:02 PM on Mon 12 Apr 2010
...It's just so wrong.
- Johanna Nielsen, 10:54 PM on Mon 12 Apr 2010
it is so inhumane and cruel, and has also put an end to individuals having the opportunity to support themselves as decent, time trusted farmers. I don't believe you have it in you to stand up to this appalling practice, but I pray for it regardless. I guess you could say i am a pretty disgruntled citizen of the country you govern, please do one thing with the integrity of our country and the views of it's citizens in mind. Regards, Kylie Boxall
- Kylie Boxall, 10:40 PM on Mon 12 Apr 2010
I was raised to be kind to all living creatures, and condoning mistreatment of animals goes abainst my moral fibre, and I feel New Zealand is better than this. Set an example Mr Key!
- Rachelle Betti, 10:36 PM on Mon 12 Apr 2010
No eggs bene is worth the thought of how these pigs are treated. NZ should be leading the way with this. Free Range and Organic Framing should be the only type of product being farmed in a "clean Green Nz"
- Tina Plunkett, 10:27 PM on Mon 12 Apr 2010
It is seriously inhumane for pigs to suffer the way they do as all animals deserve to be treated equally. There’s no need to abuse an animal throughout its life if you’re going to put them out of their misery earlier then their dying age especially when pigs are titled as pets as well. As one of the young adults of New Zealand we deserve the right to take away animal cruelty from in our country. We as New Zealanders need to make it a happy place since we are the people of New Zealand’s future.
- Kelsey Babbington, 10:25 PM on Mon 12 Apr 2010
all animals need to have a happy life they have feelings, please hElp them too,
- kylee remington, 10:23 PM on Mon 12 Apr 2010
lets do this the humane way.
- ben, 10:13 PM on Mon 12 Apr 2010
it is our responsibility as human beings to ensure that all living things are treated with love and compassion. Let's together do our best to safeguard the rights of our animals. Please do all you can to help. Thank you so very much for reading this letter Prime Minister John Key. Your sincerely, Sarah Pavadai
- Sarah Pavadai, 10:12 PM on Mon 12 Apr 2010
of the suffering it so obviously imparts upon pigs, an intelligent, sentient animal. It makes me so angry and ashamed to be part of a society that allows these practices to occur. And they largely occur because until recently people have been are unaware of industry practices. You will be aware of the outrage the public has expressed since these practices have come to light. Please support the ban of sow and farrowing crates; it is incredibly inhumane and should have no place in a modern, affluent society.
- James Ruffell, 9:56 PM on Mon 12 Apr 2010
animals have feelings,like humans.NO animal deserves to be treated with crulety.Its disgusting that this is clasified ok and is illegal because it is sick!! Britx
- Brittany Anderson, 9:54 PM on Mon 12 Apr 2010
these animals deserves to live happy and fulfilling lives before they become our food. All animals should be treated with respect and factory farming is simply cruel and unacceptable. Please help give them the lives they deserve.
- Shannah Sayers, 9:51 PM on Mon 12 Apr 2010
It is animal cruelty to do it to a domestic pet and pigs are not much different if anything they are smarter. It's unfair and unjustified. People will pay more
- Jay dudson, 9:48 PM on Mon 12 Apr 2010
these animals that have feelings just like you and me cannot stand up for themselves. They are instead made to suffer for our eventual pleasure.
- Lorna Hales, 9:48 PM on Mon 12 Apr 2010
because I am a strong believer in the five freedoms that are supposed to be demonstated while caring for animals and I think factory farming breaks four of the five freedoms and we, you and me should be doing something about it.. I believe the industry knows what they are doing but are too greedy and unwilling to part with money to give the proper welfare these animals deserve. This is New Zealand not a third world country.
- Carly Marr, 9:34 PM on Mon 12 Apr 2010
The first time I saw a documentary about pigs being farmed in these disgraceful conditions, was filmed in the U.K. up until then (about 18mths ago) I never knew these type of places existed.While I was watching, I remember thinking, this would never go in N.Z. so I was totally floored when I watched Mike King showing us all that it actually DOES happen here.Since then, I have only purchased Free Range Pork for those in the family who eat pork, there's no way our family will support or condone that kind of treatment of any animal. Its revolting.Personally I think that not only is it cruel and unecessary to "farm" animals this way,its unsanitary not only for the animals but also as a food source.Organic or free range bacon has a sweet smell not like the strong "body odour" type of smell you get when cooking factory farmed pork.Finally, all I can say is, I hope our government has the strength courage and decency to stop this factory "farming" ASAP So much for our clean, green image
- Julie Elizabeth Glover, 9:33 PM on Mon 12 Apr 2010
the amount of food produced daily far exceeds the amount consumed. Therefore we are effectively torturing animals in order to create profit for a small number of farmers. If the price of pork, ham and bacon was to rise, it would encourage people to purchase only what is needed and diminish the amount wasted. If you saw the amount of produce thrown out on a daily basis from supermarkets as well as individual's kitchens, items past their 'use by date', I'm sure you would agree. New Zealand is a wealthy country, there is more than enough food to feed us, and we have one of the highest percentages of obesity in the modern world. Would it really hurt to produce less, eat a little less and create a more humane environment for the animals that feed us?
- Jennifer Souness, 9:19 PM on Mon 12 Apr 2010
it is horrible to see the pigs in this situation and if this continues I will be pork free.
- Lisa North, 9:18 PM on Mon 12 Apr 2010
Please Mr Key, let's stop this now, and not make pigs and humans wait for another round of debates like this.
- Irina H, 9:07 PM on Mon 12 Apr 2010
the treatment is both barbaric and unnecessary. its time to move forward and treat animals with the respect they deserve. Free- range pork should be the only choice
- daniella, 8:51 PM on Mon 12 Apr 2010
It's a cruel and unneccessary method of farming which taints New Zealands clean green image. Keeping one of the most intelligent animals in the world in these crates is torturous, especially when consumers would pay extra for free range pork.
- Natalia Curtis, 8:34 PM on Mon 12 Apr 2010
Hi John, I hope you will give the utmost urgency to bring this evil Pork trade to an end as soon as possible. Please also ban all imports of cheap Pork products, if we must import then country of origin plus farming method MUST be stated, thank you. Best regards Douglas Anderson
- Douglas Anderson, 8:31 PM on Mon 12 Apr 2010
New Zealand prides itself on our clean, green image, how is our pig farming practice inline with this image? New Zealand is well behind the times in pig farming and the guidelines surrounding this area. Animal cruelty is illegal in terms of cats and dogs, why are the rights of pigs overlooked?
- Jo Malcolm, 8:21 PM on Mon 12 Apr 2010
This is pure cruelty. I don't know why this is even legal. I believe it is a low point in New Zealand.
- Grace Meyer, 8:04 PM on Mon 12 Apr 2010
animals that are sentient beings should not be subjected to conditions that cause them suffering. A pig's life is just as important to the pig as yours is to you, Prime Minister.
- Liz Hibbs, 7:23 PM on Mon 12 Apr 2010
i fear that if aliens begin to harvest humans they will treat us with the same respect that we treated animals with.
- Paul Renwick, 7:11 PM on Mon 12 Apr 2010
It is a completely uneccessary practice. We, as a society, do not have the right to cheap pork at the expense of humane farming.
- Mirelle Quin, 7:02 PM on Mon 12 Apr 2010
it is cruel, inhumane, and unneccesary. No animal deserves to spend its life this way,and after seeing freerange pigfarming in England, with our land, there is no reason we cannot promote this form of farming.
- Courtney Paull, 6:58 PM on Mon 12 Apr 2010
just because they have been doing it for years does not justify us keeping doing this cruel practice. We do not have the justification to plead ignorance anymore..we are all better informed that this practice is in-humane and against the current welfare laws! Follow the rest of the intelligent and humane countries which bann these stalls in Europe. Listen to the people in NZ. How are we to keep our clean, green NZ image when we still do this every day. We are never going to be able to compete woth the rest of the world in shear numbers but we can remain organic and cruelty-free and become a real niche market that everyone in the world would want to buy from. Thanks.
- Becky Cox, 6:52 PM on Mon 12 Apr 2010
look, quire frankly,i think maybey the factory farmers should lock hem seleves in a sow creat for a while and i know your a big fancy polititian guy bu maybey you shoul just take a few moments to actually think about this its a serious problem pigs are living things its not like thier a 5 dollar bill, they have fellings just like you and i at the moment everything seems to be about rugby the government needs to pay more attention to other matters we can live without rugby for three minutes cant we just take three minutes to imagine how terrible it would be to be locked up in a sow crate go to a factory farm please wouldnt it just be eaisier to end this atle do a servey of how may mps think its good to keep living creatures locked up they never hurt anyone its not like they're gonna murder anyone just find itm in your heart to feel for te pigs what 2018 thats not soon enough !!! thanks or not
- isla thomas, 6:40 PM on Mon 12 Apr 2010
They feel pain and discomfort just like all animals do. If it costs more to have free range pig farms (or any kind of animal farming for that fact)and is more labour intensive then wouldnt that be a way to get more jobs for NZers and if the government regulated the price of pork - then farmers wouldnt be battling uphill all the time and wouldnt mind the extra work being done for free range farming. There are a lot of options to prevent animal cruelty - Pigs / animals bleed when hurt and get scared - just like humans do - therefore it is fair to say that we should treat pigs humainly.
- Shanna Coe, 6:33 PM on Mon 12 Apr 2010
it is just inhumane. People need to appreciate where there food comes from and the stats show people that commit crimes on animals often progress to violence against other humans...what does that say about our society. Wwhen will people realise all creatures need respect - how can we be called civilised when we behave like this. If anyone can help, you can John. I voted for you and would like to see you help here.
- Gail Anderson, 6:20 PM on Mon 12 Apr 2010
It really disturbs me (and a lot of other people) that grown pigs are kept in cages that are not even big enough to turn around in. It's not fair. It says in the Animal Welfare act "animals must be able to express their natural patterns of behavior" there are some loopholes that need correcting. These pigs will probably end up on our table...can they not please have some sort of decent life, a life they deserve because they are after all living creatures and pigs are actually quite an intelligent animal. They shouldn't have to suffer frustration at not being able to wander around (which is completley natural for them). Some sows are kept in 60cm by 2m. At the moment they are allowed to be confined in crates for their entire lives until 2013! We can't wait til 2018 to ban sow stalls. I know this affects a lot of people. A lot of people have been talking about it lately. You have the power, none of us do unfortunatley. Thank you so much for taking the time to hopefully read this. Please help us... As soon as possible... Tracy.
- Tracy, 5:39 PM on Mon 12 Apr 2010
it is a dreadful thing to put pigs through. And unnecessary. Please consider supporting this ban. Kind Regards, Emma
- Emma Hislop, 5:36 PM on Mon 12 Apr 2010
I believe that pigs and all animals deserve a free life. We control them like we own them when really, We don't. We use, abuse and then throw them out. We need to change our lives and change the mainstream view on animals. Leave the pigs alone.. Please..
- Edwin Quinney, 5:23 PM on Mon 12 Apr 2010
pigs are highly intellent animals and this sort of treatment is a terrible way for them to live out their lives, it saddens me to see that some people will put profit before kindness, these animals suffer and there is no need for it. Please help the pigs!!!
- Kim Verschaffelt, 5:20 PM on Mon 12 Apr 2010
These animals are suffering - they are jammed in tiny crates and can't turn around. They are in pain. How would you like it if someone did this to you or your family members? If you support factory farming then you are taking part in animal cruelty. You have the power to do something...so do it!
- Kate Norman, 5:15 PM on Mon 12 Apr 2010
Animals have one right, that is the right not to be owned. We need to stop mistreating sentient beings of all species.
- Pip Adam, 5:06 PM on Mon 12 Apr 2010
i wont eat pig after seeing the horrible conditions that they've been kept in! and im enouraging people to do the same. I can't believe no one knows about the cruelty they are put in its horrible
- Alesha Garrity, 4:25 PM on Mon 12 Apr 2010
it is easy enough & better for the pigs if they are home grown on farms. There is no shortage of farms in NZ. Everyone knows somebody who knows somebody who has a farm to raise a pig on.
- Shannon Withers, 4:24 PM on Mon 12 Apr 2010
it is obiviously cruel and it is plain common sense. Free range pork is more expensive, but I believe even this price would come down if more people were doing it. If it is banned in NZ then support the pig farmers so they do not loose their market share. Food is already far too unaffordable. This issue should be dealt with in general and not used as an excuse to continue with cruel farming practices.
- Kim Cerqueira, 3:51 PM on Mon 12 Apr 2010
In the bible it talks about man having dominion over the animals. Dominion does not mean domination but care taking, responsibility for the well being of these creatures. I'm not religious but I understand this principle. Because we breed these animals we are responsible for their lives, their happiness, their freedom to be as they were intended to be. When we confine them to sow crates and factory farms we destroy not only the animals lives but also our own integrity. We stamp on the concept of dominion, and of basic respect for an animals right to live well. It is a dual sickness destroying not only our pigs but ourselves. Namaste, Emily
- Emily Vincent, 3:37 PM on Mon 12 Apr 2010
john key. why do these pigs have to suffer why why why. it so sad to hear what these pigs go threw!!!!!! so please lets stop factory farming pigs. please just stop
- courtney bredesen, 3:31 PM on Mon 12 Apr 2010
It is a barbaric way to keep any being for any length of time. Requirements to survive in a healthy environment is to have all of basic wants of life. Which includes Shelter, Food, environmental enrichment for any animal the ability to feel the earth and move around in a normal way. Keeping pigs this way is like back in the dark ages, if we kept any dog or cat in this way in our country charges would be laid (I hope!). Pigs have been proven to have an intelligence that rivals humans! When are we going to stop this criminal bahaviour??
- Julie Grenfell, 3:08 PM on Mon 12 Apr 2010
Please please stop this cruelty to our pigs, we wouldnt treat our dogs or cats in this manner nor our children and it is no different. These animals are alive with feelings and this must stop.I have stopped buying pork from supermarket over 2 years ago and refuse to ever buy it again. Many of my friends and relations feel the same way too. Spca would prosecute you for treating any other animal in this way. STOP STOP STOP please!!!!!
- karen morfett, 2:58 PM on Mon 12 Apr 2010
HI John. As a long standing supporter of the National Party I ask you to look at the appalling conditions the factory farmed pigs live in in New Zealand, I am worried about the pigs welfare and our image as a caring nation, friends of mine from overseas are asking me about this campaign saying they thought we were a caring nation, this cannot be doing our image any favors, lets be the leaders in this, not left to make excuses for our behavior towards animals. I ask you to join me in getting these crates banned as soon as possible then I can talk to my foreign friends with pride. Many thanks Audrey Campbell
- audrey campbell, 2:25 PM on Mon 12 Apr 2010
it is unhuman, disgusting and not like the new zealand nature. Make postive changes for my generation, that`s all we want. You think that we`re all misunderstood and have deep issues but what`s really wrong here is YOU! make this change!!
- Sophia McKay, 2:24 PM on Mon 12 Apr 2010
The cruel and totally unnecessary “factory farming" practice needs to be stopped now. New Zealand needs to take a firm stand against factory pig farming by not only banning it but also placing a ban on imported pork. New Zealand could be a world leader in free-range "happy" pig farming. This would benefit NZ pig farmers by ensuring the world that we produce top quality cruelty free pork ... which would then of course command top prices from those willing to pay for it. Please act soon and stop this barbaric practice from continuing.
- J F Rees, 2:22 PM on Mon 12 Apr 2010
I think the words " Factory Farmed Pigs" say it all. Do we really need this cruelty to continue? I am disgusted that as a country we allow this practice to happen. THIS NEEDS TO BE STOPPED NOW Please change the law and put a stop to this toture that these beautiful innocent creatures have been made to endure.
- Kiri Warren, 2:07 PM on Mon 12 Apr 2010
I am opposed to factory farming as its inhumane.
- Jill Ballinger, 2:01 PM on Mon 12 Apr 2010
New Zealand has an International reputation which is below Third World standards. I am continually appalled and disgusted by the lack of humane care with the battery farming of pigs and poultry in New Zealand. Please put a stop to this type of farming. In the future this will have comparisons to the Nazis. Thank for taking note.
- Kathy Henry, 1:49 PM on Mon 12 Apr 2010
it's completely inhumane and insanely cruel!! I believe this type of farming falls completely short of the rights all living beings deserve. No being deserves to be treated(tortured) this way. It is proven that pigs are as intelligent as dogs.... would you treat your family pet this way?? I think not(o; and hope that you'd be pulled up pretty quick if you did(o; It's time to stand up and give pigs the happy, free ranging life they deserve. I say this in gest, but am completely genuine when I PLEE: FREE THE PIGS!!!!!!! I'm sure you've heard it 100 times but I'm going to share it with you again....To quote Ghandi: “The greatness of a nation and its moral progress can be judged by the way its animals are treated” Please ban these cruel and unhealthy sow and farrow crates and factory farming. With peace and blessings Lucy
- Lucy Jane Smith, 1:48 PM on Mon 12 Apr 2010
- Anna Jackson , 1:34 PM on Mon 12 Apr 2010
it is ethically wrong. New Zealand's 'clean green' image is under the spotlight at present and the decisions you make about mining,whaling, factory farming and water usage will make an impact on the world's view of us. If the electorate does not judge you for such actions in 2011, the international community will do so. Yours sincerely Paul Edington
- Paul Edington, 1:15 PM on Mon 12 Apr 2010
if we are to regard ourselves as humane, thinking human beings, then we have a duty to give the lives of animals that we breed for our eating, as good a life as we can. Pigs are highy intelligent. Most pig farmers treat their pigs in a disgusting way. To ignore the plight of these pigs is to be something less than human. Is there no politican who will do anything?
- Leonora Wall, 1:12 PM on Mon 12 Apr 2010
They don't need to live like that, It's cruel. Please stop it.
- Janelle Freeman, 1:06 PM on Mon 12 Apr 2010
it seems a tiny space to be confined in, especially when the sow is a large creature, she needs to be able to stretch out and turn around - likewise when she has her piglets - there needs to be space, and clean space - not riddled with flies and the like. Thank you.
- H Daintree, 1:02 PM on Mon 12 Apr 2010
Pigs are intelligent animals. Just like us, they seek to have a happy life, have room to move, eat, express themselves. We can raise animals for meat in more humane ways that give them a decent quality of life. This is an appalling way to treat our fellow creatures. They should not be living in crates. I for one am boycotting all NZ pork and urging all of my friends to do the same until pigs have a better life. Thank you.
- Rebecca Reider, 12:47 PM on Mon 12 Apr 2010
they are highly unethical and should not legally exist in the civilised society. New Zealand has one of the most advanced animal welfare legislation in the world yet at the same time permitt the NZ dairy and pig industry to continue their highly controversial and unethical farming practices.
- Jan Roznawski, 12:22 PM on Mon 12 Apr 2010
Common John this cruelty in our own back yard, please don't turn a blind eye.
- Tony Minto, 12:14 PM on Mon 12 Apr 2010
I beg you to read a book just published called 'Eating Animals' by Jonathan Safran Foer. It is incredibly well written and thought provoking and deals extensively with factory farming. Before reading this book I had no idea what factory farming was. Now I refuse to eat factory farmed meat. As the Prime Minister of our country you have a responsibility not only to the human citizens of this country but to the animals as well. Their suffering is on your shoulders. To ignore their plight is to ignore monstrosities on an industrial scale. I understand you need to make decisions that will work for the entire country, all I ask is you do that with some real knowledge of factory farming. An informed decision is one that I can respect. Please read the book. Please.
- Melanie Webster, 12:04 PM on Mon 12 Apr 2010
pigs are 'living' in habitats that are extremely traumatising and darn right unnatural for them. No space to move, separated from their babies, no natural light or grass. It's shocking, it makes me ashamed to be a human. You, John and most other logical humans know that it's all for money!! Squeeze as many pigs into a barn, fatten them up so we can sell them to masses of people. Since i was a child I chose not to eat pigs, maybe because they have a lot of character, emotion and intelligenc like a dog. However I eat meat sometimes, only ethical(free range).It sickens me how people treat farmed and factory farmed animals to make big bucks-$. Thank you for taking the time to read our letters John, please support this ban, if it helps do visit a factory farm. Pigs are beautiful creatures with plenty of feelings and personality. No animal deserves a life of suffering. Thank you for helping your people and your loving furry friends :) Charlotte Orr
- Charlotte Orr, 11:56 AM on Mon 12 Apr 2010
I believe that this practice is something that shows New Zealand to be a greedy nation more concerned with keeping pork meat 'cheap' than allowing an animal room to even turn around within it's tiny crate. The condition of the pigs and the fact that they live almost their entire lives miserable and are intelligent enough to understand such misery is disturbing. I am ashamed to say that I am a huge lover of roast pork, and have purchased a lot of pork meat over the years un-aware of such horrific farming practices. I refuse to buy NZ Pork any more unless it is free farmed as I will NOT pay a cent into this horrendous industry. I hope as Prime Minister you will stand up for NZ'ers and the welfare of these pigs and call for an end to these awful conditions. Yours Sincerely Eclypse Lee
- Eclypse, 11:34 AM on Mon 12 Apr 2010
of the intelligence of the animal - basically, if you wouldn't keep a four year old child in those conditions,- don't do it pigs!
- della welch, 11:18 AM on Mon 12 Apr 2010
Dear John Key, I am writing to ask you to please ban the support of both pig sow & farrowing crates in New Zealand, they are very cruel & even though I am a vegetarian I have taught the rest of my family the importance of having respect for all the food that you eat & most especially the way that the animals live before they become food on your plate, they at least deserve to have a good quality of life while still alive, I think that with all the animal cruelty that goes on in New Zealand these days that we as a country should be setting a good example that all animals have feelings & suffer from hurt and pain just as you and I do. Best Regards Susan Beacham
- Susan Beacham, 11:05 AM on Mon 12 Apr 2010
I think that New Zealand should be world leaders in sustainable/holistic living. We all know that our 'clean and green' image and the survival of our country as we know it due to tourism is essential to our economy and yet frankly, our image is not clean or green. It is the reason that I live in New Zealand and not in America. The fact that we allow any animal cruelty to happen at all is disgusting. It's time it stopped.
- Je t'aime Hayr, 10:59 AM on Mon 12 Apr 2010
it is cruel and inhumane that we would subject living creatures to such horrible, horrible conditions. PLEASE make the changes so we can be proud about oursleves Thank you Dave
- David Grace, 10:57 AM on Mon 12 Apr 2010
causes unneccesary suffering and there is no reason to keep them in such a small confined area, at least allow them to be able to turn around.
- Judith Cramer, 10:56 AM on Mon 12 Apr 2010
I believe we as a society should respect the rights and wellbeing of animals - even those animals that we eat. Just because an animal will eventually become food does not mean it should suffer while it's alive. The government needs to step in and outlaw these cruel practices. This will ensure that the market for pork is fair (e.g. competitive pricing) and that free-range farmers are not penalised for being decent human beings.
- Andrew Campbell, 10:44 AM on Mon 12 Apr 2010
John, I am having real trouble explaining to my daughter how in this day and age we can continue to support such cruel practices in New Zealand. Our family does not support cruelty to animals in any shape or form. Please help make our generation be the one that helps make this country a kinder place for all animals. Thank you.
- Phil Brien, 10:39 AM on Mon 12 Apr 2010
it is an inhumane and unnecessary practise. New Zealand could and should lead the rest of the world in the way it treats its animals. We are 'clean and green', let's be humane too.
- Carey Conn, 10:25 AM on Mon 12 Apr 2010
the cruelty is insupportable. We did not buy pork or bacon for some years because of these farming practices. We do now buy Freedom Farm bacon and pork products because we trust the farming processes that are used. I am not a vegetarian, but I do choose not to eat meat when it has been inappropriately and cruelly farmed. An animal has a right to as natural and comfortable life as possible because it is killed for food. Please change these archaic laws.
- Angela Walker, 10:12 AM on Mon 12 Apr 2010
it is an inhumane practice which has no place in a civilised society. I understand that no pig farming management system is perfect and much depends on good animal husbandary but the intensive pork industry could make far great efforts to meet consumers expectations. I ask the Government step in to ensure the best outcome for production animals.
- Kate Horrey, 10:07 AM on Mon 12 Apr 2010
there are alternative methods which have shown that ethical treatment can be humane AND profitable. PLEASE look at the alternatives and do not be swayed by a minority who are only interested in their own financial welfare.
- Aaron, 10:06 AM on Mon 12 Apr 2010
Pure in simple, this is a disgusting act of animal cruelty. If these animals are going to die for our sake, allow them to do it with dignity.
- Francesca de Jong, 9:54 AM on Mon 12 Apr 2010
We are a country, surely, with compassion for those animals we rear to be eaten. Our country has a huge industry of animal food production that we also export to the world. It is the height of hypocrisy to purport to have a "clean, green" image in tourism with a damning record of animal cruelty in the pork industry. It seems to be run by old white men who have got used to doing things in certain ways and are railing against change. I understand most likely costs will go up with the impending changes but perhaps the pig industry should consider educating the public on how to use smaller portions of pork since it's cost is likely to go up.
- Lori Dungey, 9:49 AM on Mon 12 Apr 2010
Please John, Please look into this cruel process. It just cannot be right for NZ to support such a cruel practice. The photos are evidence enough. Why dont you go and look for yourself. Please John, dont let this be overlooked in support of more "omportant" things. This is important to your NZ people. Liundsey
- Lindsey Field, 9:46 AM on Mon 12 Apr 2010
Dear Mr Keys, there is no reason why any animals should be caged or held in any form of captivity so that breeding for eating can be controlled. we have asmall farm in kaukapakapa and find the meat we eat tastes much nicer that the commerically farmed meats, due moslty to unstressed animals. We all have to have a heart and feel for these poor creatures. they cannot fight for themselves they must be abel to live outside where god intended them to be Regards Wendy O'Flaherty
- W O'Flaherty, 9:46 AM on Mon 12 Apr 2010
it is unnatural, unnecessary and a hideous blight on the way this country treats pigs, and produces pork. Please do something about this immeidately. The pictures are making me feel sick, and our family has gone pork free.
- Melanie Douglas, 9:44 AM on Mon 12 Apr 2010
it does not allow the pigs to exhibit natural behaviour. We have incredible abuse of animals and children in this country. I believe if we respect and treat animals fairly there will be a flow on effect towards all the vulnerable and defenseless. Imagine a world where consideration was given to the suffering of the defenseless what an impact this would have on the community. By allowing factory farming in particular sow and farrowing crates you give a loud clear message to the community that you have no respect for those who cannot speak for themselves. Sow crates are about making more money for the pig farmer, if in more natural environment a few piglets are crushed inadvertedly this is nature's way to ensure that the remainder get enough milk to thrive. Factory farming encapulates the greed of the powerful while encouraging greed and profit making at the expense of defenseless. Please give serious consideration to outlawing this atrocity.
- Christine Jenkins, 9:39 AM on Mon 12 Apr 2010
this is a disgusting way of farming. We wouldn't treat our children like this or our family animals, so why treat another living being like this.
- Cheryl Wheeler, 9:30 AM on Mon 12 Apr 2010
growing up on a farm as a kid and seeing animals in a "free" environment makes me feel ill when I think about how other animals, grown purely to eat/have product "extracted" from are treated. It just seems fair that if we are to exploit the pigs for our own gain that we in turn give them the respect to have green grass and fresh air until they are consumed.
- Robbie Boyd, 9:22 AM on Mon 12 Apr 2010
no animal should be born or raised in a windowless cell of concrete and steel. Mahatma Gandhi said "The greatness of a nation and its moral progress can be judged by the way in which its animals are treated." NZ may be a small country, but we have have a proud history of protecting the vunerable and standing up for what is right. Let us continue in this way by stopping factory farming of animals.
- Judith Becker, 9:19 AM on Mon 12 Apr 2010
I have been unable to ignore the life that these intelligent animals endure to satisfy a hungry demand. I no longer buy bacon unless its free range and I will continue to do so until the laws change, despite my budget. All animals deserve a life with respect for there health & happiness.... All we are asking is that they are given the care & compassion in the short time that they have in this world before they end up on our plates. These farmers that have there animals in appalling conditions, should never have become farmers & deserve the respect they give there animals. The vet on TV the other night supporting these farmers should be assamed to call himself a vet, my daughter would like to be a vet when she's older (Now 10) & I hope to god she never sells her self to the local pig farmers. Please help us Mr Keys, I voted for you & I hope to again, but you need to make a stand & I truely thought you would be the one to do that. Kind regards Dayna
- Dayna, 9:16 AM on Mon 12 Apr 2010
cows an sheep live a good life y not pigs i no u got a heart pigs have got a heart we dont need pig meat that badly there is other ways its not like we dont have room in nz please mr key i gave u my vote because u r a good guy just ban factory pigs reg dan
- daniel, 8:56 AM on Mon 12 Apr 2010
It's a good idea to stop the cruelty now so the pigs can have a new lease of life, it's so unfair that they're not being treated decently like they should - if they're good enough to eat then they're good enough to have a wee run around and nail clipping bbefore their life comes to an end, it will not cost the farmers that much more and what it does cost they can get back from their profits so there's no reason not to really. Ban the crates mate.
- Anna Bensemann, 8:55 AM on Mon 12 Apr 2010
i think it is digusting and every time i see the ad on tv i just feel so shocked and sad to see an animal treated in such disrespect. please stop this!
- David Stewart, 8:51 AM on Mon 12 Apr 2010
it's plain wrong. The fact that some vets say its okay does not make it right at all. You have to be incredibly naive to say that those animals are well taken care of. It just makes me sick that this is how we treat animals in a developed country like ours. I'm ashamed and I hope you are too.
- Shevan Silva, 8:35 AM on Mon 12 Apr 2010
the animals have no quality of life. If we (the public) treated our pets like this we would be prosecuted (an rightly so). Why should farmers be allowed to get away with treating these animals like this?
- Tanya Scobie, 8:35 AM on Mon 12 Apr 2010
All animals should be able to be raised in a humane way, with sunlight, fresh air and room to move. Our animal farming needs to be improved in NZ and not just for profit or the easiest way to rear them. Come on PM - please eradicate crates soon.
- Rose Ashley, 8:28 AM on Mon 12 Apr 2010
I pride myself in being part of a caring society as New Zealand is supposed to be - please put a stop to crate farming so we can hold our heads up high and say ours is a compassionate country.
- Jeanette Hanson, 8:25 AM on Mon 12 Apr 2010
as a 'civilised' nation we should be taking the opportunity to lead the world in our treatment of animals and have no tolerance for animal cruelty or exploitation. The banning of sow crates is a remarkable and unique opportunity for us to show the rest of the world that it is barbaric and unnecessary to farm animals in this way
- Dale Leyland, 8:21 AM on Mon 12 Apr 2010
this practise is incredibly cruel and I do not believe most consumers are aware of what they are purchasing. NZ is supposed to be an open and free environment and that is something the majority of us are proud of. PLEASE HELP! I am huge fan of yours and national supporter and know that you take steps to do whats right. I hope you will see the logic in this.
- Nyssa Waters, 8:12 AM on Mon 12 Apr 2010
... I have a vision for New Zealand to be a world leader in compassion for flora and fauna, hoping that we will one day be quoted as an ideal in this area due to our kiwi ingenuity, finding a way to make these types of issues into economical and sustainable practice.
- Jennifer Nickel, 8:01 AM on Mon 12 Apr 2010
we live in the 21st century and should be able to produce our food without such cruelties. Espacially, because it is not impossible or economically not sustainable. Furthermore, the meat will taste better and will be more healthier for us, than meat from pigs who have been fed with hormons and antibiotheks. greetings ELisabeth Hobl
- Elisabeth Hobl, 3:16 AM on Mon 12 Apr 2010
It is ethically wrong to deny any animal (food animal or not) its natural instinctual behaviour. Politicians should be made to take a conscience vote on this matter & acknowlege the real truth here - that this is indeed speceism - of the most obvious kind ie for sheer convenience and profit- and it is Morally Unacceptable. It is understandable also that after more than 10 years now, I and so many others have entirely 100% No Confidence in AWAC and its 100%-biasedness in any animal welfare-related issues, and also No confidence in any legal or political system that ever allowed a body such as this to write and continue to set its Own rules of conduct - How totally irresponsible and inexcusable a decision by any governing 'watch-dogs.' Shame on the pork industry, AWAC and David Carter and any politicians (individually and collectively) who are complicit in allowing this practice in itself, to continue. There are so many politicians of course with vested agricultural interests - who will however also need to answer one day for their actions -or inaction, in this ethical matter. Denying something is cruel is also no escape from the universal karmic law to which we are All subject (whether we also acknowlege this or not). I certainly can't vote for National this time if pig-'farming' crate practices are not banned and the NZ pork industry shamed into action This Time. [I would also be too ashamed to vote for any government that ever allowed live-sheep exporting again...surely we would never want NZ to be viewed in this primitive and barbaric light anyway] Will you be the first enlightened PM John in terms of finally taking a moral stand here to protect these pigs -these innocent & vulnerable conscious creatures- or will you also try to justify and condone this speceism? Just how much torture via these crates would you inflict by your inaction on this innocent species before you too John would say 'Enough is Enough'? ...You will certainly receive a groundswell of the most genuine form of deep respect (verbal and silent), were you to do the right thing this time. I, and all genuinely decent NZers now hope- that you will indeed do the right thing now.
- Bridie Gregan, 11:08 PM on Sun 11 Apr 2010
they are very inhumane and archaic ways to treat animals. There is absolutely no reason (perhaps other than the financial cost) that pigs cannot be kept in a more humane way which allows them to actually turn around, and move freely in an open space. Cost should not be used as a reason to justify such awful treatment of pigs. Factory farming seems very third world, and I think that if the government is going to allow it, then that is very bad judgement, which can only be based upon a complete failure to recognise the tragedy that is a factory farmed pig's life. Please ban sow and farrowing crates.
- Gretchen J G Hart, 10:32 PM on Sun 11 Apr 2010
all animals have the right to live in a happy and healthy envrionment. We must never forget that ultimately the give their lives for our nourishment and enjoyment of eating. We must repay this at the very least by giving them the respect and care that they deserve. Pigs are extremely intelligent and feel pain and anguish just as we do and and are only kept in such appalling conditions purely for financial gain. No one would allow humans to be kept like this and nor should we be so unfeeling and devoid of all compassion that animals should be expected to live like this. Please do what is right and just. Thank you. Annie Cleary
- Annie Cleary, 10:29 PM on Sun 11 Apr 2010
It makes me angry to know that we live in a country where the treatment of pigs is so terrible. Why has it reached this stage? Where is the standard of care? Why are there no measures to protect the pigs or any other animals that are intensively farmed. This has obviously been happening for a long time and yet despite public outrage it has been allowed to continue. It is shameful that there are no morals or values regarding the welfare of our animals.
- Denise Welsh, 10:13 PM on Sun 11 Apr 2010
I have worked on a Pig Farm in Cambridgeshire England and have good work experience of managing these lovely animals. Conditions in which they were kept throughout their short lives were totally different from the appaling conditions which appeat to be prevalent in parts of the NZ industry. Better conditions need to be legislated for. It would be good if you could get this through. Phil Peters 3. Thorp Street MOTUEKA
- Philip Peters, 9:55 PM on Sun 11 Apr 2010
it is just wrong! Thank you, Amanda Richards
- amanda richards, 9:47 PM on Sun 11 Apr 2010
The time to put an end to this barbaric way of farming pigs is way overdue. Please use your power to stop these cruel farming practices. I haven't eaten meat for 13 years solely due to animal welfare concerns. I continue to fight for animals to be treated with the respect they deserve. Look what happens when they are abused, mad cow disease, bird flu, swine flu, to name a few. What goes around...comes around.
- Gillian Bicknell, 9:29 PM on Sun 11 Apr 2010
it hurts New Zealand's international image and hurts innocent creatures for no good reason.
- Zachary Dorner, 9:18 PM on Sun 11 Apr 2010
Pigs deserve fair treatment!!!
- Julien Arnoux, 9:06 PM on Sun 11 Apr 2010
all animals should enjoy the type of life they naturally deserve. Farming outdoors in natural conditions is better for the sow which in turn is better for the piglets which in turn must be better for consumers. NZ has made other great stands ... let's join Switzerland and produce quality products.
- Shelly Carr, 9:05 PM on Sun 11 Apr 2010
It is disgusting that in NZ where we are known as a nation of farmers, primitive and barbaric treatment of animals is still in use. Darwin said that pigs are one of the most intelligent of animals, science has confirmed this. But even if they were not intelligent, all animals particularly those dependant upon humans, deserve to be cared for. I believe humans have an obligation to treat with respect, animals in their charge. Free range pig farms manage well without resorting to cruel practises. There is no valid reason to allow any animal to suffer the conditions we have seen lately on TV. Glen McKenzie
- Glen McKenzie, 9:04 PM on Sun 11 Apr 2010
it is totally unecessary to keep animals in such appalling conditions. Pigs are very intelligent animals, to let them suffer in a tiny crate in which they cannot even turn around is unbelievably cruel. I don't understand how any 'farmer' can do this to his 'bread & butter'. These people should be made an example of... How Not to 'Farm'. Should profit turn people to such dispicable acts, I don't think so. Please John, do something about it. Make these practices illegal. Let us have a country with happy pigs and better pig products. Regards Sue Stroud
- Sue Stroud, 9:00 PM on Sun 11 Apr 2010
its the worst practice ever and you have to power to stop this right away. Theres no need to cruelty to animals. How much more per kilo for humanly kept pigs? Let them out to the grass. Its one thing we are not short of. GO SAFE Margaret
- margaret macaulay, 8:50 PM on Sun 11 Apr 2010
its a cruel and horrible practice. We have more than enough land to support the small number of pigs raised in New Zealand. I wouldn't keep a rat in those conditions. The sad part is if a dog was found in the same condition they would be prosecuted yet we allow it to happen to pigs. Pigs have natural instincts. I support free range pigs and i hope NZ shames thee pig industry who endorse this practice John Harding Pukerua Bay
- John Harding, 8:45 PM on Sun 11 Apr 2010
It makes Me sick and very angry to see these amazing beautiful creatures treated in such a cruel way. Please, Please.....Use your power to STOP this Now !!!!
- Debs Crowe, 8:40 PM on Sun 11 Apr 2010
Dear John Key, I am writing to bring to your attention the terrible treatment of pigs in New Zealand. I hope that we can all put an end to Sow Stalls and other shocking living standards that these poor animals suffer. I refuse to buy bacon, ham or pork that is not sold by Freedom Farms as the treatment of pigs in our country is horrific. We cannot let this continue to happen. There is no need for it. Pigs are highly intelligent animals that should be treated with respect. Please help us support the fair treatment of these lovely creatures. Thankyou so much for your time. Melissa Pearce
- Melissa Pearce, 8:35 PM on Sun 11 Apr 2010
no animal should be treated in this way esp. just for pure profit. NZ should lead the way in good farming practice.
- James McLeod, 8:28 PM on Sun 11 Apr 2010
the human race has lost all dignity and it's time each one of us started to claim this back. How we treat each other and how we treat other living beings is a large part of this.
- susan allen, 7:55 PM on Sun 11 Apr 2010
it is a historic practice that should be left in the past, we have the knowledge and rescources to upgrade our pig farming industry, and to ignore the fact that is needs to be done would be negligent. Not only is it undeniably inhumane it is also a huge embarrasment that we portray our pork industry to be something it is not. This subject needs to be exposed to New Zealanders, meat that has come from cages shared with rotting carcasses and neglected animals is disturbing and undesirable, we have the right to choose if this is what we want to eat. Thankyou :)
- sara boros, 7:54 PM on Sun 11 Apr 2010
Imagine the good you can do!..use your power to help...please!..how much more suffering do you need to see before you act?
- m stokoe, 7:48 PM on Sun 11 Apr 2010
It is cruel and horrible. These animals may be farmed, but they have a right to live in humane conditions. This is a terrible thing that is happening here. Isn't New Zealand supposed to have a Clean & Green image? Well, this isn't clean, and I doubt the pigs have ever seen green grass. The pigs live a life of pain and horror and this is simply animal cruelty. It has to stop.
- Helena Lily Finlayson, 7:28 PM on Sun 11 Apr 2010
Please do this for the pigs. It is time to end the suffering once and for all
- Shelley Quarterman, 7:21 PM on Sun 11 Apr 2010
it is truely sickening to see pigs treated like this in a country with more than enough land for free range pig farming. I realise it may be uneconomical for the NZ pork industry to change its shameful ways, but I feel that NZ should make a more significant effort to raise the standard of animal welfare on pig farms, to both live up to its 'clean green' image but more importantly for the pigs themselves, who are actually very intelligient animals, being forced to live out a depraved life in complete misery.
- Sara Ransley, 7:05 PM on Sun 11 Apr 2010
It is cruel to make the pigs live in these conditions. I will not eat pork as long as they are farmed in this way.
- R Mitchell, 7:02 PM on Sun 11 Apr 2010
it is quite simply inhumane. New Zealand could lead the world in our treatment of animals - we could be revolutionaries in standard farming practice. I am convinced that not only is it the moral choice, but that healthy happy animals will produce better tasting, healthy, high quality meat - the sort of produce New Zealand prides itself on. Sincerely, Alison Walls
- Alison Walls, 6:59 PM on Sun 11 Apr 2010
It is cruel and unnecessary. The animals suffer for convenience and profit which is completely unethical. I'm sure that New Zealanders would like to see some sort of victory and change for animals this year. Especially after the horrific cases of animal abuse that have been in the media recently.
- Jayne Hagen, 6:58 PM on Sun 11 Apr 2010
I am opposed to this mean and nasty way of humans 'controlling the lives of innocent beings' these animals need our support, any piece of this type of meat eaten will only make the person that its it ill as well, ridden with suffering, 'we are digging our graves and also using up the health dollar madly with our teeth'; this type of meat is not necessary for human survival Mr Key and that is the fundimental argument, to be locked up all your life, constantly pregnant unable to move and hosed down occasionally and baby after baby taken from you what life for a poor sow. Please stop this horrible practice now and make these farmers have to care and love their animals in order to make money from them. Please I hope you will listen, but perhaps the best way is to take the CEO of the port marketing board and some of his farmers and put them into a sow crate for a few days. Jackie Crawford Unit 1 A 56 Mozeley Ave Devonport Auckland
- Jackie Crawford, 6:48 PM on Sun 11 Apr 2010
Please, have some humanity.
- Laura Johnstone, 6:38 PM on Sun 11 Apr 2010
I feel that it is completely disrespectful to the environment. We need to respect each and every living thing as much as possible and it is unnecessary to subject these creatures to this kind of treatment. If you are going to eat meat, I would want that person to eat meat of an animal that was killed humanely and lived a life outside of a cage.
- Jason Post, 6:33 PM on Sun 11 Apr 2010
it is a disgusting way of farming. Do you eat free range meat? I do. I eat less meat and know it is ethically farmed. The cheap and cheerful crap we are presented in the supermarkets is a price we pay for intensively cruel faming practices. I am not happy with the Nat Govt on a lot of things they have done lately. Truly I really thought you might be good for the people. Don't give me another reason. Problem is all you pollies bow down to the farmers, not the consumers. I don't want a mass produced reply letter either unless you are saying that you will be banning this practice.
- Joanne Hin , 6:25 PM on Sun 11 Apr 2010
how can somthing this inhumane happen in new zealand it MUST be stopped! :(
- zoe, 6:11 PM on Sun 11 Apr 2010
I think there are better alternatives to cover the demand of pork for us all, maybe in educating to reduce the demand too. NZ with its green image should follow other countries example and ban this cruelty. It is time to change and produce happy pork meat because I believe one can taste the difference! Thanks very much for your support! Anja Meduna
- Anja Meduna, 6:10 PM on Sun 11 Apr 2010
pigs deserve to live in humane conditions. The idea that free-range pig farming presents any dangers to the animals is nonsense...just ask the people at freedom farms. A country like ours should promote and deliver free-range farming. You would be surprised by how many people will cast their vote for this government on the basis of the future pig animal welfare codes. Kind regards, Andy
- Andy Rigg, 6:04 PM on Sun 11 Apr 2010
pig deserve to live in humane conditions. The idea that free-range pig farming presents any dangers to the animals is nonsense...just ask the people at freedom farms. A country like ours should promote and deliver free-range farming. You would be surprised by how many people will cast their vote for this government on the basis of the future pig animal welfare codes. Kind regards, Andy
- Andy Rigg, 6:02 PM on Sun 11 Apr 2010
Perhaps we should challenge members of the pork board to spend a week in a crate suitably adapted for the adult human form. If nothing else, it'd give them time for quiet reflection on just how nice it is to, say, take a walk, use the bathroom, you know, all of those little things that make life ever so peachy. My challenge to you is a little less extreme - pass legislation which bans this patently cruel, inhumane, unnecessary 'farming'.
- Karl Warhurst, 5:55 PM on Sun 11 Apr 2010
it's inhumane, and should be banned.
- Gabby Watson, 5:18 PM on Sun 11 Apr 2010
It is inhumane to treat an animal in this way for any reason, let alone for profit. We are supposed to be an 'enlightened' country. However we are not 'enlightened' when we allow animals to be treated in such an appalling manner. The animal welfare act needs to be reviewed if it allows this practice of animal cruelty to continue.
- joan brown, 5:11 PM on Sun 11 Apr 2010
in a world that is becoming ever more internet savvy along with environmentally aware, New Zealand must act in a way that ensures we do not compromise our 'green image'that is so very critical to our tourism industry. However, what is more at the heart of the argument is the welfare of the animals involved in these types of farming. These animals are capable of enduring psychological stress as much as they can physical. Regardless of whether they are intelligent or not, this factor must be considered. And when considered only one option remains; to ban this method of farming.
- Ciaran Cullen, 4:40 PM on Sun 11 Apr 2010
it is unnecessary. As a leader of the country it is up to you to curb unsatisfactory behaviours. Outdated methods of farming need to be stamped out. It is not good for our "best practise" farming to have such cruelty. Surely another method can be found requiring not much more area. It is very sad to see other creatures condemned to such lives by humans who are supposed to be "more" intelligent I hope you can see the common and economic sense of bbanning such cruel methods.
- B Wright, 4:31 PM on Sun 11 Apr 2010
Every living being deserves respect, compassion and kindness. NOT received by pigs in these conditions
- J & B Sharples, 4:31 PM on Sun 11 Apr 2010
it is an unnecessary cruelty.
- Will Douglas, 4:27 PM on Sun 11 Apr 2010
it is unnecessary, and causes pain and suffering for the sake of cutting costs/prices by a few cents. Some things are more important than creating the cheapest possible priced goods.
- Nigel Wilson, 4:09 PM on Sun 11 Apr 2010
I do NOT agree with animals being farmed in a cruel manner, having no opportunity to express their natural behaviour. Pigs have an intelligence level equating to that of dogs - would we as a country endorse such close and long confinement in our pet or working dogs? It is nothing short of barbaric and all in the name of economics? I refuse to buy any pork product that is not from an SPCA approved source and hounded my supermarket until it provided such a product. This sad state of affairs MUST cease! You can help it happen.
- Michelle Holloway Mrs, 3:53 PM on Sun 11 Apr 2010
these poor animals have FEELINGS just like you and me. but what these farmers are doing to these poor pigs is cruel, and it should not be allowed. how can you sleep at night knowing that these poor pigs are settling down for another sleepless, cold unfriendly noght. how would you feel if you had to be locked up in a farrowing crate? Yours Sincerley Sian Chapman 14
- Sian Chapman, 3:26 PM on Sun 11 Apr 2010
of the cruelty that the farmed pigs experience. Just because we are used to the way things are done does not make it right. The quality of life that the farmed pigs are experiencing is not a reflection of a humane society - it needs to change. Please support this change.
- Jessica Clark, 3:24 PM on Sun 11 Apr 2010
in the case of pigs we are talking about an animal more intelligent than a dog. Think of the outcry of dogs were 'farmed' in a similar way. I also think you should pay attention to the similar backlash of public opinion about the attempt to 'factory farm' dairy cows in the Mckenzie country. Just because it isn't new practice for pig farming doesn't mean it isn't similarly ugly!
- José Entrican, 2:21 PM on Sun 11 Apr 2010
I currently work on a pig farm and it is very cruel to keep these good animals I stalls..in sow stalls. I do not mind to much about the farrowing crates if the sows were exercised daily for at least half an hour. Tending to the new born piglets is far safer when the sow cannot break your legs.
- john holmes, 1:57 PM on Sun 11 Apr 2010
Its cruel and inhumane. This should not be allowed in a country that prides itself on its green and clean image or any country. Were supposed to be a kind country so how can this be allowed? Animals should be treated with care and respect just like people should. This has to be banned, its cruel and disgraceful and its shaming to live in a country which allows this.
- Gretel Thompson, 1:49 PM on Sun 11 Apr 2010
i think it is really horrible that people do this i dont know how they can just stand there and watch these living animals suffer. i an against factory farming and i think the rest of new zealand should join this and make a big difference to this horrible condition. i think that factory farmers should be fined or prossicuted for doing this horrible thing to these animals. pigs should be alowd to live a normal life and be alowd to walk around free in a paddok and should be alowd to stay with their young in a free space where they can move around. so please john do the right thing and change the ways that these poor pig live and fined the people that are doing this horrible thing. PLEASE HELP MAKE A DIFFERENCE TO THE LIVES OF PIGS. SPREAD THE WORD.
- AISON YORKSTONE , 1:20 PM on Sun 11 Apr 2010
put simply it should not be a part of the future vision of new zealand. In many industries we have proved our ability to sit at the forefront of industries and the pork industry should not be the exception to this with their backward thinking and lack of vision.
- Briar Wakelin, 1:10 PM on Sun 11 Apr 2010
they are cruel and unnecessary. What kind of country are we to stand by and let things like this happen?
- Natalya Solimow, 12:48 PM on Sun 11 Apr 2010
it is not humane and I do not see how anyone with any degree of caring about life could possibly justify this kind of treatment. I will not touch any pork product (wherever it comes from} until this barbaric practice ceases - everyone I have spoken to has expressed similar sentiments. Thank you for caring enough to take steps to end this situation. PLEASE, treat this with urgency.
- J. White, 12:07 PM on Sun 11 Apr 2010
I appose all cruelty to animals in any shape and form and as a result do not eat meat, however for those that do, surely the habitation and slaughter of these animals should have some dignity to it. Just because animals and in this case factory farmed pigs have no choice to endure this barbaric suffering, they feel pain and extreme discomfort as much as we do. we appose human concentration camps, this should also apply to animals!
- Jo Chester, 11:55 AM on Sun 11 Apr 2010
there is no justification for inflicting suffering on farm animals for their miserable short lives that they already give up for human consumption. The very least that they are owed by us is a happy, natural, stress-free life before they end up on the dinner plate. Whilst New Zealand's welfare code is better than many countries, it still falls far short of the mark for pig and chicken farming and the fact that it's legal makes it all the worse!
- Paul Barnes, 11:51 AM on Sun 11 Apr 2010
Crate Farming is against humane way .It was appallng and extrememy sad to see how Pigs are being treated.We have faith in you that by taking a stand against factory farmed pigs you will make a difference for .I am seriously concerned for the animals and how we are allowing this to happen.Please do something about it.Please stop it now.
- Moana, 11:36 AM on Sun 11 Apr 2010
Every living creature deserves the right to be free of torture. Regardless of our desire to farm animals for their use to us as food or clothing they are still living breathing animals like us and they deserve the right to live a natural humane life. If we have chosen to farm animals then we must also choose consciously, as human beings, to treat them with compassion. We are humane enough to know that slavery and torture are barbaric beyond culture, beyond tradition and beyond desire. Although it is a new step for us as humans, legislating safe, sanitary and soul full living conditions for animals is a necessary step to ensure all animals are free from our barbarism. Surely respect and reverence for creatures that we use for our own means makes more sense than believing we have a divine right to treat other creatures any way we wish because of our humanness. It is because we are human that we should - you should - legislate to treat all creatures in a humane way. Please - oppose factory farming, take a stand against torture and lead our country and the rest of the world into a new age where humanity is something to be proud of!
- reb fountain, 11:09 AM on Sun 11 Apr 2010
I am a veterinary nurse, and I honest to god hate seeing ANY animal having to put up with cruelty, for ANY reason! nothing apsolutely NO reason to hurt or treat animals in this manner. It is immoral and against life. they are here to be enjoyed, not to be a toy that entertains humans that decide that they need or want to hurt something! and this goes for any animal. I feel very strongly about animal cruelty. And I wish that in the future that because you are the one who has the power to change these laws, you need to make it stronger and more harsher consequences for those who have obviously anger problems, and no sense between wrong and right... think John if it was the other way around and animals were humans and they were doing that to us... how would you feel..? what would you do in defence? and then you end up getting put down for it!? how is that fair?! Thank you for your time. Mandy.
- Mandy Lehrke, 11:06 AM on Sun 11 Apr 2010
one day will will wake up and realise what we have allowed to happen and current practices of pig farming are clearly wrong and profit driven. You were elected to be our voice so please do something
- Angela Bayc, 11:03 AM on Sun 11 Apr 2010
This so unfair to animals they have no one to talk for them and it this was a human living like that people would have somethinh to say about it. Animals are a part of our lifes to me this is not fair as i have had pets all my life and feel very strongly aboout this. Something needs to be done about it.
- Melissa Nuttall-Ross, 10:55 AM on Sun 11 Apr 2010
Its horrible what they are doing in the cages, I wouldn't keep my family pet, in these conditions! Since the very first Mike King program, I have become semi-vegatarian, It made me feel sick to the stomach that we as humans , not only condone this practice, But we EAT them aswell, :( Please Please, Help ?! Peace love and Compassion Jennifer Shalfoon
- jennifer shalfoon, 10:49 AM on Sun 11 Apr 2010
Dear John It is cruel and inhumane to allow animals to be treated in this manner. New Zealand cannot continue to maintain a clean and green image while the treatment of "factory farmed" animals continues. A similar situation relating to domestic cats and dogs would never be accepted by the New Zealand SPCA, or the New Zealand general public. This matter needs to be addressed with urgency, for the sake of the animals lives at stake and our country's good name.
- Marie Brunel, 10:29 AM on Sun 11 Apr 2010
It is completely wrong and immoral. Unimaginable that any animal should have to live like that. Please change the laws, do the right thing.
- Marisa Lupis, 9:47 AM on Sun 11 Apr 2010
it is a hideous treatment of an intelligent animal, how do you think your cat would cope in such a place?
- Jane Emily Dickson, 9:20 AM on Sun 11 Apr 2010
Anybody who treat animals in this way, will justify treating humans the same way!!
- caryl watterson, 8:18 AM on Sun 11 Apr 2010
as any human being who pays any attention to their conscience knows, it is cruel, inhumane and completely unnecessary to torture these defenceless creatures. There is no excuse for this type of activity. New Zealand does not yet have a reputation for being weak, spineless and cowardly when it comes to issues of morality and cruelty - the majority of New Zealanders want it to stay that way. What kind of stand will we be taking if we can't even require our own farmers to treat the animals they are legally obligated to care for in a humane way?
- Riki Andrew, 1:34 AM on Sun 11 Apr 2010
it is an appalling practice that simply cannot be justified in any way. It is unacceptable for any creature to be treated in this manner. Our actions define us, as do our inactions. I hope you will not remain inactive on this matter, allowing those that are active in this atrocity to continue. Please "step outside your box" Mr Key, because this DOES matter.
- Dale Donoghue, 11:32 PM on Sat 10 Apr 2010
it is inhumane. Pigs suffer, like most living creatures when they are unable to move freely. Their joints and muscles, internal organs cannot function without movement. The use of chemicals also increases to reduces diseases when animals live in confined quarters. Warm blooded mammals also need exposure to sunlight and clean air. The factory farming of pigs is unethical, that is the bottom line. New Zealand can promote farming that is ethically sound and complies with animal welfare legislation.
- claire Coveney, 11:23 PM on Sat 10 Apr 2010
Its cruel and horrible and I often wonder how pig farmers can sleep so comfortably at night it makes me sick to the stomach.
- Edwina Mahe, 11:13 PM on Sat 10 Apr 2010
it is inhumane and immoral. New Zealand has enough land to spare to give these animals the life they deserve. If it became law New Zealand could start a world trend. You have the power to change this.Please..
- Tiffany Alderman, 10:45 PM on Sat 10 Apr 2010
1. They encourage the commodification of life. 2. They foster the development of a culture low in empathy 3. They encourage low prices for meat and this increases meat consumption which increases the risks of cardiovascular disease at the population level 4. Higher rates of cardiovascular disease leads to increased population suffering and higher healthcare costs 5. They are environmentally risky 6. They contravene NZs clear green image and harm our international brand 7. Factory farmed animals suffer and it is right to avoid knowingly causing suffering John, there is a swell of popular opinion against factory farming and this is your voting public speaking. I will not continue to vote for you or your party unless you oppose factory farming (you are doing well so far BTW - keep up the good work!)
- james Webb, 10:24 PM on Sat 10 Apr 2010
Why is it that it is ok to treat animals with no respect and no apparent regard for their wellbeing? I would warrant a guess that the excuse would involve money. However this is simply not ok. What kind of lesson does this teach us? That it is ok to treat animals cruelly to gain money? That it is ok for suffering to occur if it is in the name of business? Shame on us for letting this lesson be taught. Why not allow dog-fighting? What about bear farms? Allowing Pigs to live in crates is ridiculous. Don't let this go on any longer.
- Sophie Bicknell, 10:13 PM on Sat 10 Apr 2010
New Zealand enjoys an overseas reputation of being "clean and green", surprisingly despite repeated exposures of cruel treatment of factory farmed animals. This disparity cannot carry on forever and we must clean up our treatment of animals in order to maintain our reputation. The animals deserve it.
- Greg Hewgill, 9:32 PM on Sat 10 Apr 2010
this is a cruel and totally unnecessary practice. There is NO excuse for cruelty. NO excuse. So why are we still allowing this? I absolutely refuse to buy any factory farmed produce and struggle to understand why anyone would endorse such practice. If you continue to turn a blind eye to this, you are as guilty as the person inflicting the stress and pain to these delightful animals. NO excuse. Please ban this practice now.
- Val Tester, 9:22 PM on Sat 10 Apr 2010
I respect these animals and wish them to have the same quality of life as other NZers. If NZers are going to eat them shouldn't the pigs at least have a nice ilfe first? Respectfully, -Amy Hewgill
- Amy Hewgill, 9:21 PM on Sat 10 Apr 2010
it is completely unnecessary. Cruelty is wrong and it needs to end. Please do the right thing.
- Chris Scott, 8:57 PM on Sat 10 Apr 2010
animals deserve to be treated with kindness and respect. I refuse to buy any pork that is factory farmed and I know many people who feel the same. Please ban sow and farrowing crates. Yours respectfully, Julia Saunders
- Julia Saunders, 8:32 PM on Sat 10 Apr 2010
it is both bad for the health and well-being of the animal and person who consumes the animal. It doesn't take a PHD to gather than if you eat an animal that has produced stress related chemicals and been given anti-biotics etc etc. one is effectively consuming these also. Over time dis-ease sets into the body. I also believe there is a karmic responsibility. However, suspect this might be a stage too far for an official to follow. With hope karen
- karen, 8:07 PM on Sat 10 Apr 2010
how can we allow such suffering to go on in such a beautiful country like new zealand. where is our intellegene? obviously lacking! :( lisa -avonndale
- lisa, 8:05 PM on Sat 10 Apr 2010
Pigs are intelligent. There are free-range pork products more commonly available now. We also live in a time where this in-humane practice is just unacceptable. To treat animals this cruelly is not right.
- Rachel Pearson, 7:47 PM on Sat 10 Apr 2010
the pointless suffering caused by this practice undermines the foundations of civilised society. To ignore this is unconscionable. As your fellow countryman I ask that you help our nation take this long overdue step toward compassion, and make a decision that everybody can live with.
- Michael Pritchard, 7:46 PM on Sat 10 Apr 2010
it is not humane. A dog would never be allowed to be kept in these conditions in New Zealand. We are far to educated to believe that the pigs are not suffering.
- Lisa Swanson, 7:32 PM on Sat 10 Apr 2010
It is time for the New zealand government to stand up and say no to curelty, I was a Dairy farmer for years and seen some horrible thing's but never have we ever treated our animals like these pig farmers have. You know for to long farmers have in general been a law unto themselves when it comes to the welfare of the animals, they so called looked after, it's time to make them acountable for it. Maf is useless to act in defence of these animals so it is up to us to do the right thing. The news coverage on close up was an eye opener for me and i couldn't stand by any longer and alow this to happen in my country i love, right back to the five generations, i am sickened by this and beg you to stop this please..
- Jennifer Lehrke, 7:02 PM on Sat 10 Apr 2010
Shame on NZ if you do not support this change!
- Stana M, 6:53 PM on Sat 10 Apr 2010
I have seen the baby pigs being born on top of rotting half eaten carcasses, it was revolting this is what happens in these horrid places. I dont know about you but i wouldn't treat my dog or a puppy like that, would you? Please get on board with this, because if you dont then your just as disgusting as the farmers who do this!
- Jeff lehrke, 6:46 PM on Sat 10 Apr 2010
if it will be an offence in 2017 then it should be an offence now. to give farmers license to to ill treat animals in this way is criminal and the people responsible for this course of action should reflect on the on what their true motivations are. at the same time as banning these practices they should also ban the import of pork that does not meet the standard of animal welfare in this country that way the local farmers would not be disadvantaged. Whilst I appreciate there will be short term implications on the economics of pig farming the long term benefits of the portrayal of the New Zealand clean green image abroad will make the pork products exported from here a premium product like the dairy industry Thank you for taking the time to read my e mail.
- Andrew Hope, 6:46 PM on Sat 10 Apr 2010
it is cruel and totally unnecessary. The European Union has already committed to ban sow and farrowing crates and New Zealand should follow this excellent example to keep up with the global drive towards animal welfare!
- Tanja Ottmann, 6:10 PM on Sat 10 Apr 2010
New Zealand wishes to uphold the highest international standards of their agricultural goods. New Zealand relies heavily on its image of free-feed animals and humane animal husbandry - this is why NZ meat - though not necessarily organic - can be found in exclusive whole food chain stores throughout America and Natural food stores and restaurants throughout Europe. Don't threaten this status by allowing terrible animal husbandry practices within NZ. Yours sincerely, Robyn.
- Robyn Schofield, 5:49 PM on Sat 10 Apr 2010
Dear John Key As a Christian, the Bible tells me to look after the animals. As a decent person, my conscience tells me to look after the animals. Surely there is an obligation to protect pigs, raised in pens from birth until death without normal movement, from what seems to me to be cruelty. If it is not considered a crime to treat these pigs so, if these pig farmers cannot in law be prevented from treating pigs in this way, like the egg industry I would like it to be legally required to state how pigs have been farmed on the relevant pork packet so that I can have my say with my purse. Many thanks. Rosemary Purchas
- Rosie Purchas, 5:23 PM on Sat 10 Apr 2010
It,s so unfair to the pigs, an awful business thats got to change surely farming pigs naturally and freely is much more pleasant both for the farmer and certainly for the pigs. PLEASE change it,s so sad look at the pigs expression doesn't that tell you something, We are a civilized people PLEASE free the pigs
- M. Roberts, 4:54 PM on Sat 10 Apr 2010
it places inhumane stress on an animal which is known to have high intelligence by preventing it from being able to freely move around and undertake it's natural and instinctive daily routines. This inhumane treatment of animals for profit is not something I wish to have my great country associated with. As a proud New Zealander Mr. Key, I ask that you take this opportunity to add Animal Humanity to our growing list of accomplishments.
- Peter Aden, 4:46 PM on Sat 10 Apr 2010
there is no need for it in this modern day and age. Alternative, more humane methods are now available. The excuse that factory pig farmers use, of saying that it is unaffordable to end factory farming is false. Factory farming is based on a false economy where the welfare of the pigs is given no value. This is morally wrong. There is no good reason why pigs should suffer so that we can save a few dollars on pork products and factory pig farmers can make a few more dollars. John Key, if you are not in support of an immediate ban on sow and farrowing crates then I believe you should be prepared to spend as much time in these cruel devices as factory farmed pigs in this country currently do.
- Jared Oliver, 4:01 PM on Sat 10 Apr 2010
it's cruel, inhumane and new zealand can do far better than allowing this substandard terrible treatment of animals. lets lead by example and show the world new zealand is a place where good things happen !!
- georgina Neumann, 3:41 PM on Sat 10 Apr 2010
IT'S INHUMANE! ALL CREATURES HAVE RIGHTS! Would you like to live in a box that you can't lie down in or turn around in??!! IT"S A PRISON CELL. Even prisoners have more room than these poor animals. Pigs can be farmed in grassy fields. They are interesting, intelligent, creatures. They would go INSANE in a stall. As a child i mucked out the pig pen. Our pig loved her newly strawed house which was a 3x2mtr night shelter. She was affectionate and curious and followed us around in the paddocks. BUY FREE RANGE, IT"S WELL WORTH THE EFFORT. It's more expensive, but at least the animals have had a real existance. Thank you for your attention. Seriously concerned, Christine Guy
- Christine Guy, 3:39 PM on Sat 10 Apr 2010
all animals have feeling are loving creatures and breath just like the rest of us,, would u like to live in these conditions and see your children grow this way? make a difference!!
- Bronagh, 3:38 PM on Sat 10 Apr 2010
pigs should be given the same rights as other animals. It is proven that pigs are very intelligent animals. Why should they be treated with less rights than other animals. As a farming nation we should have proper standards in place and only accept pig products that have come from countries with recognised acceptable standards. New Zealanders will not stand for continual animal cruelty, pigs that can only lay down or stand up is absolutely with no question animal cruelty. Raising the standards of acceptable living conditions will ensure that pig farming becomes more ethical and will undoubtedly secure pig farming economically. New Zealanders will boycott this industry if a huge improvement is not made. I trust that you and the National Government will find an acceptable resolution to this inhumane problem. yours faithfully Tracey Bell
- Tracey Bell, 3:29 PM on Sat 10 Apr 2010
there is no need to create misery in the lives of our food animals. It is equally bad for them and for us. As human beings we have turned our food animals into commodities, bad enough, but there is no excuse for out and out cruelty. Please do all you can to stop this practice. It is a dreadful reflection of our society, there is a fine line between how we tolerate cruelty to animals and how we tolerate it to each other. Thank you.
- Sue Sweetman, 3:26 PM on Sat 10 Apr 2010
It is totally unacceptable to allow this cruelty to continue, every animal has the right to live it's life....to smell the fresh air, roam outside in the sunshine, feel the grass under its feet, eat good real food, be shown love, compassion and kindness. To deny any animal these basic elements of life is arrogant and disgusting, and it makes me ashamed to be a member of the human race when people among us decide it is right to do this! There is absolutely NOTHING right about treating another living creature in this way - all factory farming and animal testing should be immediately banned!
- Denise Snoad, 3:25 PM on Sat 10 Apr 2010
it is disgusting, cruel and inhumane. You wouldn't treat a dog or cat like this... so why treat a pig in this way? I find it very hard to believe the NZ government has not done anything about this already. At the end of the day, the pigs are being treated in this way so people can eat cheap meat. Disgraceful. I hope I don't see more images like the ones displayed at the moment this time next year. Please do the right thing by these animals.
- Rebecca Joseph, 3:14 PM on Sat 10 Apr 2010
It confines and tortures sentient creatures. All animals have personalities and show love and feel pain. Pigs are extremely intelligent and have the mental capacity of a three year old child. They are very loyal and loving and make wonderful pets. I will never forget when I saw a mother pig who just gave birth retrieve blossoms and place them around her babies. She was so very proud. Factory farming is one of the atrocities of our society. It is heartbreaking!
- Grace, 2:29 PM on Sat 10 Apr 2010
the pigs are not given the opportunity to live their life to their fullest and express themselves like other animals who are able to run freely, enjoy the fresh air, sun light and the feeling of expressing themselves in the soil/dirt and mud like other happy pigs in the world. Crate pigs are kept in crates like chickens are confined to their cages, it is unhumaine and cruel. Would anyone want this cruelty placed on themsleves, I don't think so. These poor pigs are confined to these crates like villians, just like imprisonment. Why do they have to endure a suffering life for the pleasure of humans to enjoy pork. Pigs should have the same rights as any other animal - e.g. dogs, cats and other farm animals. It is crual to imprison these animals for their whole lives, and denying them the right to enjoy the little things in life, like sunshine, freedom, happyness and affection and the enjoymnet of the outdoors. I have also found out that piglet death is the same rate if the sow is locked in crates or in outdoor situations, this is no excuse to lock these poor animals indoors so that humans/consumers do not see what they experience for the reast of their lives, in these poor conditions, surrounded by howling pigs who are suffering from blistered feet and so small confinments that piglets are squashed and die, and eaten by other pigs and with swarming flies which hover over. This is disgusting! Do us New Zealander's want this to happen behind our backs and approve of this disgusting cruelty to animals. No! We will not stand here and allow this to happen, we will no longer cover our eyes to this cruelty. Please stop this disgusting crime, we do not want this to continue. Do the right thing, and imagine how it must feel to be confined to such a small area, cold, depressed and such a small confined area you are squashed to death, with flies and never knowing that there is a better life outside those crates in the sunshine and outdoors with freedom to walk and live a more healthy and well life, and probably a longer life. Do the right thing, and abolish pig crates by law. Pig cruelty should not be aloud, go the 'free range' way and all New Zealander's will have pride and not feel disgusted to enjoy NZ Pork. Do the right thing!
- Kataraina Stephens, 2:23 PM on Sat 10 Apr 2010
As humans we have a moral obligation to treat all fellow creatures with respect. As an Agricultural based economy it is unacceptable, shameful,illegal and immoral to allow these present Pig farming practises to continue. Please do the right thing and bring about change sooner rather than later for the good of ALL concerned. Thank You.
- Rodger Short, 2:18 PM on Sat 10 Apr 2010
pigs are intelligent sociable creatures.Like all domesticated animals, they deserve to be treated humanely and in conditions that ensure they are both comfortable and able to behave as nature intended.There are no animals that choose to sleep and eat in the same place they void their own waste.The conditions they are currently kept in are inhumane in the extreme. The fact that the Pork industry denies that this is the case suggests to me that there needs to be an independent body set up to monitor the welfare of factory farmed pigs.
- b gelling, 2:15 PM on Sat 10 Apr 2010
we are a forward-thinking country with a great history of taking the lead worldwide. Why not do the same with animal welfare standards? It is a fantastic opportunity to show the world that we value the animals that underpin our main industries.
- Amanda Thomas, 2:10 PM on Sat 10 Apr 2010
I believe that humans are on this earth specifically to take care of the planet, and all it's numerous variations of life. How would you feel if you were brought up stuck in a tiny crate, not allowed to move or enjoy any of the freedoms all animals should have. It is our responsibility to speak up for those that cannot speak for themselves.
- Chevy Hill, 2:04 PM on Sat 10 Apr 2010
For the sake of a few dollars and someone being able to put a swimming pool in their backyard, this is unacceptable. This is such a huge statement in morality, some countries might do worse than us here, some countries might look the other way when these things happen, but in NZ this should never be the case EVER!
- Bryce Morgan, 1:46 PM on Sat 10 Apr 2010
it is cruel to treat animals in anyway in which we ourself would not like to be treated. You cannot justify the way these animals are treated so why condone it by allowing it to continue. Please help to change to law so that pigs can live a naturally free life to which everything on this earth deserves. I am pained to see these animals suffer the way they do.
- zoe moynahan, 1:42 PM on Sat 10 Apr 2010
I think the tratment towards our animals is cruel and barbarick
- caseycardonsmith, 1:28 PM on Sat 10 Apr 2010
we have no right to treat any animal, let alone animals as intelligent as pigs, in inhumane and cruel ways. All in the pursuit of saving a few dollars. You are a disgrace to allow this country to condone and continue such treatment.
- Ann Sullivan, 12:56 PM on Sat 10 Apr 2010
It is very important that New Zealand sets a standard against animal cruelty. If countries such as New Zealand and Australia begin to take these issues seriously, then citizens of other countries will put pressure on their governments to follow suit. New Zealand is lucky. We do not have widespread factory farming, such as in America. Help us to set a standard for others to follow, a standard which we are more than capable of meeting. This is our chance to be part of an important change; the abolition of factory farming. New Zealanders want to lead the charge.
- Stephanie Radley, 12:52 PM on Sat 10 Apr 2010
it is completely inhumane, morally indefensible, and - of course - totally unnecessary. Mr Key when you said a year ago that you found the footage "very very disturbing", that was more than any leader of the country has ever said in regards to systematic animal abuse in New Zealand, and I took it as a sign that you and your government had a conscience and weren't afraid to exercise it in the Beehive. You also said that if it were typical of a NZ pig farm, changes would have to be made. Last night's program proves that, a year later, it is still typical of pig farming in NZ, and it is indeed time for you, as PM, to change it. I hope you will listen to your own conscience and the majority of New Zealanders who want to see an immediate ban on sow and farrowing crates.
- Jesse Duffield, 12:50 PM on Sat 10 Apr 2010
it is putting a price on cruelty, the opposition is coming from people wanting to protect their wallets. We need to set the standard for the world, and say that profits should not be made at the cost of unnecessary suffering of any animals, let alone against an animal with proven intelligence and emotions such as a pig. We all only get one life in this world and we all should do our best to make it good for every person and animal, you Mr John Key, are in a position where your actions can do alot. Thank you for taking the time to read this and I hope engage empathetically with this matter when making a decision.
- Mason Ozich, 12:37 PM on Sat 10 Apr 2010
I believe it is unnecessary and cruel. It is a scientific fact that pigs are one of the most intelligent animals on this planet akin to the intelligence of a 3 year old human child. You wouldn't place a child in confinement no larger than their own body size for months on end year after year. Just because pigs cannot speak a human language does not mean they don't experience depression, fear and anxiety. Please stand up for real animal welfare not what is convenient for making farmers the most amount of money.
- Melanie Berghuis, 12:29 PM on Sat 10 Apr 2010
pigs are intelligent animals and can make wonderful pets, it is unacceptable to treat a cat or a dog this poorly, so why treat these animals of the same intelligence and trust as any other pet like this? It sickens me the thought that people would rather save a few dollars than make these animals stop suffering. How selfish can people be. They would rather distance themselves from it all, but if you think about this happening to your beloved pets, or even your family, I'm sure that you can see that it is not right and no creature deserves to be treated that way.
- Sarah Ure, 12:27 PM on Sat 10 Apr 2010
I believe in our country that we are caring New Zealanders. I want our country to be clean and green, to have a conscience and take a stance on animal cruelty. I don't want to be part of any another country that doesn't care about the people, the pollution, the callousness. As our prime minister I have total faith in you that you will take care of and help those that cannot help themselves, animals, children and the elderly of New Zealand.
- Annie Harrington, 12:19 PM on Sat 10 Apr 2010
it is discustingly cruel these people need a bullet!!!!!!!!!
- katina skepetaris, 12:10 PM on Sat 10 Apr 2010
The way pigs are currently farmed in New Zealand is a national disgrace. It is time we caught up with the rest of the civilised world and showed that we do understand that animals should be treated in a completely humane way.
- Joan Farnborough, 12:08 PM on Sat 10 Apr 2010
anyone with any decency or conscience could not possibly condone it or think that it is actually ok, because it is not. Would it be acceptable if it happened to kittens, kakapo or police dogs? Would it be acceptable if it was you in a sow crate 24 hours a day? No? Why then is it allowed to happen to pigs? There are New Zealanders who deal with it in a quite cowardly way by looking the other way or trying to pretend that it isn't happening, but it is happening RIGHT NOW, and hiding it away and pretending we are not to blame does not make it go away. National is about the crack down on crime, and this is a crime. Crime is not limited to stabbings or robbing grannies. We are asking you to support the ban on sow and farrowing crates. They break animal cruelty LAWS. Please tap into your conscience Prime Minister?
- TM Wano, 12:08 PM on Sat 10 Apr 2010
Enough is enough. It is time that we left barbaric ways and become civilised. If we exepect respect for ourselves then we need to show respect to all living creatures. Respect is not a one-way street and nor has it ever been. We have the power to determine how we wish to be remembered... Is this extensive cruelty that we force on other living beings in the name of the $ really what being human is about? What is humanity and why dont we care?
- christine aldridge, 12:00 PM on Sat 10 Apr 2010
we have the ability to take care with our actions, to take the responsibilities of meat-eating seriously. These animals are in our collective care; we breed them for food and should remember the responsibility for their quality of life that this puts upon us. Yours sincerely Tamara Rendell (Tauranga)
- Tamara Rendell, 11:57 AM on Sat 10 Apr 2010
As a person who has firsthand seen the most un natural confinement and suffering of pigs( as a young child living on a battery pig farm run by my mothers partner ) I urge the Government to hear the voice of the people who do not want this kind of inhumane treatment towards other sentient beings.
- Miriam Rand, 11:53 AM on Sat 10 Apr 2010
of the cruelty involved, no animal should have to live their life in such a way....Its not ok for dogs, cats, people so why is it ok for pigs? Its not! I will no longer buy any pork product unethically farmed! All to line your stomachs and pockets...I thought a country such as New Zealand would have more integrity than to let this sort of treatment happen to any living thing!?
- Angela Shatford, 11:48 AM on Sat 10 Apr 2010
it is totally unnecessary. In a country where we are so rich in land space, the outdoor rearing of all anials is a viable, sustainable and healthier alternative to factory farming.
- nick raynor, 11:47 AM on Sat 10 Apr 2010
please stop this unnecessary cruelty to pigs. This farming practice is archaic and barbaric and nothing on earth deserves to be subjected to this. Please Please Please John stop this.
- sarah riley, 11:19 AM on Sat 10 Apr 2010
it's cruel and unnecessary. We can treat pigs right and still have a good meal!
- Dayna Wall, 11:15 AM on Sat 10 Apr 2010
EARN PEOPLES RESPECT AND SHOW SOME GUTS, INSTEAD OF COWTAILING TO EVERYONE WITH MONEY.
- P DAWSON, 11:13 AM on Sat 10 Apr 2010
Pigs are intelligent animals, where do we get the authority to pen them up? Why not have a paddock, it costs less money ie. don't have to build sheds etc. Why should NZ be like the rest of the world and display the same ignorance. Every Life is valuable, you'd think that if they are an important part of fueling our economy and our bodies we would treat them with a little more respect. I can't understand why they need to be couped up.. Its lazy and cruel and you are wrong to turn away from it.
- Sophie Cartmer, 11:00 AM on Sat 10 Apr 2010
We have the power to make a difference in the quality of animals' lives.
- avila allsop, 10:47 AM on Sat 10 Apr 2010
Dear Mr Key, as the world is becoming more aware of food and where it comes from, and the conditions animals are having to suffer before they go to slaughter... is just down right cruelty people now are making a choice not to eat food where the animal is treated this way! I fully support the ban of sow and farrowing crates and hope that new zealnd will be a country where this type of animal cruelty is banned in all areas of factory farming.
- joanne billesdon, 10:46 AM on Sat 10 Apr 2010
I no longer want to buy pork products that are not farmed ethically and increasingly find this is the same with my friends. If more and more people realise how unethical the conditions that pigs are kept in are then this will have to stop anyway. Why not do something about it first!
- chris rickards, 10:44 AM on Sat 10 Apr 2010
Its disgusting and cruel. Put yourself in their shoes, how would you like to be kept in a tiny pen with dead bodies surrounding you, the smell of yours and others filth filling the air and never seeing the light of day. This brings tears to my eyes. please stop
- Safiyah Solliman, 10:38 AM on Sat 10 Apr 2010
animals deserve to be treated in a humane manner. I really believe that we have a chance to make NZ known nation wide as a proactive country with regards to animal welfare that other countries will look to. Thank you.
- fiona rickards, 10:37 AM on Sat 10 Apr 2010
my daughter is so depressed with what she is seing on tv about the pigs, that she is very depressed and refused to eat anything as she thinks anything has meat and pigs in it. she has not been out or to see her friends for a long time now, as she cant live in a world where this happens to animals. a few weeks ago we found her with her wrists cut but thankfully we found her in time. please let new zealand not do this to animals, let them help them and be of the good counties in the world......please stop for my daughters sake and the poor pigs sake, pigs are smarter then dogs, would you do this to your dog???? its crazy ...what all of us have to go through that love animals and are oversensitive like my daughter.
- belinda, 10:34 AM on Sat 10 Apr 2010
I think about where my food has come from? Do you? Would you keep your child in such conditions?
- Julie Kitchen, 10:33 AM on Sat 10 Apr 2010
no living creature should be treated with cruelty!
- j denton, 10:33 AM on Sat 10 Apr 2010
Because they are horrifically cruel. No animal should be kept in these conditions and it seems inhumane that we as human beings continue to treat animals with such lack of care and or compassion. It is unneeded to keep our pigs in these conditions so why are we putting them through this torture?
- Rani Judd, 10:30 AM on Sat 10 Apr 2010
this really should be stopped if you have any heart at all. its insane that in this modern day this happens to animals. we are not barbarians anymore are we??? we live in modern times but it seems man have gone back to being worse then in the middle ages.....when animals had space to roam free, now they are so many greedy people on this planet.....that all animals have to suffer for them......how you can live in a planet that is this corrupted it makes me sick
- andrea, 10:29 AM on Sat 10 Apr 2010
It is unnecessary and disgusting. I like to eat pork but not at this cost. I think more people will stop buying factory farmed pigs (lots of my friends won't already) so there's another company out of business...support these farmers to get it right ethically and the whole country will benefit.
- Deborah Joy, 10:29 AM on Sat 10 Apr 2010
If similar cruelties were meted out to dogs or cats, those responsible would be fined, banned from keeping animals or imprisoned. Why should we condone similar cruelties to other sentient beings? I realise that in a globalised world economy possibly pig farmers here either export their pork products or would like to do so. Under WITO New Zealand cannot refuse to allow imports of pork products from other countries (=Canada, USA, Asia). So the arguement from the pork producers here would be that they have to produce pork as cheaply as possible in order to compete with these other countries..I submit that to meter out cruelty to deal with this problem is not the answer of a civilised country. Instead, all pork products should bear the country of origin label and pork produced here humanely should be strongly advertised as such...and/or an import duty could go on the imported products. If importing countries should then complain to WTTO, then this would be an excellent area in which New Zealand could make a stand and all could openly discuss the awful effects on animal welfare that globalisation is doing. With kind regards, Ann Bell
- Ann Bell, 10:25 AM on Sat 10 Apr 2010
its not just cruel it makes people lower then any animal on this planet....no animal would ever do this to another animal or a human being. it makes me a shame to be human, and makes me not trust any humans on this planet, because of they are capable of doing something like this to loving and living creatures, then there really no hope for this planet and the human race. people that eat meat are all responsible for this as well, they dont see whats going on when they buy meat in the supermarket when its all nicely presented to them. if they where actually going to these farms to see whats going on and pick and kill the poor animal with their own eyes, they might consider NOT purchasing meat. The word MEAT does not seem to make people realise it comes from animals, sweet animals that suffer their whole lives so they can have a bit of meat on their plate. its shameless. people are selfish and stuppid to care, and the nice ones out there the ones that help animals and care for them are being overpowered by all the stuppid ones that only care for their own useless lives. did you know that by helping animals and not eating meat you can actually save this planet??? the pollution that is killing this planet is mainly caused by to many animals being farmed for your selfish needs....think about this..... you might end up in hell one day where they pigs eat you, that would be great, if you believe in karma this will happen hopefully.............save the pigs save the chickens and all suffering animals, stop eating meat.
- escha, 10:22 AM on Sat 10 Apr 2010
its cruel that the pigs are confined to such awful conditions, the pigs are very intelligent animals and should not be kept in such a way. You have the power to change this inhumane way that they are treated.
- Karen Bareham, 10:10 AM on Sat 10 Apr 2010
it is less than 100 years ago that we were being told Black people had no feelings and were less than any one else. Are we now to believe the same message in relation to Pigs, one of the most intelligent animals in the world? I was taught to treat others as I wanted to be treated myself and this extends to all living creatures. I am not vegetarian,a member of the Green Party, in fact I voted for you. I object to cruelty on all levels and only when we stand up and have a zero tolerance will child abuse diminish and disappear. To practice a double standard is to court dysfunction, even on a national level.
- Anne Mills, 9:50 AM on Sat 10 Apr 2010
it is cruel and no living being should suffer such abuse. Have these farmers lost their hearts in a bid to make more money. WE must not not let factory farming continue. We must stand up for these intelligent and harmless animals and say no to these hideous crates. PLease make me proud of the vote I cast for you and take a stand against this now.
- Magen Govender, 9:37 AM on Sat 10 Apr 2010
I think it is disgusting how the pigs are kept, there is no need for such horrible conditions.
- hana, 9:36 AM on Sat 10 Apr 2010
its disgusting and cruel, these pigs have no freedom. how can anyone be happy putting something in their mouths that has been tortured. please do something about this, you have the power to change this, you hold the key to freedom. please help
- stacey judd, 9:35 AM on Sat 10 Apr 2010
Please John , Listen to us. You are a good man and I don't believe that you would want this to carry on.Cathy
- Cathy & Neil Warren, 9:32 AM on Sat 10 Apr 2010
it makes me sick that we live in a society that seems to think this behaviour is okay. ITS NOT!!!!! We are the only voices for these poor animals, so speak up, stop this cruelty and makes this country safe for ALLL!!!
- Nikki Taylor, 9:29 AM on Sat 10 Apr 2010
did you know that pigs have the intelligence of a two year old human child? Perhaps the people who run these pig farms should try lying in a coffin for a month to see how it feels. Do the right thing John. Sincerely.
- Tracy Pepper, 9:29 AM on Sat 10 Apr 2010
it is just simply cruel. How can we, a civilized society with a moral conscience accept such barbaric practices. I am constantly shocked and disgusted by animal abuse and this is one of the worst I have seen. Pigs are highly intelligent animals and to do what factory farming does to them is unforgivable. It is so sad that all some farmers seem to care about is their profit at the end of the day. I am always of the belief that means do not justify the end. Please, please, please put a stop to this horrible situation.
- Anushka Govender, 9:28 AM on Sat 10 Apr 2010
Pigs are intelligent feeling creatures and do not deserve to be treated in the disgusting way we are treating them in this so called clean green country.They say you can tell how evolved a society is, by the way it cares for its elderly, its children and its animals.By these standards we would be judged unevolved at least .Barbaric most likely.Please take a stand to change our reputation and most of all to restore our stewardship responsibilities to our most vulnerable. respectfully Joyce Kennedy
- joyce Kennedy, 9:24 AM on Sat 10 Apr 2010
it is a cruel and medieval way to treat such an intelligent and sensitive animal. It is unnecessary to have farrowing crates. Please stop the cruelty.
- Anya Whitlock, 9:20 AM on Sat 10 Apr 2010
I will not be purchasing any more pork until this discrasful and inhumane practise has been stopped. If prices have to rise so that these animals are treated humanely so be it.
- Doreen Mc Queen, 9:17 AM on Sat 10 Apr 2010
This treatment is completely baffling, and that it is legal, LEGAL, is even more shocking. So what to do? i say, cancel every sow crate, every indoor farming, because these animals are intelligent. Not to be wasted on a tiny crate, where they can only stand up and sit down. And even a pig specialist, says that these should be legal!!?? what about the pigs?, what about their feelings and pain?, it doesn't matter about money, a happy pig comes first. This is stupid, so so so so so stupid and i think if you put a whole bunch of fourteen year olds-like me!- into deciding if this is good treatment or not, you would come across a much more humane and kind pig farms. so i am giving a voice to the animals who can't speak, and why take advantage of them like that, why? thank you for your time.
- Ailis coleman, 9:15 AM on Sat 10 Apr 2010
it produces low quality food, takes jobs away from farm hands and is ethically dubious.
- Joseph Diamond, 9:12 AM on Sat 10 Apr 2010
A relative had a pig farm for years in Sth Island, NEVER EVER were his pigs kept in the disgusting condition as has been aired. Pigs are CLEAN, inteligent animals. I suspect the vet speaking in latest video is on farmers payroll as he is incorrect in a number of statements he made
- Shazza, 9:08 AM on Sat 10 Apr 2010
I don't think we should use cruel inhumane practices just to make a profit. it is not an argument that we need to compete with other countries who are using cruel farming methods . NZ should rise above this even if prices need to go up.
- karen main, 9:07 AM on Sat 10 Apr 2010
the treatment of the pigs is disgusting! i have not bought or eaten pork in a year since seeing the first program on sunday. to think the animals were treated so cruelly before their end is just horrible. at least cows and sheep live in paddocks breathing in fresh air, although some farmers want to change that too, the pigs deserve the same life. please change the rules on these terrible crates, i wouldnt treat my worst enemy that way!
- lisa williams, 9:07 AM on Sat 10 Apr 2010
in a civilised society, we have a responsibility to use our knowledge and awareness of the affects of intense sow crate farming on pig well being to improve their lives. Consumers are aware of the power of choice in purchasing pork from free range farms and will not tolerate the suffering of sow crate farming. This will impact on the NZ pork industry if not addressed.
- Jo Bain, 9:06 AM on Sat 10 Apr 2010
It is barbaric ,a poor reflection on the state of a nation and its people. All beings have the right to live as nature intended, to nurture their young and to live without fear and stress. Our sheep and cattle do. We removed all pig products and intensively farmed poultry off our shopping list a long time ago. The vet that was on Close Up last night should be sacked he is clearly off a different planet and brings shame to the Veterinary Profession. Imported pig products should conform to NZ welfare standards. Free Trade or not!!!!
- Fiona Gardner, 9:01 AM on Sat 10 Apr 2010
it's cruel, immoral and unnecessary! I had 2 pet pigs when we lived on a lifestyle block. They were both more intelligent than our dog. To confime animals like that is just plain wrong. You must also ensure that any imported pig product is farmed to the same standards or not allowed in. In no way should good farming in NZ be penalised and subject to unfair competition.
- Harry Young, 8:51 AM on Sat 10 Apr 2010
It is absolutey digusting the way these pigs are treated. I am no longer going to purchase any meat or products, until there enviroment changes for the better!! Im ashamed that our country allows farmers to do this. I hope you can make a change for the better. I would rather pay more for pork etc if this means the pigs will have a better enviroment.
- Lauren , 8:19 AM on Sat 10 Apr 2010
it is cruel beyond belief and totally needless. Pigs are intelligent sentient beings who have the right to live their lives naturally and not be imprisoned and tortured, only to die horribly in pain so that human animals can consume their corpses. I have been vegetarian for 30 years and vegan for the last 12 months. I belive that eventually everyone will be vegan - we have already abolished the legal slavery of humans - and our fellow animals will be free in the future as well. Humans do not need to eat other animals (or the products of live animals) to survive, but they are lazy and greedy beings who do so out of habit and lack of respect for the creatures whose suffering they are personally responsible for. I urge you to ban the foul practices of sow and farrowing crates in factory pig farms immediately. It is high time that New Zealanders made a stand on animal welfare and rights - we have profitted from their pain and suffering for long enough. The disgusting way that pigs are factory farmed is in urgent need of review and abolition, so lets start there. Thank you for your action on this important issue.
- Sue Yates, 8:14 AM on Sat 10 Apr 2010
Hi John, how are you going? I come from a household who have already either started to buy freerange pigs or omit from eating swine due to the exposed knowledge